Exam practice

Why did I lose the mark?

Every entry below is a realistic student answer that scores badly, the precise reason it loses marks, and the version that scores. Read these before your exam — recognising your own habit here is worth more than another hour of reading notes.

Pure Mathematics 1

A student wrote · Quadratics(x+3)2=x2+9
Why it loses marksSquaring a bracket is not the same as squaring each term. (x+3)2=x2+6x+9, and that missing 6x is the whole reason completing the square works.
The answer that scores(x+3)2=x2+6x+9. Expand whenever you write a completed square, and the error cannot survive.
Revise this topicQuadratics
A student wrote · Quadraticsx2+6x+1=(x+3)2+1
Why it loses marksThe bracket contributes 9, not 0. Half of 6 is 3, and 32=9 has to be taken back off the constant.
The answer that scoresx2+6x+1=(x+3)2−9+1=(x+3)2−8.
Revise this topicQuadratics
A student wrote · Quadraticsx2−3x−10>0, so −2<x<5.
Why it loses marksThat is the solution of the opposite inequality. The parabola is above the axis outside its roots, so >0 selects the outside.
The answer that scoresx<−2 or x>5. Test x=0: 0−0−10=−10>0 is false, and 0 lies between −2 and 5, so the middle is not in the solution.
Revise this topicQuadratics
A student wrote · Quadraticsx2+kx+9=0 has a repeated root when k2−9=0, so k=3 or k=−3.
Why it loses marksThe discriminant is b2−4ac, and both the 4 and the c matter. With a=1 and c=9 the discriminant is k2−36, not k2−9.
The answer that scoresk2−4(1)(9)=k2−36=0, so k=6 or k=−6.
Revise this topicQuadratics
A student wrote · Quadraticsx−6x+8=0 gives x=2 or x=4, so x=2 or x=4.
Why it loses marksThe substitution solves for x, not for x. Each value has to be squared, and both are positive so neither is rejected.
The answer that scoresx=2 gives x=4, and x=4 gives x=16.
Revise this topicQuadratics
A student wrote · Quadraticsy=x+1 with x2+y2=25 gives x=3, x=−4, y=4, y=−3.
Why it loses marksThe four numbers are right but they are not paired, and the pairs are what the question asks for. The point (3,−3) is on neither the line nor the circle.
The answer that scoresThe solutions are (3,4) and (−4,−3).
Revise this topicQuadratics
A student wrote · Functionsf(x)=x2 for all real x, so f−1(x)=x.
Why it loses marksOn the whole real line f is not one-one, so it has no inverse at all. Restricting the domain to x≥0 is what makes the inverse exist, and that restriction must be stated.
The answer that scoresFor f(x)=x2 with domain x≥0, f−1(x)=x with domain x≥0.
Revise this topicFunctions
A student wrote · Functionsgf(x) means f(g(x)).
Why it loses marksThe function nearest the x acts first. gf(x) applies f first and then g, which is the opposite of what the letters look like in order.
The answer that scoresWith f(x)=3x−1 and g(x)=x2+2: gf(x)=g(3x−1)=9x2−6x+3, while fg(x)=f(x2+2)=3x2+5.
Revise this topicFunctions
A student wrote · Functionsf(x)=9−2x for x≥1, so the range is f(x)≥7.
Why it loses marksThe rule decreases as x increases, so the smallest input gives the largest output. The range runs downwards from 7, not upwards.
The answer that scoresf(1)=7 is the largest output, so the range is f(x)≤7.
Revise this topicFunctions
A student wrote · Functionsy=f(x+3) moves the graph 3 units to the right.
Why it loses marksA change inside the bracket acts on the input and does the opposite of what the sign suggests. The value f(4) is now reached at x=1, so the graph has moved to the left.
The answer that scoresy=f(x+3) is a translation of 3 units in the negative x-direction.
Revise this topicFunctions
A student wrote · Functionsy=f(2x) doubles every x-coordinate.
Why it loses marksIt is the other way round: f(2x) reaches a given height twice as quickly, so each x-coordinate is halved. y=2f(x) is the one that doubles, and it doubles y-coordinates.
The answer that scoresy=f(2x) is a stretch parallel to the x-axis with scale factor 12.
Revise this topicFunctions
A student wrote · Coordinate GeometryThe gradient of the line through (2,3) and (6,6) is 6−26−3=43.
Why it loses marksThe coordinates have been subtracted the wrong way round. Gradient is rise over run, so the difference in y goes on the top and the difference in x on the bottom.
The answer that scoresThe gradient is 6−36−2=34. The run is 4 and the rise is 3.
Revise this topicCoordinate Geometry
A student wrote · Coordinate GeometryThe circle (x−3)2+(y+4)2=36 has centre (−3,4) and radius 36.
Why it loses marksBoth numbers have been read wrongly. The sign inside each bracket is the opposite of the coordinate it gives, and the number on the right is r2, not r.
The answer that scoresThe centre is (3,−4) and the radius is 36=6.
Revise this topicCoordinate Geometry
A student wrote · Coordinate GeometryA line perpendicular to y=2x+1 has gradient −2.
Why it loses marksChanging the sign is not enough. Perpendicular gradients multiply to −1, so each is the negative reciprocal of the other.
The answer that scoresThe gradient is −12, because 2×−12=−1.
Revise this topicCoordinate Geometry
A student wrote · Coordinate GeometryThe line y=x+k is a tangent to the circle x2+y2=8 when k=4.
Why it loses marksSetting the discriminant to zero gives k2=16, which has two solutions. The line can touch the circle on either side, so both values are needed.
The answer that scoresk=4 or k=−4. The tangent lines are y=x+4 and y=x−4.
Revise this topicCoordinate Geometry
A student wrote · Coordinate GeometryThe distance between (1,1) and (4,5) is 3+4=7.
Why it loses marksAdding the run and the rise does not give the distance. The distance is the hypotenuse of the right-angled triangle whose legs are the run and the rise.
The answer that scoresAB=32+42=25=5.
Revise this topicCoordinate Geometry
A student wrote · Circular MeasureA sector of radius 6 cm and angle 60∘ has arc length 6×60=360 cm.
Why it loses marksThe formula s=rθ needs the angle in radians. 60∘ is not 60 radians, and the answer is larger than the whole circle, which is the giveaway.
The answer that scores60∘=π3 radians, so s=6×π3=2π=6.28 cm.
Revise this topicCircular Measure
A student wrote · Circular MeasureThe perimeter of a sector of radius 8 cm and angle 1.5 radians is 12 cm.
Why it loses marksThat is the arc on its own. The boundary of a sector is the arc together with the two radii that close it.
The answer that scoresP=rθ+2r=8×1.5+16=28 cm.
Revise this topicCircular Measure
A student wrote · Circular MeasureThe area of a sector of radius 4 cm and angle 3 radians is 12×4×3=6 cm2.
Why it loses marksThe radius is squared in the area formula. Using r instead of r2 gives an answer four times too small here.
The answer that scoresA=12×42×3=24 cm2.
Revise this topicCircular Measure
A student wrote · Circular MeasureThe area of the segment cut off by a chord of a circle of radius 6 cm and angle π3 is 6π=18.8 cm2.
Why it loses marksThat is the area of the sector. The segment stops at the chord, so the triangle formed by the two radii and the chord has to come off.
The answer that scores6π−93=18.85−15.59=3.26 cm2 to 3 significant figures.
Revise this topicCircular Measure
A student wrote · Circular Measure1 radian is 180∘.
Why it loses marksπ radians is 180∘. The conversion factor has been confused with the unit itself, which makes every answer about 3 times too large.
The answer that scores1 radian is 180π=57.3∘ to 3 significant figures.
Revise this topicCircular Measure
A student wrote · Trigonometrysin−1x means 1sinx, so sin−12=1sin2.
Why it loses marksThe −1 in sin−1x marks an inverse function, exactly as it does in f−1(x). The reciprocal of the sine is a different function altogether and is not in this syllabus.
The answer that scoressin−1x is the angle whose sine is x, so sin−1(12)=30∘. There is no angle whose sine is 2, so sin−12 has no value.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · Trigonometrysin230∘ means sin(30∘)2=sin900∘.
Why it loses marksThe index sits on the function value, not on the angle. sin2θ is the conventional shorthand for (sinθ)2, and the square applies to the sine, never to the angle.
The answer that scoressin230∘=(12)2=14.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · TrigonometrySolving cos2x=12 for 0≤x≤2π gives x=π6 and x=5π6.
Why it loses marksThe interval for x has been used for 2x. Since x runs from 0 to 2π, the angle 2x runs from 0 to 4π, which contains twice as many solutions.
The answer that scores2x=π3,5π3,7π3,11π3, so x=π6,5π6,7π6,11π6.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · Trigonometrycos150∘=32, because cos30∘=32.
Why it loses marksThe size is right but the sign is wrong. 150∘ is in the second quadrant, where the cosine is negative, and the minus sign has been dropped between the related angle and the answer.
The answer that scorescos150∘=−cos30∘=−32.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · Trigonometrysinx=1.5 has the solution x=sin−11.5.
Why it loses marksThe sine of an angle never leaves the interval from −1 to 1, so no angle has a sine of 1.5. A calculator's error message is telling you something mathematical, not something mechanical.
The answer that scoresThe equation has no solutions, because −1≤sinx≤1 for every value of x.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · Trigonometrysinθcosθcosθ=sinθ is always true, so the cosine can be cancelled safely.
Why it loses marksCancelling divides by cosθ, which is zero at θ=90∘ and θ=270∘. At those angles the original expression is undefined, so the simplified version is not equivalent to it everywhere.
The answer that scoresThe simplification holds only where cosθ≠0, that is for θ≠90∘+180∘n. State that restriction, or keep the expression as it stands.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · SeriesThe nth term of a geometric progression is arn.
Why it loses marksThe index is one less than the position, because the first term is a itself and no multiplication by r has happened yet. Using arn gives the term after the one you want.
The answer that scoresun=arn−1. For 3, 6, 12, ... the 4th term is 3×23=24, not 3×24=48.
Revise this topicSeries
A student wrote · SeriesThe nth term of an arithmetic progression is a+nd.
Why it loses marksTo reach the nth term you add d one time fewer than n. Writing a+nd gives the (n+1)th term.
The answer that scoresun=a+(n−1)d. For 7, 12, 17, ... the 20th term is 7+19(5)=102.
Revise this topicSeries
A student wrote · SeriesS∞=a1−r can be used for any geometric progression.
Why it loses marksThe formula comes from letting rn→0, which only happens when |r|<1. For r=2 or r=−1 the terms do not shrink and the sum has no limit, so the formula produces a meaningless number.
The answer that scoresUse it only when |r|<1. For 5, 10, 20, 40, ... the progression diverges, so there is no sum to infinity.
Revise this topicSeries
A student wrote · Series(62)=6!2!=360.
Why it loses marksThe (n−r)! in the denominator has been dropped. (nr) counts selections, not arrangements, and dividing only by r! counts arrangements instead.
The answer that scores(62)=6!2!4!=7202×24=15.
Revise this topicSeries
A student wrote · SeriesIn (1+3x)6 the coefficient of x2 is 9, because 32=9.
Why it loses marksThe binomial coefficient has been left out. The term in x2 is (62)(3x)2, so the 15 and the 9 both belong in the answer.
The answer that scores(62)(3x)2=15×9x2=135x2, so the coefficient is 135.
Revise this topicSeries
A student wrote · SeriesFor a geometric progression with u3=12 and u6=96, the common ratio is 96÷12=8.
Why it loses marksThree steps of the progression separate the two terms, so the ratio between them is r3, not r. The cube root is the common ratio, not the quotient.
The answer that scoresu6u3=r3=8, so r=2. Then a=1222=3.
Revise this topicSeries
A student wrote · DifferentiationThe derivative of 5 is 5, because the number stays the same.
Why it loses marksA derivative is a gradient. The graph of y=5 is a horizontal line, and a horizontal line has gradient 0. Constants do not change when x changes, so they contribute nothing to the rate of change.
The answer that scoresddx(5)=0. Only terms containing x survive differentiation.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · Differentiationddx(x1/2)=12x1/2.
Why it loses marksThe power has not been reduced. The rule says multiply by the old power and then take one away from it, so the new power is 12−1=−12.
The answer that scores12x−1/2, which can also be written 12x. It is positive for x>0 because the square root curve is rising.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · DifferentiationThe normal to a curve at a point has the same gradient as the tangent there.
Why it loses marksThe normal is perpendicular to the tangent, so its gradient is the negative reciprocal. Using the tangent gradient again produces a line that crosses the curve instead of meeting it at right angles.
The answer that scoresIf the tangent gradient is 9, the normal gradient is −19, because m1m2=−1 for perpendicular lines.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · DifferentiationTo find the nature of a stationary point, substitute the x-value into dydx.
Why it loses marksAt a stationary point dydx is 0 by definition, so that substitution tells you nothing. The test uses the rate of change of the gradient, which is the second derivative.
The answer that scoresSubstitute into d2ydx2. A negative value means a maximum and a positive value means a minimum; if it is zero, test the sign of dydx either side.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · DifferentiationFor y=(2x+5)3, dydx=3(2x+5)2.
Why it loses marksThe chain rule was half applied: the outside was differentiated but the inside was not. The bracket 2x+5 differentiates to 2, and that factor must be multiplied in.
The answer that scoresdydx=3(2x+5)2×2=6(2x+5)2. Expand the bracket if you want to check it: y=8x3+60x2+150x+125 differentiates to 24x2+120x+150, which is 6(2x+5)2.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · DifferentiationThe rate of change of the area of a circle is dAdr=2πr.
Why it loses marksThat is the rate of change of the area with respect to the radius, not with respect to time. A question about a circle growing asks for dAdt, which needs the chain rule with the given drdt.
The answer that scoresdAdt=dAdr×drdt=2πr×drdt. With r=5 and drdt=0.4 the rate is 4π square centimetres per second.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · Integration∫x3dx=x43+c.
Why it loses marksThe division is by the new power, not the old one. Dividing by 3 instead of 4 gives an answer whose derivative is 43x3, not x3.
The answer that scores∫x3dx=x44+c. The power rises by one and you divide by what it became.
Revise this topicIntegration
A student wrote · Integration∫(2x+3)4dx=(2x+3)55+c.
Why it loses marksThe division by a=2 is missing. Differentiating (2x+3)55 gives 2(2x+3)4 by the chain rule, which is twice the integrand.
The answer that scores∫(2x+3)4dx=(2x+3)510+c. Divide by the new power and by the coefficient of x inside the bracket.
Revise this topicIntegration
A student wrote · IntegrationThe integral of 2x+1 is x2+x.
Why it loses marksAn indefinite integral is a family of curves, not one curve. Every function of the form x2+x+c has derivative 2x+1, and only a point on the curve can say which one is wanted.
The answer that scores∫(2x+1)dx=x2+x+c, and c is found by substituting a point the curve passes through - c=−4 for the curve through (1,−2).
Revise this topicIntegration
A student wrote · IntegrationThe area between y=x2 and y=x+2 is ∫−12(x2−x−2)dx=−92, so the area is negative.
Why it loses marksThe lower function was subtracted from the upper one the wrong way round. The line is above the curve between x=−1 and x=2, so the line must come first.
The answer that scores∫−12(x+2−x2)dx=92. An area is positive; a negative value means the subtraction was the wrong way round, not that the region is unusual.
Revise this topicIntegration
A student wrote · IntegrationThe volume of revolution about the x-axis is π∫ydx.
Why it loses marksA thin strip of the region becomes a disc of radius y, and the area of that disc is πy2, not πy. Without the square the answer is an area, not a volume.
The answer that scoresV=π∫aby2dx. Square y first, then integrate - for y=x that turns the integral into π∫xdx.
Revise this topicIntegration
A student wrote · Integration∫03(x2−4x)dx=−9, so the area between the curve and the x-axis from x=0 to x=3 is −9.
Why it loses marksOn that interval the curve lies below the x-axis, so the integral counts every strip as negative. The integral is the signed area, not the area.
The answer that scoresThe area is 9 square units. Sketch first, and if the region is below the axis, take the positive value of the integral for the area.
Revise this topicIntegration

Pure Mathematics 3

A student wrote · Algebra|x|=x for every value of x, so |−4|=−4.
Why it loses marksThe modulus is a distance, so it can never be negative. The definition has two cases and the second one is the one that removes the sign: for x<0, |x|=−x.
The answer that scores|−4|=−(−4)=4. More generally |x|=x for x≥0 and |x|=−x for x<0.
Revise this topicAlgebra
A student wrote · AlgebraSquaring both sides of 2x+5<|x+1| to get 4x2+20x+25<x2+2x+1.
Why it loses marksSquaring preserves the direction of an inequality only when both sides are certainly non-negative. The left side here is negative for x<−2.5, so the two inequalities are not equivalent: at x=−5 the original reads −5<4, which is true, while the squared version reads 25<16, which is false.
The answer that scoresSplit at x=−1. For x<−1, 2x+5<−x−1 gives x<−2; for x≥−1 the branch gives x<−4, which is impossible. So x<−2.
Revise this topicAlgebra
A student wrote · AlgebraThe remainder when f(x) is divided by 2x−1 is f(1).
Why it loses marksThe remainder theorem uses the value that makes the divisor zero. Setting 2x−1=0 gives x=12, not x=1.
The answer that scoresDivide by 2x−1: the remainder is f(12).
Revise this topicAlgebra
A student wrote · AlgebraWriting 3x2+3x−9(x+1)2(x−2) as Ax+1+Bx−2.
Why it loses marksA repeated factor needs one fraction for each power. Two constants cannot reproduce a numerator of degree 2 against a denominator of degree 3, and the form mark is lost before any algebra is done.
The answer that scoresThe correct form is Ax+1+B(x+1)2+Cx−2, which here gives 2x+1+3(x+1)2+1x−2.
Revise this topicAlgebra
A student wrote · AlgebraExpanding (1+3x)13 and stopping at 1+x, or leaving the validity as |x|<1.
Why it loses marksThe first two terms are not 'the expansion' unless the question asks for them, and the validity condition belongs to the substituted variable u=3x, not to x itself.
The answer that scores1+x−x2+56x3+⋯, valid for |3x|<1, that is |x|<13.
Revise this topicAlgebra
A student wrote · Logarithmic and Exponential Functionslog26=log22+log24, so the product law lets you split a logarithm of a sum.
Why it loses marksThe product law is logaxy=logax+logay, which is about a product inside the logarithm. There is no law at all for the logarithm of a sum, and log26 is not 1+2.
The answer that scoreslog26 stays as it is. log22+log24=1+2=3, which is log28, not log26.
A student wrote · Logarithmic and Exponential FunctionsFrom log2x+log2(x+2)=3, writing x(x+2)=3.
Why it loses marksThe 3 is the value of the logarithm, so the definition gives x(x+2)=23. Losing the base is the commonest single error in this topic.
The answer that scoresCombine first: log2[x(x+2)]=3, so x(x+2)=8, giving x2+2x−8=0, x=2 or x=−4. The root x=−4 is rejected, so x=2.
A student wrote · Logarithmic and Exponential FunctionsDividing by ln0.5 to solve 0.5x>3 and writing x>ln3ln0.5.
Why it loses marksln0.5 is negative, so dividing by it reverses the direction of the inequality. The arithmetic is right and the inequality sign is wrong.
The answer that scoresxln0.5>ln3 with ln0.5=−0.693, so x<ln3ln0.5=−1.585.
A student wrote · Logarithmic and Exponential FunctionsA graph of lny against x has intercept 1.0986, so the constant k is 1.0986.
Why it loses marksThe linear form is lny=lnk+xlna, so the intercept on the lny axis is lnk. The value of k is the exponential of that intercept.
The answer that scoreslnk=1.0986, so k=e1.0986=3.
A student wrote · Logarithmic and Exponential FunctionsUsing elnx=x for x=−5 to conclude that eln(−5)=−5.
Why it loses marksln(−5) is not defined: the argument of a logarithm must be positive. The inverse relationship only holds for x>0.
The answer that scoresThere is no value of eln(−5), because ln(−5) does not exist. elnx=x holds only for x>0.
A student wrote · Trigonometrysecθ=cos−1θ, so sec0.5=60∘.
Why it loses marksThe reciprocal and the inverse are different functions. secθ is a value, cos−1θ is an angle, and sec0.5 would be 2 if it existed at all - which it does not, since secθ never lies between −1 and 1.
The answer that scoressecθ=1cosθ. So sec60∘=10.5=2, while cos−10.5=60∘ is a different statement entirely.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · Trigonometrysec2θ=1−tan2θ when the angle is obtuse.
Why it loses marksThe identity has no case-by-case version. It comes from dividing sin2θ+cos2θ=1 by cos2θ, and the plus sign is fixed by that division. The quadrant changes the sign of secθ itself, not the sign in the identity.
The answer that scoressec2θ=1+tan2θ for every angle where both sides exist. If θ is obtuse and tanθ=34, then sec2θ=2516 and secθ=−54.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · Trigonometrycos(A+B)=cosAcosB+sinAsinB.
Why it loses marksThe sign is the wrong way round. The cosine expansion reverses the sign inside the bracket, so a plus in the bracket produces a minus in the expansion. Testing with A=B=60∘ shows it: the left side is −12, and the wrong right side gives 14+34=1.
The answer that scorescos(A+B)=cosAcosB−sinAsinB. The plus version, cos(A−B)=cosAcosB+sinAsinB, is the one with the plus on the right.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · TrigonometryDividing sin2θ=cosθ by cosθ to get tan2θ=1.
Why it loses marksThis is illegal when cosθ=0, and it throws away those solutions. It also divides the sin2θ term by cosθ, which is not tan2θ - the angle is different. In 0∘≤θ≤360∘ the division loses θ=90∘ and 270∘.
The answer that scoresWrite sin2θ=2sinθcosθ, move everything to one side and factorise: cosθ(2sinθ−1)=0, so cosθ=0 or sinθ=12.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · Trigonometry3sinθ−4cosθ=5sin(θ+53.13∘).
Why it loses marksThe sign inside the bracket is wrong. Matching Rsin(θ+α) against the expression gives Rcosα=3 and Rsinα=−4, so the sine of α is negative and the bracket must be θ−α. Check at θ=0: the original is −4, while 5sin53.13∘=+4.
The answer that scores3sinθ−4cosθ=5sin(θ−53.13∘), since tanα=43 with α=53.13∘.
Revise this topicTrigonometry
A student wrote · Differentiationddx(ln2x)=12x.
Why it loses marksThe chain rule was applied to the outside function and then forgotten. ln2x=ln2+lnx, and ln2 is a constant, so the derivative is 1x. The chain rule gives the same thing: 12x×2=1x.
The answer that scoresddx(ln2x)=1x. More generally ddx(lnax)=1x for any positive constant a.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · Differentiationddx(e3x)=e3x.
Why it loses marksThe exponential differentiates to itself only when the exponent is exactly x. Here the inside function is 3x, whose derivative is 3, and the chain rule requires that factor.
The answer that scoresddx(e3x)=3e3x. Check it numerically: at x=0 the gradient of e3x is 3, not 1.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · Differentiationddx(x2lnx)=2x×1x=2.
Why it loses marksThe derivatives of the two factors have been multiplied. The product rule adds two terms, each of which keeps one original factor: udvdx+vdudx. The wrong answer also happens to be constant, which is impossible for a curve that is clearly not a straight line.
The answer that scoresddx(x2lnx)=x2×1x+lnx×2x=x+2xlnx.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · DifferentiationDifferentiating x2+y2=9 to get 2x+2y=0.
Why it loses marksThe y2 term was differentiated as though y were the variable of differentiation. Because y is a function of x, the chain rule contributes a factor of dydx, and without it the equation cannot give a gradient at all.
The answer that scores2x+2ydydx=0, so dydx=−xy. At the point (3,0) on x2+y2=9 the tangent is vertical, and −xy correctly has no value there.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · DifferentiationThe normal to a curve at a point where the gradient is 3 has gradient 3.
Why it loses marksThe normal is perpendicular to the tangent, so its gradient is the negative reciprocal, −13. Writing the tangent's gradient again gives a line that lies along the curve's direction instead of across it.
The answer that scoresIf the tangent has gradient m, the normal has gradient −1m. For m=3 the normal has gradient −13, and 3×(−13)=−1, which is the test for perpendicular lines.
Revise this topicDifferentiation
A student wrote · Integration∫e2xdx=e2x+c
Why it loses marksDifferentiating e2x brings a factor of 2 down from the exponent. The integral needs the reciprocal factor to cancel it, exactly as the 1a in the standard result says.
The answer that scores∫e2xdx=12e2x+c. Differentiating 12e2x gives e2x, which is the check.
Revise this topicIntegration
A student wrote · Integration∫12x+3dx=ln|2x+3|+c
Why it loses marksThe derivative of the bottom is 2, not 1, so the logarithm result brings a factor 12. This is the same missing factor as the exponential case.
The answer that scores∫12x+3dx=12ln|2x+3|+c.
Revise this topicIntegration
A student wrote · Integration∫1x2+9dx=tan−1x3+c
Why it loses marksThe standard result carries 1a in front, and here a=3. Without it the derivative of the answer is three times too big.
The answer that scores∫1x2+9dx=13tan−1x3+c.
Revise this topicIntegration
A student wrote · Integration∫sin2xdx=sin3x3+c
Why it loses marksThat is the power rule applied to sinx as though it were a variable. The square has to be removed with the double-angle identity before anything can be integrated.
The answer that scores∫sin2xdx=12∫(1−cos2x)dx=12x−14sin2x+c.
Revise this topicIntegration
A student wrote · IntegrationIn ∫xsin2xdx, take u=sin2x
Why it loses marksDifferentiating sin2x gives 2cos2x, which is no simpler, and the integral you are left with is worse than the one you started with.
The answer that scoresTake u=x, so dudx=1 and v=−12cos2x. Then ∫xsin2xdx=−12xcos2x+14sin2x+c.
Revise this topicIntegration
A student wrote · Numerical Solution of Equationsf(2)=−1 and f(3)=16, so the root is 2.5.
Why it loses marksA sign change locates the root inside an interval; it does not find it. 2.5 is the midpoint of the interval and is not a root of the equation.
The answer that scoresThe root lies between 2 and 3. The iteration xn+1=2xn+53 from x0=2 gives 2.095 correct to 3 decimal places.
A student wrote · Numerical Solution of EquationsFor x3−2x−5=0, use the iteration xn+1=2xn+5.
Why it loses marksThat is x3 on its own, not x. An iterative formula needs a single x on the left, so the rearrangement has to finish by taking the cube root.
The answer that scoresx3=2x+5 gives x=2x+53, so xn+1=2xn+53.
A student wrote · Numerical Solution of EquationsStop at x1=2.08008 and give that as the root.
Why it loses marksOne approximation says nothing about accuracy. The sequence has to settle: two successive values that agree at the accuracy asked for, and only then is the answer known to that many figures.
The answer that scoresIterate until two successive values round to the same 3 decimal places: x4=2.09450 and x5=2.09454 both round to 2.095, so the root is 2.095.
A student wrote · Numerical Solution of Equationsf(1.4)=0.7 and f(1.5)=0.9, both positive, so there is no root between 1.4 and 1.5.
Why it loses marksA sign change proves a root exists, but the absence of one proves nothing. The curve can dip below the axis and come back up, crossing it twice inside the interval.
The answer that scoresThe test can only confirm a root. To rule one out you would need to know the shape of the curve, or examine smaller intervals inside the range and check each of those.
A student wrote · Numerical Solution of EquationsUse the iteration xn+1=cosxn with the calculator in degree mode.
Why it loses marksIn degrees the equation being solved is not x=cosx but x=cos(x∘), which has a different root. The iteration still converges, which is what makes the error hard to spot.
The answer that scoresSwitch to radians. The root of x=cosx is 0.739085 to six decimal places, and the degree-mode sequence drifts towards 0.9998, which solves a different equation.
A student wrote · VectorsAB→=OA→−OB→, so AB→ points from B to A.
Why it loses marksThe displacement from A to B is the position vector of B minus the position vector of A. Subtracting the other way round gives the negative vector, which reverses the direction and changes every later answer.
The answer that scoresAB→=OB→−OA→=b→−a→, and BA→=−AB→.
Revise this topicVectors
A student wrote · VectorsThe angle between the lines is cos−1a→·c→|a→||c→|, where a→ and c→ are the position vectors of points on the two lines.
Why it loses marksThe angle between two lines depends only on their directions, and position vectors depend on where the origin happens to be.
The answer that scoresUse the direction vectors: cosθ=d→1·d→2|d→1||d→2|.
Revise this topicVectors
A student wrote · Vectors|a→+b→|=|a→|+|b→|.
Why it loses marksAdding the lengths of two journeys is only the length of the direct route when the two vectors point the same way. In general the direct route is shorter, which is the triangle inequality.
The answer that scoresAdd the components first, then find the magnitude. For a→=(4−13) and b→=(−251), a→+b→=(244) and |a→+b→|=6, while |a→|+|b→|=10.58.
Revise this topicVectors
A student wrote · VectorsThe lines are parallel because their direction vectors look similar, so they never meet.
Why it loses marks"Similar" is not "a scalar multiple". Parallelism is an exact test: one direction vector must equal a constant times the other, with the same constant in every component.
The answer that scores(339)=3(113), so those two are parallel; (134) and (−234) are not, because no single constant works for all three components.
Revise this topicVectors
A student wrote · VectorsTwo lines that fail to meet are skew.
Why it loses marksSkew means not parallel and not meeting. Two parallel lines also never meet, but they are parallel, not skew. The decision is a two-part test and both parts must be shown.
The answer that scoresCheck the direction vectors first. If they are not multiples, solve two of the three component equations and substitute into the third: agreement means the lines intersect, disagreement means they are skew.
Revise this topicVectors
A student wrote · VectorsA unit vector in the direction of a→ is a→ divided by the number of components, or a→ left as it is because the fractions are awkward.
Why it loses marksA unit vector must have magnitude exactly 1. Dividing by 3 when the magnitude is 7 gives a vector of magnitude 73, and leaving a→ unchanged leaves its original magnitude.
The answer that scoresDivide by the magnitude: for a→=2i→+3j→+6k→, |a→|=7, so the unit vector is 17(2i→+3j→+6k→).
Revise this topicVectors
A student wrote · Differential Equationslny=x2+c, so y=ex2+c.
Why it loses marksThe constant is added inside the logarithm, so exponentiating turns it into a multiplier, not an additive term. ex2+c=ecex2, and ec is just a new constant.
The answer that scoresy=Aex2 with A=ec, which is then fixed by the initial condition.
Revise this topicDifferential Equations
A student wrote · Differential EquationsSubstituting y = 3 when x = 0 into dydx=2xy gives 0 = 6, so something is wrong.
Why it loses marksThe initial condition is a statement about the solution, not about the differential equation. Substituting it into the equation tells you nothing and destroys the information you need.
The answer that scoresIntegrate first to get y=Aex2, then substitute x = 0 and y = 3 to find A = 3.
Revise this topicDifferential Equations
A student wrote · Differential EquationsOne integration, so write a constant on each side: lny+c1=x2+c2.
Why it loses marksTwo constants that differ by a fixed amount can be combined into one, so the second carries no extra information. Carrying both invites an algebra slip and hides which constant you are finding.
The answer that scoresWrite a single constant on the right: lny=x2+c.
Revise this topicDifferential Equations
A student wrote · Differential Equations∫13y+1dy=ln|3y+1|.
Why it loses marksDifferentiating ln|3y+1| gives 33y+1, which is three times too big. The linear coefficient has to come out as a factor of 13.
The answer that scores∫13y+1dy=13ln|3y+1|.
Revise this topicDifferential Equations
A student wrote · Differential EquationsA leaking tank is modelled by dVdt=kV with k positive, because the volume is decreasing.
Why it loses marksThe constant has to carry the sign, and the wording says the volume decreases. Taking k positive with a plus sign builds growth into the model, and no later substitution can repair it.
The answer that scoresdVdt=−kV with k > 0, or dVdt=kV with k < 0 stated explicitly.
Revise this topicDifferential Equations
A student wrote · Differential EquationsThe solution N=50e−0.02t means the substance has gone after 50 years.
Why it loses marksAn exponential decay never reaches zero in finite time: at every finite t the value is positive, however small. "Gone" is not something the model predicts.
The answer that scoresThe model predicts a mass that decreases towards zero without reaching it. The mass halves every ln20.02=34.7 years, for ever.
Revise this topicDifferential Equations
A student wrote · Complex Numbers\arg(−2−2i)=π4, because tan−1(1)=π4.
Why it loses marksπ4 is only the reference angle with the real axis. The point (−2,−2) is in the third quadrant, so the angle from the positive real axis is π4−π=−3π4.
The answer that scores\arg(−2−2i)=−3π4, or 5π4 if the question uses the interval 0≤θ<2π.
Revise this topicComplex Numbers
A student wrote · Complex Numbers|z1+z2|=|z1|+|z2|.
Why it loses marksModuli do not add when the complex numbers do. Take z1=1 and z2=i: |z1+z2|=|1+i|=2, but |z1|+|z2|=2.
The answer that scoresOnly products and quotients behave like that: |z1z2|=|z1||z2| and |z1z2|=|z1||z2|. There is no such rule for a sum.
Revise this topicComplex Numbers
A student wrote · Complex Numbers5+12i=3+2i.
Why it loses marksA non-zero complex number has two square roots. (−3−2i)2=5+12i as well, so giving one root is an incomplete answer.
The answer that scores5+12i=±(3+2i).
Revise this topicComplex Numbers
A student wrote · Complex Numbers(2+3i)(2−3i)=4−9=−5, treating i2 as +1.
Why it loses marksi2=−1, so 3i×(−3i)=−9i2=+9. The product of a complex number and its conjugate is never negative.
The answer that scores(2+3i)(2−3i)=4+9=13=|2+3i|2.
Revise this topicComplex Numbers
A student wrote · Complex NumbersA cubic with real coefficients can have exactly two non-real roots.
Why it loses marksNon-real roots occur in conjugate pairs, so the count of non-real roots is even. A real cubic has three real roots or one real root and a conjugate pair.
The answer that scoresIf 1+2i is a root then 1−2i is also a root, and the third root of a real cubic must be real.
Revise this topicComplex Numbers
A student wrote · Complex NumbersTo divide by 2+i, multiply the numerator by 2−i only.
Why it loses marksMultiplying only the numerator changes the value of the fraction. The conjugate must multiply the numerator and the denominator.
The answer that scoresMultiply top and bottom by 2−i; the denominator becomes (2+i)(2−i)=22+12=5.
Revise this topicComplex Numbers

Mechanics

A student wrote · Forces and EquilibriumR=mg always, so the reaction equals the weight.
Why it loses marksA force with a vertical component changes the reaction. Pulling a block upwards at an angle reduces R below mg; pushing down at an angle increases it.
The answer that scoresResolve perpendicular to the surface. For a block of mass 6 kg pulled by a rope with a 15 N upward component and g=10, R=60−15=45 N, not 60 N.
Revise this topicForces and Equilibrium
A student wrote · Forces and Equilibrium9 N and 12 N at right angles give a resultant of 21 N.
Why it loses marksForces are vectors, so they combine as a triangle rather than as numbers. Adding the magnitudes is only correct when the forces act in the same direction.
The answer that scoresR=92+122=15 N, at tan−1(912)=36.9∘ to the 12 N force.
Revise this topicForces and Equilibrium
A student wrote · Forces and EquilibriumFriction is always equal to μR.
Why it loses marksF=μR is the maximum friction, reached only at limiting equilibrium. A block at rest on rough ground often has far less friction than the maximum available.
The answer that scoresUse F=μR when the body is about to slip; otherwise find F from ∑F=0 and note that F≤μR.
Revise this topicForces and Equilibrium
A student wrote · Forces and EquilibriumThe weight of a book and the normal reaction from the table are a Newton's third law pair.
Why it loses marksThey act on the same body, and a third-law pair acts on two different bodies. The forces in a pair are also of the same type.
The answer that scoresThe third-law partner of the weight of the book is the gravitational force the book exerts on the Earth.
Revise this topicForces and Equilibrium
A student wrote · Forces and EquilibriumA string can push, so a string below a block can hold it up a slope.
Why it loses marksTension in a string can only pull the particle towards the other end. A string that would have to push simply goes slack.
The answer that scoresThrust requires a rod or strut. A string holding a block on a slope must be on the uphill side, pulling the block up the slope.
Revise this topicForces and Equilibrium
A student wrote · Forces and EquilibriumOn a slope I resolved horizontally and vertically and the equations came out wrong.
Why it loses marksResolving horizontally and vertically is not wrong in principle, but it puts both R and F into both equations and invites sign errors. Along and perpendicular to the plane is the method the mark scheme expects.
The answer that scoresTake up the slope and perpendicular to the slope as the two directions, giving F=mgsinθ and R=mgcosθ for a block resting in limiting equilibrium.
Revise this topicForces and Equilibrium
A student wrote · Kinematics in a Straight LineThe particle is at rest, so it must be at the origin.
Why it loses marksBeing at rest is a statement about the velocity, not about the position. A particle can be instantaneously at rest at any point of its path, and a question that asks where it is at that instant expects you to substitute the time back into the displacement.
The answer that scoresSolve v = 0 for the time, then put that time into the expression for s. With s = t cubed minus 6t squared plus 9t the particle is at rest at t = 1, when s = 4 m, and at t = 3, when s = 0.
A student wrote · Kinematics in a Straight LineThe car reaches a speed of 24 m/s in 8 s, so I will use a = 24 m/s squared.
Why it loses marks24 m/s is the final velocity v, not the acceleration. The acceleration is how fast the velocity changes, which here is 24 divided by 8.
The answer that scoresFind a first from v = u + at: 24 = 0 + 8a, so a = 3 m/s squared. Then s = ut + half a t squared = 0 + half times 3 times 64 = 96 m.
A student wrote · Kinematics in a Straight LineI add all the areas under the velocity-time graph to get the displacement.
Why it loses marksArea below the time axis is displacement in the negative direction, so it subtracts. Adding it inflates the displacement and gives the distance travelled instead.
The answer that scoresAdd the areas above the axis and subtract the areas below it for the displacement. Add the magnitudes of all the areas for the distance travelled. Forwards 5 s at 4 m/s then backwards 3 s at 4 m/s gives displacement 8 m and distance 32 m.
A student wrote · Kinematics in a Straight LineIntegrating a = 4t + 2 gives v = 2t squared plus 2t.
Why it loses marksThe constant of integration has been dropped. The acceleration alone does not determine the velocity; you also need to know the velocity at one instant.
The answer that scoresv = 2t squared plus 2t plus c, and v = 3 when t = 0 forces c = 3, so v = 2t squared plus 2t plus 3 and the velocity at t = 2 is 15 m/s.
A student wrote · Kinematics in a Straight LineThe acceleration is negative, so the particle must be slowing down.
Why it loses marksA negative acceleration means the velocity is decreasing, not that the speed is. A particle moving in the negative direction with a negative acceleration has a velocity that is becoming more negative, so its speed is increasing.
The answer that scoresCompare the signs of v and a. The speed decreases when v and a have opposite signs, which is the case Cambridge calls deceleration, and increases when they have the same sign.
A student wrote · MomentumA is moving to the left at 5 m/s, so its momentum is 5m.
Why it loses marksMomentum is mass times velocity, and the velocity is negative when the body moves in the negative direction. Using the speed instead of the velocity gives a momentum with the wrong sign, and every total built on it is wrong.
The answer that scoresTaking to the right as positive, a 3 kg particle moving to the left at 5 m/s has momentum 3(-5) = -15 kg m/s, with magnitude 15 kg m/s.
Revise this topicMomentum
A student wrote · MomentumThe second ball is at rest, so its momentum before the impact is 0.2.
Why it loses marksThe mass has been used in place of the momentum. A stationary body has velocity zero, so its momentum is mass times zero.
The answer that scoresThe momentum of a stationary 0.2 kg ball is 0.2(0) = 0. In the coalescence of a 0.4 kg ball at 6 m/s with it, the equation is 2.4 = 0.6V, giving V = 4 m/s.
Revise this topicMomentum
A student wrote · MomentumThe two bodies coalesce, so 0.4(6) = 0.4V and V = 6 m/s.
Why it loses marksThe mass of the second body has been left out of the right-hand side. Coalescing means one body of the combined mass moving with one velocity, so both masses must appear.
The answer that scores0.4(6) = (0.4 + 0.2)V, so 0.6V = 2.4 and V = 4 m/s. The combined mass is 0.6 kg, not 0.4 kg.
Revise this topicMomentum
A student wrote · MomentumThe velocity comes out as -2 m/s, so I have made a sign error somewhere.
Why it loses marksA negative velocity after an impact is a genuine result: it means the body is now moving in the direction opposite to the positive direction you chose, so it has rebounded. Changing the sign to make it look tidier loses the mark.
The answer that scoresKeep the minus sign and interpret it. A 2 kg particle that hits a stationary 3 kg particle and comes away at -2 m/s has rebounded and is travelling at 2 m/s in the opposite direction to its original motion.
Revise this topicMomentum
A student wrote · MomentumThe kinetic energy before the impact equals the kinetic energy after it, so I can use energy as well as momentum.
Why it loses marksKinetic energy is only conserved in a perfectly elastic impact, which is not part of this syllabus. When bodies coalesce the kinetic energy always decreases, so an energy equation gives the wrong answer.
The answer that scoresUse conservation of momentum only: total momentum before equals total momentum after. For a 0.4 kg ball at 6 m/s coalescing with a stationary 0.2 kg ball, the energy falls from 7.2 J to 4.8 J, while the momentum stays at 2.4 kg m/s.
Revise this topicMomentum
A student wrote · Newton's Laws of MotionThe weight of the block is 6 kg, so the force is 6.
Why it loses marksMass and weight are different quantities with different units. A mass of 6 kg has a weight of 6g newtons, which is 60 N with g=10.
The answer that scoresW=mg=6×10=60 N. It is the 60 N that goes into F=ma, never the 6.
Revise this topicNewton's Laws of Motion
A student wrote · Newton's Laws of MotionThe car is moving at a constant speed, so there are no forces on it.
Why it loses marksNewton's first law says constant velocity means no resultant force, not no forces. The driving force and the resistances are both there and they are equal in size.
The answer that scoresAt constant speed a=0, so the driving force equals the total resistance. That equality is the equation you solve.
Revise this topicNewton's Laws of Motion
A student wrote · Newton's Laws of MotionMoving up a rough plane, I used a=gsinθ−μgcosθ.
Why it loses marksFriction opposes the motion. Moving up the plane, friction acts down the plane, so it adds to the component of the weight instead of subtracting from it.
The answer that scoresMoving up: a=gsinθ+μgcosθ, a deceleration. Moving down: a=gsinθ−μgcosθ. Check which way the particle is moving before choosing.
Revise this topicNewton's Laws of Motion
A student wrote · Newton's Laws of MotionThe tension in the string is equal to the weight of the hanging particle.
Why it loses marksThat would leave no resultant force, so the particle would not accelerate. While the system is moving, the tension differs from the weight on both sides.
The answer that scoresFor the descending mass T=m1(g−a), which is less than m1g; for the ascending one T=m2(g+a), which is more than m2g. Only if the system is at rest is T=mg.
Revise this topicNewton's Laws of Motion
A student wrote · Newton's Laws of MotionOn a slope, R=mg.
Why it loses marksThe reaction is perpendicular to the surface, so it balances only the component of the weight perpendicular to the surface, which is mgcosθ.
The answer that scoresPerpendicular to the plane, R=mgcosθ. On a slope at 30° that is about 0.87mg, and using mg would make the friction μR too big.
Revise this topicNewton's Laws of Motion
A student wrote · Newton's Laws of MotionIn the car and trailer question I used the trailer's resistance in the whole-system equation and again in the car's equation.
Why it loses marksEach resistance belongs to one body and appears once. The whole-system equation already accounts for every resistance on every part of the system.
The answer that scoresUse the whole-system equation for a, then take one body alone - the trailer is easier - and put only the forces on that body into its equation.
Revise this topicNewton's Laws of Motion
A student wrote · Energy, Work and PowerThe block moves 5 m up a plane at 30°, so its gain in potential energy is mg×5.
Why it loses marksh in mgh is the vertical height, not the distance along the slope. The block rises 5sin30∘=2.5 m.
The answer that scoresGain in potential energy =mg×5sin30∘=2.5mg. The distance along the plane is only used for the work done against friction.
Revise this topicEnergy, Work and Power
A student wrote · Energy, Work and PowerA force of 50 N at 60° to the motion over 8 m does 50×8=400 J of work.
Why it loses marksOnly the component of the force along the motion does work, and that component is 50cos60∘=25 N. The other component is perpendicular to the displacement and does no work.
The answer that scoresW=Fdcosθ=50×8×cos60∘=200 J.
Revise this topicEnergy, Work and Power
A student wrote · Energy, Work and PowerThe normal reaction pushes the block up the slope, so it does work as well as the weight.
Why it loses marksThe normal reaction is perpendicular to the surface, and the block moves along the surface, so the angle between the force and the displacement is 90°. cos90∘=0.
The answer that scoresThe normal reaction does no work. On a smooth slide it does not appear in the energy equation at all, which is why a curved smooth slide is no harder than a straight one.
Revise this topicEnergy, Work and Power
A student wrote · Energy, Work and PowerA sledge slides down a rough slope, so mgh=12mv2.
Why it loses marksFriction has done work against the motion, so some of the potential energy has gone into heating the surfaces. The speed at the bottom is less than 2gh.
The answer that scoresmgh=12mv2+Fd, where F is the friction and d is the distance slid along the slope. The missing energy is exactly Fd.
Revise this topicEnergy, Work and Power
A student wrote · Energy, Work and PowerA car develops 30 kW at 15 m/s, so the driving force is 30×15=450 N.
Why it loses marksP=Fv rearranges to F=Pv, not Pv. The power must also be in watts, so 30 kW is 30000 W.
The answer that scoresF=3000015=2000 N. Multiplying instead of dividing gives 450 N, less than a quarter of the force actually needed, so the size of the answer alone should send you back to the formula.
Revise this topicEnergy, Work and Power
A student wrote · Energy, Work and PowerThe engine works at 9 kW, so the power is 9 W.
Why it loses marksA kilowatt is a thousand watts. Leaving the power in kW changes every force and acceleration that follows from it.
The answer that scores9 kW=9000 W. Convert before using P=Fv or P=Wt, and keep one unit for the whole calculation.
Revise this topicEnergy, Work and Power

Probability & Statistics

A student wrote · Representation of DataThe frequency density of the class 30<t≤40 is 30, because 30 observations lie in that class.
Why it loses marksThe vertical axis of a histogram is frequency density, not frequency. The 30 observations are the area of the bar, so the height is the area divided by the width.
The answer that scoresFrequency density =3010=3. The bar has height 3 and width 10, and its area is the 30 observations.
Revise this topicRepresentation of Data
A student wrote · Representation of Dataσ=Σx2n−x¯2
Why it loses marksThat expression is the variance, σ2. The standard deviation is its square root, and leaving the answer as a variance loses the final mark.
The answer that scoresWith Σx2n−x¯2=49, the variance is 49 and the standard deviation is 49=7.
Revise this topicRepresentation of Data
A student wrote · Representation of DataThe coding subtracted 50 from every value, so I subtracted 50 from the standard deviation as well.
Why it loses marksSubtracting a constant moves every value by the same amount, so it shifts the mean but leaves the spread exactly as it was.
The answer that scoresThe standard deviation is unchanged by the coding; only the mean moves, by adding 50 back. Multiplying by a constant is the coding that would change the standard deviation.
Revise this topicRepresentation of Data
A student wrote · Representation of DataThe median of the grouped data is the midpoint of the middle class.
Why it loses marksThe midpoint of a class is a representative value for that class, not the median. The median is the value with half the observations below it, and it usually falls somewhere inside the middle class.
The answer that scoresFind the median position n2, then read across from that cumulative frequency on the graph and down to the value axis. With 80 observations the median is at cumulative frequency 40, not at the middle of the middle class.
Revise this topicRepresentation of Data
A student wrote · Representation of DataI compared the two sets by writing: 'the mean of A is 12 and the mean of B is 9'.
Why it loses marksThat is two numbers, not a comparison. There is no comparison word, no unit, and nothing about spread.
The answer that scores'The mean of A is 12 minutes, compared with 9 minutes for B, so on average A is slower. The standard deviations are 3 minutes and 1.5 minutes, so the times in A are also more variable than those in B.'
Revise this topicRepresentation of Data
A student wrote · Permutations and CombinationsThe number of ways of choosing a committee of 3 from 7 people is 7×6×5=210.
Why it loses marksThat is the number of ordered selections. A committee does not have an order, and every committee has been counted 3! = 6 times, once for each order of its three members.
The answer that scores7C3=7!3!4!=2106=35 committees.
A student wrote · Permutations and CombinationsFor two particular people who must not stand next to each other in a line of 6, I answered 5!×2=240.
Why it loses marks240 is the number of arrangements in which they ARE next to each other. The question asks for the arrangements in which they are apart, which is the complement of that.
The answer that scores6!−5!×2=720−240=480 arrangements.
A student wrote · Permutations and CombinationsThe letters of BALLOON can be arranged in 7!=5040 ways.
Why it loses marksSwapping the two Ls, or the two Os, produces the same word, so 5040 counts every word four times over.
The answer that scores7!2!2!=50404=1260 different arrangements.
A student wrote · Permutations and CombinationsA committee of 3 from 5 men and 4 women, with at least one woman, is 4C1×5C2=40.
Why it loses marksThat counts only the committees with exactly one woman. The committees with 2 women and with 3 women also satisfy 'at least one', and they have been left out.
The answer that scores40+4C2×5C1+4C3=40+30+4=74. The complement gives the same answer: 9C3−5C3=84−10=74.
A student wrote · Permutations and CombinationsThe number of ways of arranging 5 people in a line, with two particular people together, is 5!=120.
Why it loses marksOnce the pair is glued together there are only 4 objects to arrange, not 5, and the pair itself has 2 orders. Both corrections are needed.
The answer that scores4!×2!=24×2=48 arrangements.
A student wrote · ProbabilityThe probability that two fair dice score a total of 7 is 111, because there are 11 possible totals.
Why it loses marksThe totals are not equally likely. A total of 7 happens in six ways and a total of 2 in only one, so the equally likely outcomes are the 36 pairs of faces.
The answer that scoresP(total=7)=636=16.
Revise this topicProbability
A student wrote · ProbabilityTwo counters are taken without replacement, so P(both red)=58×58=2564.
Why it loses marksWithout replacement the second probability is conditional. One red counter has gone, so only 4 of the remaining 7 counters are red.
The answer that scoresP(both red)=58×47=2056=514.
Revise this topicProbability
A student wrote · ProbabilityA and B are mutually exclusive, so they must be independent.
Why it loses marksMutually exclusive means the events cannot both happen, so P(A∩B)=0. Independence needs P(A∩B)=P(A)×P(B), which is not 0 when both probabilities are greater than 0.
The answer that scoresWith P(A)=0.3 and P(B)=0.4, independence would need P(A∩B)=0.12. It is 0, so the events are dependent, and the two ideas are opposites here.
Revise this topicProbability
A student wrote · ProbabilityP(A∣B) and P(B∣A) are the same thing.
Why it loses marksThe bar decides which group the sample space is restricted to. In the table of 60 students, P(boy∣walks)=1824 but P(walks∣boy)=1830.
The answer that scoresP(A∣B)=P(A∩B)P(B) and P(B∣A)=P(A∩B)P(A). They agree only when P(A)=P(B).
Revise this topicProbability
A student wrote · ProbabilityFor a bag of 3 red and 2 blue counters, the probability of at least one red is 310+310=35.
Why it loses marksOne of the three routes containing red has been missed, or a route counted twice: the routes are RR, RB and BR.
The answer that scoresP(at least one red)=1−P(BB)=1−110=910.
Revise this topicProbability
A student wrote · Discrete Random VariablesThe number of red counters in 5 counters drawn without replacement from a bag is a binomial variable.
Why it loses marksWithout replacement the probability of a red counter changes after every draw, so the trials are not independent and p is not constant. Those are two of the four conditions for a binomial model.
The answer that scoresA binomial model needs a constant probability on every trial. Here p falls from 820 to 719 to 618, so the variable is not binomial.
Revise this topicDiscrete Random Variables
A student wrote · Discrete Random VariablesVar(X)=∑x2P(X=x).
Why it loses marksThat sum is E(X2), not the variance. The variance is the mean of the squares minus the square of the mean.
The answer that scoresVar(X)=E(X2)−{E(X)}2. For a fair die, 916−12.25=2.9167.
Revise this topicDiscrete Random Variables
A student wrote · Discrete Random VariablesFor X~Geo(0.2) the expected number of trials is np, and I used E(X)=1p for the binomial.
Why it loses marksThe two means belong to different models. np counts successes in a fixed number of trials; 1p counts the trials until the first success.
The answer that scoresFor B(n,p), E(X)=np; for Geo(p), E(X)=1p. With p=0.2 the geometric mean is 5 trials.
Revise this topicDiscrete Random Variables
A student wrote · Discrete Random VariablesP(X≥2)=1−P(X=2).
Why it loses marks'At least 2' excludes 0 and 1, so both of those terms have to come out of the complement - not just the term for 2.
The answer that scoresP(X≥2)=1−P(X≤1)=1−P(X=0)−P(X=1).
Revise this topicDiscrete Random Variables
A student wrote · Discrete Random VariablesThe distribution is B(0.15,20), with 0.15 trials and 20 successes.
Why it loses marksThe order of the two numbers in B(n,p) is fixed by the notation: the number of trials comes first, the probability of success second.
The answer that scoresB(20,0.15): n=20 trials with p=0.15. The same order applies to Geo(p), which takes only the one parameter.
Revise this topicDiscrete Random Variables
A student wrote · The Normal DistributionP(X>23)=Φ(0.6)=0.7257 for X~N(20,25).
Why it loses marksThe table gives the area to the left of z. The question asks for the right-hand tail, which is everything else, so the reading has to be taken away from 1.
The answer that scoresP(X>23)=1−Φ(0.6)=1−0.7257=0.2743.
Revise this topicThe Normal Distribution
A student wrote · The Normal DistributionX~N(50,16), so z=55−5016=0.3125.
Why it loses marksThe second number in the bracket is the variance, not the standard deviation. Standardising divides by σ, and here σ=16=4.
The answer that scoresz=55−504=1.25, so P(X<55)=Φ(1.25)=0.8944.
Revise this topicThe Normal Distribution
A student wrote · The Normal DistributionP(46<X<62)=Φ(1.5)+Φ(−0.5)=0.9332+0.3085.
Why it loses marksThe area between two values is the difference of two left-hand areas, not their sum. Adding gives an area larger than the region and, here, larger than 1.
The answer that scoresP(46<X<62)=0.9332−0.3085=0.6247.
Revise this topicThe Normal Distribution
A student wrote · The Normal DistributionX~B(100,0.5), so P(X≥60)≈P(Y>60) and z=60−505=2.
Why it loses marksThe binomial is discrete and the normal is continuous, so the boundary has to move half a unit. Using 60 instead of 59.5 shifts the answer and loses the accuracy mark.
The answer that scoresz=59.5−505=1.9, so P(X≥60)≈1−Φ(1.9)=1−0.9713=0.0287.
Revise this topicThe Normal Distribution
A student wrote · The Normal DistributionΦ(−1.5)=−0.9332.
Why it loses marksA probability is never negative. The table prints only positive values of z, and the symmetry rule turns a negative one into 1−Φ(z).
The answer that scoresΦ(−1.5)=1−Φ(1.5)=1−0.9332=0.0668.
Revise this topicThe Normal Distribution