AS Level Content
A student wrote · Atomic structureA student wrote: 'The relative atomic mass of magnesium is 24, because the tallest peak in its mass spectrum is at m/z = 24.'
Why it loses marksRelative atomic mass is the weighted mean of the masses of all the isotopes present, not the mass of the most abundant one. In a sample of magnesium about 21% of the atoms are Mg-25 or Mg-26, so using the tallest peak alone ignores a fifth of the atoms and gives an answer that is too low.
The answer that scoresMultiply the mass of each isotope by its relative abundance, add the products and divide by 100: (24 x 79.0) + (25 x 10.0) + (26 x 11.0) = 1896 + 250 + 286 = 2432, and 2432 / 100 = 24.3. The relative atomic mass has no units, because it is a mass compared with one twelfth of the mass of an atom of carbon-12.
Revise this topicAtomic structure
A student wrote · Atomic structureA student wrote: 'First ionisation energy increases down a group, because the atoms get bigger and hold more electrons.'
Why it loses marksGetting bigger works against the trend, not with it. Down a group the outer electron occupies a shell with a larger principal quantum number, so it is further from the nucleus, and the extra inner shells shield it from the nuclear charge. Both effects weaken the attraction between the nucleus and the outer electron, and they outweigh the extra protons.
The answer that scoresDown a group the first ionisation energy decreases. The outer electron is in a shell further from the nucleus and is shielded by more inner shells, so less energy is needed to remove it: the value falls from 520 kJ mol-1 for lithium to 496 for sodium and 419 for potassium. The number of electrons in the atom is irrelevant; what matters is how strongly the outer electron is held.
Revise this topicAtomic structure
A student wrote · Atomic structureA student wrote: 'The 4s sub-shell is filled before the 3d sub-shell, so the electronic configuration of chromium is [Ar] 4s2 3d4.'
Why it loses marksThe filling order tells you which sub-shell is occupied first when the atom is built up, not the final arrangement of the electrons. A half-filled 3d sub-shell with a single 4s electron is lower in energy than 3d4 4s2, because five electrons in five separate d orbitals keep further apart and there is less electron-electron repulsion.
The answer that scoresChromium is [Ar] 3d5 4s1 and copper is [Ar] 3d10 4s1, because the half-filled and completely filled d sub-shells have a lower energy than the alternatives. Because 3d lies below 4s in energy once it is occupied, a transition element loses its 4s electrons first when it forms a positive ion: iron is [Ar] 3d6 4s2, Fe2+ is [Ar] 3d6 and Fe3+ is [Ar] 3d5.
Revise this topicAtomic structure
A student wrote · Atomic structureA student wrote: 'A 2p orbital can hold six electrons, because a p sub-shell takes six electrons.'
Why it loses marksThe student has confused the sub-shell with the orbital. A p sub-shell is made up of three separate p orbitals, each lying along a different axis, and every orbital holds a maximum of two electrons with opposite spins. Six electrons therefore occupy the whole sub-shell, not one orbital.
The answer that scoresA 2p sub-shell contains three orbitals, labelled 2px, 2py and 2pz, and each holds a maximum of two electrons, so the sub-shell holds six electrons in total. An s sub-shell holds two electrons in its single orbital and a d sub-shell holds ten in its five orbitals. In electrons in boxes notation a 2p sub-shell is drawn as three boxes, filled singly with parallel spins before any box is given a second electron.
Revise this topicAtomic structure
A student wrote · Atoms, molecules and stoichiometryA student wrote: 'The relative molecular mass of sodium chloride is 58.5, because Na is 23.0 and Cl is 35.5.'
Why it loses marksSolid sodium chloride is a giant ionic lattice of Na+ and Cl- ions. It contains no molecules at all, so the term relative molecular mass does not apply to it, and that costs a definition mark even though the arithmetic is right.
The answer that scoresThe relative formula mass of sodium chloride is 23.0 + 35.5 = 58.5. Relative molecular mass is reserved for substances that genuinely exist as molecules, such as H2O, CO2 and C2H5OH. Use relative formula mass for any ionic compound and for giant covalent structures.
Revise this topicAtoms, molecules and stoichiometry
A student wrote · Atoms, molecules and stoichiometryA student found the simplest ratio of the atoms in a compound to be 1 : 2 : 1 and wrote: 'The molecular formula is CH2O.'
Why it loses marksThe ratio 1 : 2 : 1 gives only the empirical formula. The molecular formula needs the relative molecular mass as well, because the actual molecule may contain 2, 3 or more times as many atoms of each element as the simplest ratio shows.
The answer that scoresThe empirical formula is CH2O. If Mr is 60.0, the empirical formula mass is 12.0 + 2.0 + 16.0 = 30.0, so the multiplier is 60.0 / 30.0 = 2 and the molecular formula is C2H4O2, which is ethanoic acid. With Mr = 180 the multiplier would be 6 and the molecular formula would be C6H12O6, glucose.
Revise this topicAtoms, molecules and stoichiometry
A student wrote · Atoms, molecules and stoichiometryA student obtained 4.20 g of copper from a reaction whose equation predicts a maximum of 5.00 g, and wrote: 'The percentage yield is 5.00 / 4.20 x 100 = 119%.'
Why it loses marksThe fraction has been turned upside down, which gives a yield above 100%. Percentage yield compares what was actually obtained with what was theoretically possible, so the actual mass must be on top.
The answer that scoresPercentage yield = (mass actually obtained / maximum mass from the equation) x 100 = 4.20 / 5.00 x 100 = 84.0%. The answer must always be less than 100%; a value above 100% means the product is wet or impure, or that the fraction has been inverted.
Revise this topicAtoms, molecules and stoichiometry
A student wrote · Atoms, molecules and stoichiometryA student dissolved 10.6 g of sodium carbonate in water, made the solution up to 250 cm3 and wrote: 'n = 10.6 / 106 = 0.100 mol, so the concentration is 0.100 / 250 = 4.00 x 10^-4 mol dm-3.'
Why it loses marksThe volume was substituted in cm3. The relationship c = n / V needs the volume in dm3, so leaving 250 in place of 0.250 dm3 makes the answer 1000 times too small - the most common single error in solution calculations.
The answer that scoresConvert the volume first: 250 cm3 = 250 / 1000 = 0.250 dm3. Then c = 0.100 / 0.250 = 0.400 mol dm-3. The same conversion is needed in every titration: divide the cm3 from the pipette or burette by 1000 before using c = n / V.
Revise this topicAtoms, molecules and stoichiometry
A student wrote · Chemical bondingA student wrote: 'Sodium chloride has a low melting point because the bonds between the sodium and chlorine atoms are weak van der Waals forces.'
Why it loses marksSodium chloride is not made of molecules at all. It is a giant ionic lattice, and the force that holds the lattice together is the strong electrostatic attraction between Na+ and Cl- ions, which acts in every direction. Van der Waals' forces are the weak intermolecular forces between molecules, not the forces inside a lattice.
The answer that scoresSodium chloride is a giant ionic lattice containing Na+ and Cl- ions, and the lattice is held together by the electrostatic attraction between oppositely charged ions. This attraction acts between every ion and all the oppositely charged ions around it, so a large amount of energy is needed to break the lattice. Sodium chloride therefore has a high melting point, about 800 degrees C. Ionic bonding, covalent bonding and metallic bonding are all much stronger than the van der Waals' forces that act between molecules.
Revise this topicChemical bonding
A student wrote · Chemical bondingA student wrote: 'The H-O-H bond angle in water is 109.5 degrees, because there are four pairs of electrons around the oxygen atom in a tetrahedral arrangement.'
Why it loses marksThe angle depends not just on how many pairs there are but on which kind they are. Two of the four pairs on the oxygen of water are lone pairs, and a lone pair repels more strongly than a bonding pair, so it squeezes the two O-H bonding pairs together and reduces the angle.
The answer that scoresWater has two bonding pairs and two lone pairs around the oxygen, so the four pairs are arranged tetrahedrally. The two lone pairs repel more strongly than the bonding pairs, so the H-O-H angle is squeezed from the tetrahedral 109.5 degrees to 104.5 degrees. Methane, with four bonding pairs and no lone pairs, keeps the full 109.5 degrees, and ammonia, with one lone pair, sits in between at 107 degrees.
Revise this topicChemical bonding
A student wrote · Chemical bondingA student wrote: 'In ethene the C=C double bond is two identical bonds, both formed by the direct end-on overlap of the orbitals on the two carbon atoms.'
Why it loses marksA double bond is never two identical bonds. It is one sigma bond from end-on overlap plus one pi bond from the sideways overlap of the two remaining unhybridised p orbitals, above and below the sigma bond. The pi bond is the weaker of the two, which is why ethene reacts by addition rather than by substitution.
The answer that scoresEthene is made of three sp2 hybrid orbitals on each carbon. Two of them on each carbon form C-H sigma bonds, and one forms the C-C sigma bond by end-on overlap, giving 120 degree angles in a plane. The remaining unhybridised 2p orbital on each carbon, perpendicular to that plane, overlaps sideways with its partner to give one pi bond with electron density above and below the sigma bond. The double bond is therefore one sigma plus one pi, and the weaker pi bond is the one that breaks when bromine adds across the C=C to give 1,2-dibromoethane.
Revise this topicChemical bonding
A student wrote · Chemical bondingA student wrote: 'Ice is denser than liquid water, because in a solid the molecules are packed more closely together than in a liquid.'
Why it loses marksThat is true of most solids, but ice is an exception. Hydrogen bonds hold the water molecules of ice in a regular tetrahedral arrangement that builds an open structure, so the molecules are on average further apart in ice than in the liquid and ice is less dense.
The answer that scoresIn ice each water molecule is hydrogen bonded to four others, using its two O-H groups to donate and the two lone pairs on its oxygen to accept, and this tetrahedral arrangement builds an open lattice containing hexagonal rings. As ice melts, some of those hydrogen bonds break and the structure collapses, so the molecules can pack closer together and the liquid is denser than the solid. That is why ice floats, and why the relatively high melting and boiling points, and the high surface tension of water, are all described as anomalous for such a small molecule.
Revise this topicChemical bonding
A student wrote · States of matterA student wrote: 'In pV = nRT the temperature is 25, because the gas was measured at 25 degrees Celsius, so n = pV / (8.31 x 25).'
Why it loses marksThe ideal gas equation requires the temperature in kelvin. Substituting degrees Celsius gives an answer that is larger by a factor of 298 / 25, so the amount of gas is wrong by more than ten times. The same student may also lose marks by leaving the volume in cm3 or the pressure in kPa.
The answer that scoresConvert everything into SI units first. A gas measured at 25 C is at 25 + 273 = 298 K, so with p in Pa, V in m3 and T in K, n = pV / (8.31 x 298). Mixed units are the most common reason for losing marks in pV = nRT questions, so write the unit beside each value as you substitute.
Revise this topicStates of matter
A student wrote · States of matterA student wrote: 'Iodine has a low melting point because the covalent bonds between the iodine atoms are weak.'
Why it loses marksThe covalent bond inside an I2 molecule is strong; it is the weak instantaneous dipole-induced dipole forces between separate I2 molecules that are overcome when iodine melts. The student has also lost the distinction between a bond and an intermolecular force, which is the point of the question.
The answer that scoresIodine is a simple molecular solid in which I2 molecules are held in a lattice by weak id-id forces. Melting supplies enough energy to overcome those weak forces and separate the molecules, but not enough to break the strong covalent bonds within the molecules, which is why the purple vapour that forms is still made of I2 molecules. Similar molecules with stronger intermolecular forces, such as hydrogen-bonded ice, melt at much higher temperatures.
Revise this topicStates of matter
A student wrote · States of matterA student wrote: 'Graphite does not conduct electricity because carbon is a non-metal and all of its electrons are used in covalent bonding.'
Why it loses marksIn graphite each carbon atom forms only three covalent bonds, so three of its four outer electrons are used in bonding and the fourth is delocalised. Graphite therefore conducts along its layers, unlike diamond, where each carbon forms four bonds and no electrons are free to move.
The answer that scoresIn graphite each carbon atom is bonded to three others in flat hexagonal layers, and the fourth outer electron from each atom is delocalised across the layer and free to move, so graphite conducts electricity along its layers. In diamond each carbon atom forms four tetrahedral covalent bonds, so all its outer electrons are localised in bonds and diamond does not conduct. In both substances melting requires the breaking of strong covalent bonds, which is why both have very high melting points.
Revise this topicStates of matter
A student wrote · States of matterA student wrote: 'A crystal of sodium chloride conducts electricity because it contains sodium ions and chloride ions that carry charge.'
Why it loses marksContaining ions is not enough; the ions must be free to move. In the solid the ions are held in fixed positions by the strong electrostatic attraction throughout the lattice, so they cannot carry charge to the electrodes.
The answer that scoresSolid sodium chloride does not conduct, because its ions are locked in the lattice and cannot move. When the crystal is melted, or dissolved in water, the lattice breaks down and the Na+ and Cl- ions become free to move, so both molten sodium chloride and aqueous sodium chloride conduct electricity. This difference between the solid and the molten or dissolved substance is exactly how you identify a giant ionic lattice.
Revise this topicStates of matter
A student wrote · Chemical energeticsA student wrote: 'The standard enthalpy change of formation of methane is the energy transferred when one mole of methane burns completely in excess oxygen.'
Why it loses marksThat is the definition of the standard enthalpy change of combustion, not of formation. Formation is about building one mole of a compound from its elements, and the answer the student gave loses the mark because both the starting materials and the meaning of the change are wrong.
The answer that scoresThe standard enthalpy change of formation of methane is the enthalpy change when one mole of methane is formed from its elements, carbon and hydrogen, in their standard states at 298 K and 101 kPa. Its value is about -75 kJ mol-1. The standard enthalpy change of combustion of methane is a different quantity entirely: it is -890 kJ mol-1, the energy transferred when one mole of methane is burned completely in excess oxygen.
Revise this topicChemical energetics
A student wrote · Chemical energeticsA student measured the temperature rise in the polystyrene cup experiment, calculated an enthalpy change of neutralisation of -56.8 kJ mol-1, and wrote: 'so the accepted value must be -56.8 kJ mol-1 too, because the calculation is exact.'
Why it loses marksThe calculation uses assumptions that are not exactly true: no energy is lost to the surroundings, the polystyrene cup and thermometer absorb no energy, the density of the solution is exactly 1.00 g cm-3 and c is exactly 4.18 J g-1 K-1. Because some energy always escapes, the recorded temperature rise is too small and the experimental value is less exothermic than the true value.
The answer that scoresThe temperature rise measured is smaller than it should be, because energy is lost to the surroundings and absorbed by the cup and the thermometer. The measured value of -56.8 kJ mol-1 is therefore slightly less exothermic than the accepted value of about -57 kJ mol-1 for a strong acid with a strong base. The experiment can be improved by insulating the cup more effectively, fitting a lid, mixing the reagents quickly, and plotting temperature against time so that the graph can be extrapolated back to the moment of mixing to correct for the heat lost during the measurement.
Revise this topicChemical energetics
A student wrote · Chemical energeticsA student wrote: 'delta Hr = energy released making bonds - energy absorbed breaking bonds, so for H2(g) + Cl2(g) -> 2HCl(g), delta Hr = 862 - 678 = +184 kJ mol-1.'
Why it loses marksThe formula has been written the wrong way round, which reverses the sign of the answer. Bond breaking absorbs energy and bond making releases it, and the energy released in this reaction is greater than the energy absorbed, so the reaction must be exothermic and delta H must be negative.
The answer that scoresdelta Hr = energy absorbed breaking bonds - energy released making bonds = (436 + 242) - (2 x 431) = 678 - 862 = -184 kJ mol-1. The negative sign shows that more energy is released when the two H-Cl bonds form than is absorbed when the H-H and Cl-Cl bonds break, so the reaction is exothermic.
Revise this topicChemical energetics
A student wrote · Chemical energeticsA student wrote: 'I worked out the enthalpy change of combustion of methane from mean bond energies and got about -700 kJ mol-1, but the data book says -890 kJ mol-1, so I must have copied one of the bond energies down wrongly.'
Why it loses marksA mean bond energy is an average taken over many different compounds, not the exact strength of a bond in one particular molecule, so a bond energy calculation is only ever an approximation. The C=O bonds in carbon dioxide are stronger than the average C=O bond energy, and bond energies refer to gaseous species, whereas the standard enthalpy change of combustion of methane is measured with water formed as a liquid.
The answer that scoresThe difference is expected and is not an arithmetic error. Mean bond energies average the same bond over many compounds, in which the surroundings of the bond differ, so they do not reproduce a measured enthalpy change exactly. Bond energies also apply only to gaseous species, so the value they give refers to gaseous water, not to the liquid water formed in the standard combustion reaction. A calculation from exact bond energies, in a diatomic molecule such as H2 or HCl, does agree with the measured value.
Revise this topicChemical energetics
A student wrote · ElectrochemistryA student wrote: 'The oxidation number of hydrogen is +1 in every compound, because it always forms one bond.'
Why it loses marksHydrogen is +1 in most of its compounds, but not in the metal hydrides. In sodium hydride, NaH, and calcium hydride, CaH2, hydrogen is the more electronegative atom of the pair, so it takes the shared electrons and its oxidation number is -1.
The answer that scoresHydrogen has oxidation number +1 in most compounds, including water, methane and sulphuric acid. The exception is the metal hydrides, such as sodium hydride NaH and calcium hydride CaH2, where hydrogen is -1. Check with the rule that the sum of the oxidation numbers equals the charge: in NaH, sodium is +1 and the compound is neutral, so hydrogen must be -1.
Revise this topicElectrochemistry
A student wrote · ElectrochemistryA student wrote: 'In hydrogen peroxide, H2O2, the oxidation number of oxygen is -2, because oxygen is always -2 except in compounds with fluorine.'
Why it loses marksThe calculation is not carried out. In H2O2 the two hydrogen atoms supply 2(+1) = +2, and the species is neutral, so the two oxygen atoms together must carry -2 and each separate oxygen atom is -1, not -2.
The answer that scoresOxygen is -2 in most compounds but -1 in the peroxides, which include hydrogen peroxide H2O2, sodium peroxide Na2O2 and barium peroxide BaO2. Work it out from the charge: 2(+1) + 2x = 0, so x = -1. Oxygen is +2 in OF2, because fluorine is the more electronegative element and takes the shared electrons.
Revise this topicElectrochemistry
A student wrote · ElectrochemistryA student wrote: 'Disproportionation is when one compound breaks down into two simpler substances, for example calcium carbonate into calcium oxide and carbon dioxide.'
Why it loses marksThat is thermal decomposition, not disproportionation. In disproportionation a single element must be oxidised and reduced at the same time, so it must appear in the products with one higher and one lower oxidation number than it had at the start. Thermal decomposition is not a redox reaction at all.
The answer that scoresDisproportionation is the oxidation and reduction of the same element in the same reaction. In Cl2 + 2NaOH -> NaCl + NaClO + H2O, chlorine is 0 in Cl2, -1 in the chloride and +1 in the chlorate(I) ion. A second example is 2Cu+ -> Cu2+ + Cu, where copper goes from +1 to +2 in one product and from +1 to 0 in the other.
Revise this topicElectrochemistry
A student wrote · ElectrochemistryA student wrote: 'In electrolysis the positive ions move to the anode and are oxidised there, because the anode is the negative electrode.'
Why it loses marksBoth halves of the statement are wrong. Ions with a positive charge are attracted to the negatively charged electrode, and the loss of electrons that defines oxidation happens at the positively charged electrode. The names and the charges have been mixed up.
The answer that scoresIn electrolysis, positive ions (cations) move to the cathode, which is the negative electrode, and are reduced there by gaining electrons. Negative ions (anions) move to the anode, which is the positive electrode, and are oxidised there by losing electrons. In the electrolysis of concentrated aqueous sodium chloride, hydrogen is formed at the cathode by reduction of water and chlorine is formed at the anode by oxidation of chloride ions.
Revise this topicElectrochemistry
A student wrote · EquilibriaA student wrote: 'Adding a catalyst to a system at equilibrium moves the position of equilibrium to the right, because the forward reaction is speeded up.'
Why it loses marksA catalyst speeds up the forward and the reverse reactions by the same amount, so the rates stay equal and the position of equilibrium does not move at all. The yield of product at equilibrium is unchanged; only the time taken to reach equilibrium is reduced.
The answer that scoresA catalyst lowers the activation energy of both the forward and the reverse reactions equally, so both rates increase by the same factor. The position of equilibrium is unchanged and the value of Kc is unchanged. The mixture simply reaches equilibrium sooner, which is why a catalyst lets an industrial plant work at a compromise temperature that gives a better equilibrium yield at an acceptable rate.
Revise this topicEquilibria
A student wrote · EquilibriaA student wrote: 'Increasing the pressure on the equilibrium N2(g) + 3H2(g) <-> 2NH3(g) increases the value of Kc.'
Why it loses marksIncreasing the pressure shifts the position of equilibrium to the right, towards the fewer molecules of gas, so the yield of ammonia rises, but the value of Kc is unchanged. Temperature is the only change that alters the value of an equilibrium constant.
The answer that scoresIncreasing the pressure does shift the position of equilibrium to the right, because four moles of gas become two, but the equilibrium concentrations change in exactly the ratio that leaves Kc the same. Kc changes only when the temperature changes. For this exothermic forward reaction, raising the temperature would decrease the value of Kc, and lowering the temperature would increase it.
Revise this topicEquilibria
A student wrote · EquilibriaA student wrote: 'A 0.100 mol dm-3 solution of ethanoic acid has a pH of about 1, because a 0.100 mol dm-3 acid gives 0.100 mol dm-3 of hydrogen ions.'
Why it loses marksThat is only true for a strong acid. Ethanoic acid is a weak acid and is only partially dissociated, so the concentration of H+(aq) ions is far lower than 0.100 mol dm-3, and the pH is much higher. The student has confused concentration with degree of dissociation.
The answer that scoresHydrochloric acid is fully dissociated, so 0.100 mol dm-3 HCl gives 0.100 mol dm-3 of H+(aq) ions and a pH of about 1. Ethanoic acid sets up the equilibrium CH3COOH(aq) <-> H+(aq) + CH3COO-(aq), and in a 0.100 mol dm-3 solution only a small fraction of the molecules has donated a proton, so the concentration of H+(aq) ions is only about 1.3 x 10^-3 mol dm-3 and the pH is about 2.9.
Revise this topicEquilibria
A student wrote · EquilibriaA student wrote: 'The Haber process is run at about 450 °C and about 200 atm because those conditions give the highest possible yield of ammonia.'
Why it loses marksThe industrial conditions are a compromise, not an optimum for yield. The highest possible yield would need the lowest possible temperature, because the forward reaction is exothermic, and the highest possible pressure. A very low temperature would make the rate far too slow, and an extremely high pressure would need plant that is far too expensive to build and run.
The answer that scoresThe yield of ammonia increases as the temperature is lowered and as the pressure is raised, so 450 °C is a compromise between a reasonable yield and a workable rate, and the iron catalyst makes that rate acceptable. About 200 atm is the highest pressure that is economical: it shifts the equilibrium further towards ammonia, but the plant must be built to withstand it. The ammonia formed is liquefied out and the unreacted gases are recycled, so the overall conversion is high even though each pass is not.
Revise this topicEquilibria
A student wrote · Reaction kineticsA student wrote: 'A catalyst speeds up a reaction by increasing the energy of the reactant particles, so that they collide with more energy.'
Why it loses marksA catalyst does not change the energy of the particles or the temperature of the mixture. The molecules keep the same spread of energies (the same Boltzmann distribution) and the activation energy is what changes, not the particles.
The answer that scoresA catalyst provides an alternative reaction pathway of lower activation energy. At the same temperature a much larger fraction of the molecules now has energy greater than or equal to that lower activation energy, so the frequency of effective collisions increases and the reaction goes faster. The catalyst takes part in the reaction and is regenerated at the end, so it is chemically unchanged.
Revise this topicReaction kinetics
A student wrote · Reaction kineticsA student wrote: 'Raising the temperature increases the rate simply because the particles move faster and collide more often.'
Why it loses marksMore frequent collisions are only a small part of the effect and are not enough to explain why a 10 K rise can roughly double the rate. The explanation the examiner wants is about the fraction of collisions that are effective.
The answer that scoresTwo effects operate. The molecules move faster, so collisions are a little more frequent, but far more importantly the higher temperature shifts and flattens the Boltzmann distribution, so a much greater proportion of the molecules has energy greater than or equal to the activation energy. The area under the curve beyond EA increases greatly, so the frequency of effective collisions rises sharply and the rate increases far more than the collision frequency alone would explain.
Revise this topicReaction kinetics
A student wrote · Reaction kineticsA student wrote: 'Adding a catalyst to a reaction at equilibrium increases the yield of the product, because it speeds up the forward reaction.'
Why it loses marksA catalyst lowers the activation energy of the forward and the reverse reactions by the same amount, so both directions are accelerated equally. It does not change the position of equilibrium and does not change the yield; only a change in temperature (or concentration, or pressure) does that.
The answer that scoresThe catalyst accelerates both directions equally, because it lowers the energy barrier of the forwards and the backwards reaction. The position of equilibrium and the value of the equilibrium constant are unchanged, so the final yield is the same. What changes is the time taken to reach equilibrium: the reaction gets there sooner, which is why industrial catalysts are used to make a workable rate at a moderate temperature.
Revise this topicReaction kinetics
A student wrote · Reaction kineticsA student wrote: 'The concentration of a reactant was 0.600 mol dm-3 after 30 s, so the rate of the reaction at that time was 0.600 / 30 = 0.0200 mol dm-3 s-1.'
Why it loses marksThe rate at an instant is the gradient of the concentration-time curve at that point, not the concentration divided by the time. Dividing the concentration by the time gives a rough average rate over the whole 30 s, and it is not the rate at 30 s. The curve is steepest at the start, so this value is also too large for the rate at 30 s.
The answer that scoresDraw a tangent to the curve at t = 30 s and find its gradient: rate = change in concentration / change in time, taken between two points on the tangent. For example, if the tangent passes through 0.750 mol dm-3 at 20 s and 0.450 mol dm-3 at 40 s, the rate at 30 s is 0.300 / 20 = 0.0150 mol dm-3 s-1. The unit is mol dm-3 s-1, and the answer should be given to the same number of significant figures as the data.
Revise this topicReaction kinetics
A student wrote · The Periodic Table: chemical periodicityA student wrote: 'Aluminium oxide is a basic oxide, because aluminium is a metal and aluminium oxide reacts with hydrochloric acid.'
Why it loses marksThe reaction with an acid only shows that the oxide is basic; it does not show that it is only basic. Aluminium oxide also reacts with sodium hydroxide solution, so it is amphoteric, and a statement that it is basic alone throws away the mark for the reaction with a base.
The answer that scoresAluminium oxide is amphoteric: it reacts with both an acid and a base. With hydrochloric acid, Al2O3 + 6HCl -> 2AlCl3 + 3H2O, giving a colourless solution of aluminium chloride. With sodium hydroxide solution, Al2O3 + 2NaOH + 3H2O -> 2NaAl(OH)4, giving a solution of sodium tetrahydroxoaluminate(III). Aluminium hydroxide behaves in the same way: Al(OH)3 + 3HCl -> AlCl3 + 3H2O and Al(OH)3 + NaOH -> NaAl(OH)4.
Revise this topicThe Periodic Table: chemical periodicity
A student wrote · The Periodic Table: chemical periodicityA student wrote: 'Silicon has a low melting point for a solid because it is a non-metal, and only weak forces between the molecules have to be overcome.'
Why it loses marksSilicon is not a simple molecular substance. It is a giant covalent structure in which each atom is joined to four others by strong covalent bonds, and melting it means breaking covalent bonds, not overcoming London forces between molecules. Its melting point is about 1414 C, the highest in Period 3.
The answer that scoresSilicon is a giant covalent macromolecule: every silicon atom is covalently bonded to four neighbours in a continuous three-dimensional network. To melt it, the strong covalent bonds themselves must be broken, which needs a great deal of energy, so the melting point is very high, about 1414 C. The low melting points in Period 3 belong to P4, S8, Cl2 and Ar, where the molecules are separate and only weak London forces hold them together.
Revise this topicThe Periodic Table: chemical periodicity
A student wrote · The Periodic Table: chemical periodicityA student wrote: 'A solution of aluminium chloride in water is neutral, and a solution of phosphorus pentachloride is neutral too, because both compounds are covalent and covalent compounds do not conduct electricity or react with water.'
Why it loses marksBoth chlorides are hydrolysed by water, and the solutions are strongly acidic. Reacting with water is not the same as being ionised by water, and covalent chlorides of small, highly charged atoms are hydrolysed vigorously. The pHs are about 3 for AlCl3 and about 1 for PCl5, not 7.
The answer that scoresAlCl3 hydrolyses vigorously to give an acidic solution of pH about 3, with a white precipitate of Al(OH)3 and fumes of HCl: AlCl3 + 3H2O -> Al(OH)3 + 3HCl. PCl5 hydrolyses violently to give a strongly acidic solution of pH about 1: PCl5 + 4H2O -> H3PO4 + 5HCl. The acidic character is caused by the partial positive charge on the aluminium and phosphorus atoms, which attracts a water molecule and displaces the chloride as HCl. Only NaCl, with the low charge density of Na+, dissolves to give a neutral solution of pH 7.
Revise this topicThe Periodic Table: chemical periodicity
A student wrote · The Periodic Table: chemical periodicityA student wrote: 'The oxidation number of phosphorus in P4O10 is +10, because there are ten oxygen atoms in the formula, and each oxygen is -2.'
Why it loses marksThe oxidation number is the charge on one atom, not on the whole formula. Dividing the total positive charge by the number of phosphorus atoms in the formula unit is what gives the answer, and forgetting that P4 contains four phosphorus atoms is the commonest error in these questions.
The answer that scoresLet x be the oxidation number of phosphorus. 4x + 10(-2) = 0, so 4x = 20 and x = +5. Phosphorus has five outer-shell electrons and uses all five in P4O10, so +5 is consistent with the position of phosphorus in Period 3, between silicon at +4 and sulfur at +6 in SO3.
Revise this topicThe Periodic Table: chemical periodicity
A student wrote · Group 2A student wrote: 'Magnesium reacts with cold water to make magnesium hydroxide and hydrogen, so when magnesium is heated in steam the same reaction happens, just faster.'
Why it loses marksThe product depends on the temperature. Magnesium hydroxide decomposes when it is hot, so at the temperature of the steam reaction the solid left behind is magnesium oxide, not the hydroxide. The steam reaction is faster because the water molecules have much more energy, but it is also a different reaction.
The answer that scoresWith cold water: Mg(s) + 2H2O(l) -> Mg(OH)2(s) + H2(g), and the reaction is extremely slow because the sparingly soluble hydroxide coats the metal and keeps the water away from it. With steam: Mg(s) + H2O(g) -> MgO(s) + H2(g); the magnesium glows brightly and a white solid of magnesium oxide is left in the tube.
Revise this topicGroup 2
A student wrote · Group 2A student wrote: 'Barium carbonate decomposes at a lower temperature than magnesium carbonate because barium is a bigger atom, so its bond to the carbonate is weaker.'
Why it loses marksThe bond that breaks when a carbonate decomposes is a C-O bond inside the carbonate ion, not the bond between the metal ion and the carbonate. The important property is the charge density of the cation: the small, highly charged Mg2+ polarises the carbonate ion strongly and weakens one of its C-O bonds, so magnesium carbonate decomposes more easily. The student has also reversed the trend.
The answer that scoresThermal stability increases down the group. MgCO3(s) -> MgO(s) + CO2(g) happens on fairly gentle heating, at about 350 °C, whereas CaCO3(s) -> CaO(s) + CO2(g) needs about 825 °C, and the strontium and barium carbonates need higher temperatures still. The larger cation down the group has a lower charge density and polarises the carbonate ion less.
Revise this topicGroup 2
A student wrote · Group 2A student wrote: 'The Group 2 metals react more vigorously down the group with every acid, so barium reacts fastest with dilute sulfuric acid.'
Why it loses marksThis is true for dilute hydrochloric acid, where the chloride formed is soluble and the metal surface stays clean, and it is true for water. It is false for dilute sulfuric acid, because the sulfate becomes less soluble down the group and an insoluble coating forms on the metal.
The answer that scoresWith dilute hydrochloric acid the vigour increases from magnesium to barium, because the ionisation energies fall down the group and all the chlorides are soluble. With dilute sulfuric acid the reaction becomes slower down the group: magnesium reacts steadily because magnesium sulfate is soluble, calcium slows down and stops as sparingly soluble calcium sulfate coats the metal, and barium reacts hardly at all because barium sulfate is essentially insoluble.
Revise this topicGroup 2
A student wrote · Group 2A student wrote: 'I added barium chloride solution to an unknown solution, a white precipitate formed, so the solution must contain sulfate ions.'
Why it loses marksBarium chloride gives a white precipitate with carbonate and sulfite solutions as well as with sulfate solutions, so the test as carried out proves nothing. The test is only valid when the mixture is acidified with dilute hydrochloric acid first, because barium sulfate does not dissolve in dilute hydrochloric acid whereas barium carbonate and barium sulfite do, with the carbonate fizzing as it dissolves.
The answer that scoresAcidify the unknown solution with dilute hydrochloric acid, then add barium chloride solution. A white precipitate that does not dissolve in the dilute hydrochloric acid confirms sulfate ions: Ba2+(aq) + SO4^2-(aq) -> BaSO4(s). If the precipitate fizzes or dissolves in the acid, the solution contained carbonate or sulfite ions instead.
Revise this topicGroup 2
A student wrote · Group 17A student wrote: 'Iodine is a solid and chlorine is a gas at room temperature because the I-I covalent bond is much stronger than the Cl-Cl covalent bond, so iodine needs a much higher temperature to melt.'
Why it loses marksThe trend is the wrong way round and the wrong bond is named. The I-I bond enthalpy (151 kJ mol-1) is lower than the Cl-Cl bond enthalpy (242 kJ mol-1), and in any case melting and boiling a halogen do not break the covalent bond at all. The physical state depends on the forces between the molecules.
The answer that scoresChlorine is a gas and iodine a solid because the instantaneous dipole-induced dipole forces between the molecules are much stronger in iodine. An iodine molecule has more electrons and a larger, more polarisable electron cloud than a chlorine molecule, so the temporary dipoles it can set up are larger and the molecules are held together more strongly. More energy is therefore needed to separate the molecules, so iodine has the higher boiling point and the lower volatility. The X-X covalent bond is not broken when a halogen boils.
Revise this topicGroup 17
A student wrote · Group 17A student wrote: 'Chlorine reacts with cold dilute sodium hydroxide to give sodium chloride and water: Cl2 + 2NaOH -> 2NaCl + H2O. The chlorine is reduced, so this is not a disproportionation.'
Why it loses marksThe equation is wrong and so is the conclusion. Chlorine with cold dilute sodium hydroxide also gives the chlorate(I), so the chlorine is both reduced (from 0 to -1) and oxidised (from 0 to +1) in the same reaction, which is exactly what disproportionation means.
The answer that scoresCl2(g) + 2NaOH(aq) -> NaCl(aq) + NaClO(aq) + H2O(l). The oxidation number of chlorine is 0 in Cl2, -1 in NaCl and +1 in NaClO, so one portion of the chlorine has been reduced and another portion oxidised at the same time. This is a disproportionation. With hot concentrated sodium hydroxide the oxidation goes further and the product is the chlorate(V): 3Cl2(g) + 6NaOH(aq) -> 5NaCl(aq) + NaClO3(aq) + 3H2O(l), chlorine going from 0 to -1 and from 0 to +5.
Revise this topicGroup 17
A student wrote · Group 17A student wrote: 'Adding silver nitrate solution to the unknown gave a yellow precipitate that did not dissolve in concentrated ammonia, so the unknown must contain bromide ions.'
Why it loses marksBoth observations are wrong for a bromide. Silver bromide is a cream precipitate, not yellow, and it does dissolve in concentrated aqueous ammonia. A yellow precipitate that will not dissolve in concentrated ammonia is silver iodide, and the colour and the ammonia behaviour must agree before you name the ion.
The answer that scoresSilver chloride is a white precipitate and dissolves in dilute aqueous ammonia. Silver bromide is cream and dissolves only in concentrated aqueous ammonia. Silver iodide is yellow and does not dissolve even in concentrated aqueous ammonia. A yellow precipitate that is insoluble in concentrated ammonia therefore confirms iodide ions, by Ag+(aq) + I-(aq) -> AgI(s). Always quote the colour and the ammonia result together.
Revise this topicGroup 17
A student wrote · Group 17A student wrote: 'When sodium bromide is warmed with concentrated sulfuric acid, the bromide ions reduce the acid all the way to hydrogen sulfide, and you can smell the rotten eggs.'
Why it loses marksHydrogen sulfide requires sulfur to be reduced from +6 all the way to -2, and only a strong reducing agent can do that. Bromide is a weaker reducing agent than iodide, so with bromide the reduction stops at sulfur dioxide, where sulfur is +4.
The answer that scoresSodium bromide with concentrated sulfuric acid first gives steamy fumes of hydrogen bromide, NaBr(s) + H2SO4(l) -> NaHSO4(s) + HBr(g), and the hydrogen bromide is then oxidised to bromine while sulfur is reduced from +6 to +4: 2HBr(g) + H2SO4(l) -> Br2(g) + SO2(g) + 2H2O(l). The observations are orange-brown bromine vapour and choking sulfur dioxide. Yellow sulfur and hydrogen sulfide appear only with iodide, because iodide is the stronger reducing agent and can take sulfur to 0 and then to -2: 6HI(g) + H2SO4(l) -> 3I2(g) + S(s) + 4H2O(l) and 8HI(g) + H2SO4(l) -> 4I2(g) + H2S(g) + 4H2O(l).
Revise this topicGroup 17
A student wrote · Nitrogen and sulfurA student wrote: 'Nitrogen is unreactive because its atoms have a full outer shell of electrons, like a noble gas.'
Why it loses marksA nitrogen atom has five outer electrons, not eight, so its outer shell is not full. Nothing about the atom explains the inertness of nitrogen; the reason lies in the molecule and its bond.
The answer that scoresIn the N2 molecule the two atoms are held by a triple bond with a bond enthalpy of about 945 kJ mol-1, so an enormous amount of energy is needed to break it and any reaction has a very high activation energy. The molecule is also non-polar, because two identical atoms share the electrons equally, so there is no partially charged end for a polar reagent such as H+ or OH- to attack. Nitrogen reacts only at very high temperature, as in lightning or an engine, or with a catalyst, as in the Haber process with iron.
Revise this topicNitrogen and sulfur
A student wrote · Nitrogen and sulfurA student wrote: 'The ammonium ion has three ordinary covalent bonds and one ionic bond, and it is pyramidal in shape.'
Why it loses marksThe fourth bond is not ionic. When the lone pair on the nitrogen of ammonia attacks the proton, a dative covalent bond forms and both electrons in it come from the nitrogen. Because the ammonium ion has four bonding pairs and no lone pair, its shape is tetrahedral, not pyramidal.
The answer that scoresThe ammonium ion, NH4+, is tetrahedral with bond angles of about 109.5 °. It is formed in an acid-base reaction when the lone pair on the nitrogen atom of ammonia accepts a proton from an acid. The new N-H bond is a dative (coordinate) covalent bond, with both electrons donated by the nitrogen atom, and once it has formed all four N-H bonds are identical in length and strength.
Revise this topicNitrogen and sulfur
A student wrote · Nitrogen and sulfurA student wrote: 'A catalytic converter stops nitrogen oxides forming by taking the nitrogen out of the air before it reaches the engine.'
Why it loses marksThe converter sits in the exhaust pipe and treats the gases after combustion, so it cannot affect what happens inside the cylinder. Nitrogen is not removed from the air, because air is what the engine burns, and the formation of NO at about 2000 °C cannot be prevented in that way.
The answer that scoresNitrogen oxides are formed inside the cylinder, where the high temperature makes N2 and O2 react: N2 + O2 -> 2NO. The catalytic converter then removes them from the cooled exhaust gas by reducing them to nitrogen, 2NO + 2CO -> N2 + 2CO2, while at the same time oxidising carbon monoxide to carbon dioxide, 2CO + O2 -> 2CO2, and unburned hydrocarbons to carbon dioxide and water. The catalyst is platinum, palladium and rhodium, it must be hot to work, and it is poisoned by lead and by sulfur in the fuel.
Revise this topicNitrogen and sulfur
A student wrote · Nitrogen and sulfurA student wrote: 'Nitrogen dioxide catalyses the formation of acid rain, so NO2 makes sulfur dioxide react with water to form sulfuric acid.'
Why it loses marksThe catalysed step is the oxidation of sulfur dioxide to sulfur trioxide, not the addition of water. Sulfur dioxide with water gives sulfurous acid, H2SO3, which is a weak acid and is not the main acid in acid rain, and NO2 does not act as a catalyst for the reaction with water at all.
The answer that scoresNitrogen dioxide takes part in the oxidation of sulfur dioxide: NO2 + SO2 -> SO3 + NO, and the NO is oxidised back to NO2 by the air, 2NO + O2 -> 2NO2, so that the overall change is 2SO2 + O2 -> 2SO3 with NO2 unchanged at the end. The sulfur trioxide is the acid anhydride, and it is this that forms sulfuric acid with water: SO3 + H2O -> H2SO4. Separately, NO2 makes acid rain directly by dissolving in water to give nitric acid, 2NO2 + H2O -> HNO3 + HNO2.
Revise this topicNitrogen and sulfur
A student wrote · An introduction to AS Level organic chemistryA student wrote: 'But-1-ene and 2-methylpropene are functional group isomers, because they have different structures.'
Why it loses marksBoth compounds contain the same functional group, a C=C double bond, so they cannot be functional group isomers. Their carbon skeletons differ, which makes them chain isomers.
The answer that scoresChain isomers have the same functional group but a different carbon skeleton, so but-1-ene, CH2=CHCH2CH3, and 2-methylpropene, (CH3)2C=CH2, are chain isomers, not functional group isomers. Functional group isomers have different functional groups, like propanal and propanone, CH3CH2CHO and CH3COCH3, which are both C3H6O.
Revise this topicAn introduction to AS Level organic chemistry
A student wrote · An introduction to AS Level organic chemistryA student wrote: 'Propene shows cis/trans isomerism because it contains a carbon-carbon double bond, and rotation about the double bond is restricted.'
Why it loses marksRestricted rotation is only half the requirement. Geometrical isomerism also needs each carbon of the double bond to carry two different groups. In propene the CH2 carbon carries two hydrogen atoms, so the two arrangements are the same molecule.
The answer that scoresPropene has no geometrical isomers. Restricted rotation about the C=C means the groups cannot swap ends, but one carbon of the double bond carries two hydrogen atoms, so there is no second arrangement to form. But-2-ene, CH3CH=CHCH3, has a methyl group and a hydrogen atom on each carbon of the double bond, so it does exist as a cis and a trans isomer.
Revise this topicAn introduction to AS Level organic chemistry
A student wrote · An introduction to AS Level organic chemistryA student wrote: 'Chlorine and methane react in the dark by nucleophilic substitution to give chloromethane.'
Why it loses marksThe C-H bonds of methane are not polar, so there is no delta-positive carbon for a nucleophile to attack, and a chlorine molecule is not a nucleophile. The reaction needs ultraviolet light and it is a free-radical substitution.
The answer that scoresIn the dark there is no reaction at all. Ultraviolet light supplies the energy for the Cl-Cl bond to break homolytically, forming two chlorine radicals; the radicals then take a hydrogen atom from methane and give chloromethane in a chain of propagation steps, which end when two radicals combine in a termination step.
Revise this topicAn introduction to AS Level organic chemistry
A student wrote · An introduction to AS Level organic chemistryA student wrote, in the mechanism for the addition of HBr to ethene: 'a curly arrow from the hydrogen atom of HBr to the carbon of the C=C'.
Why it loses marksA curly arrow shows the movement of a pair of electrons, so it must start where those electrons are: in the middle of a bond or on a lone pair. The hydrogen atom of HBr has no lone pair, so an arrow drawn from the hydrogen itself is meaningless and scores nothing.
The answer that scoresThe correct arrows run the other way round. The pi bond of the C=C is the electron-rich species, so the first curly arrow starts at the pi bond and points to the hydrogen atom of HBr. A second curly arrow starts in the middle of the H-Br bond and points to the bromine, which takes both electrons and leaves as a bromide ion, leaving a carbocation that the bromide ion then attacks.
Revise this topicAn introduction to AS Level organic chemistry
A student wrote · HydrocarbonsA student wrote: 'Cracking is used to turn petrol into the heavier fractions such as diesel and fuel oil, because those are the fuels that sell best.'
Why it loses marksThe direction is the wrong way round, and that reverses the whole point of the process. Cracking breaks large molecules into smaller ones, so it converts surplus heavy fractions of high Mr into petrol-range alkanes of lower Mr together with alkenes. Nothing in a refinery cracks petrol back into diesel or fuel oil.
The answer that scoresCracking is used to obtain more useful alkanes and alkenes of lower Mr from heavier crude oil fractions. Long-chain alkanes from the heavy fractions are heated with Al2O3 or passed over a hot zeolite catalyst, and they break into shorter-chain alkanes such as octane, which are the petrol components, and into alkenes such as ethene and propene, which are the raw materials for polymers and for ethanol. It is carried out because distilling crude oil gives too much of the heavy, low-demand fractions and too little of the light, high-demand ones, and because crude oil contains almost no alkenes of its own.
Revise this topicHydrocarbons
A student wrote · HydrocarbonsA student wrote: 'The ultraviolet light in the reaction between ethane and chlorine is needed to break the C-H bond in ethane, so that a chlorine atom can take the hydrogen.'
Why it loses marksUltraviolet light does not have enough energy to break a C-H bond, whose bond enthalpy is of the order of 400 kJ mol-1. It breaks the much weaker Cl-Cl bond homolytically, and the C-H bond is broken later, in the propagation step, when a chlorine radical takes a hydrogen atom from ethane.
The answer that scoresUltraviolet light splits the halogen molecule by homolytic fission: Cl2 -> 2Cl, giving two chlorine atoms, each a free radical with one unpaired electron. In the propagation step a chlorine radical removes a hydrogen atom from ethane, C2H6 + Cl -> C2H5 + HCl, and the ethyl radical then reacts with a chlorine molecule, C2H5 + Cl2 -> C2H5Cl + Cl, which gives chloroethane and regenerates a chlorine radical. The Cl-Cl bond is much weaker than a C-H bond, and that is exactly why the light breaks only the halogen molecule.
Revise this topicHydrocarbons
A student wrote · HydrocarbonsA student wrote: 'When hydrogen bromide adds to propene the product is 1-bromopropane, because the hydrogen adds to the middle carbon so that the bromine can attach to the end of the chain.'
Why it loses marksThe hydrogen does not add to the middle carbon, and the reasoning has no chemical basis. The hydrogen joins the terminal CH2 carbon, which leaves the positive charge on the middle carbon, and the two possible cations are the secondary CH3-CH(+)-CH3 and the primary CH3-CH2-CH2(+). The secondary cation is the more stable one, so the route through it is faster and its product predominates.
The answer that scoresThe pi electrons of the C=C attack the delta-positive hydrogen of HBr, forming a C-H bond and releasing a bromide ion. The hydrogen adds to the terminal carbon, so the carbocation is CH3-CH(+)-CH3, a secondary cation, which is more stable than the primary cation that the alternative route would give because the two electron-releasing alkyl groups spread and reduce the positive charge. The bromide ion then attacks the positive carbon, so the major product is 2-bromopropane. This is Markovnikov's rule: the hydrogen goes to the carbon that already carries more hydrogen atoms.
Revise this topicHydrocarbons
A student wrote · HydrocarbonsA student wrote: 'Cold dilute acidified potassium manganate(VII) ruptures the carbon-carbon double bond, so ethene gives carbon dioxide and water, while the hot concentrated reagent gives ethane-1,2-diol.'
Why it loses marksThe two sets of conditions have been swapped. Cold dilute acidified KMnO4 is a mild oxidising agent that adds two hydroxyl groups across the double bond without breaking it, while the hot concentrated reagent is vigorous enough to rupture the C=C and oxidise each of the two carbons separately.
The answer that scoresCold dilute acidified KMnO4 reacts with ethene to give the diol, ethane-1,2-diol, HOCH2CH2OH, and the purple colour of the manganate(VII) ion disappears. Hot concentrated acidified KMnO4 ruptures the C=C, and a =CH2 group becomes CO2, a =CHR group becomes the carboxylic acid RCOOH and a =CR2 group becomes a ketone; ethene therefore gives carbon dioxide and water, propene gives ethanoic acid and carbon dioxide, and hex-2-ene gives ethanoic acid and butanoic acid.
Revise this topicHydrocarbons
A student wrote · Halogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Bromoethane reacts with sodium hydroxide to give ethene and sodium bromide.'
Why it loses marksThe product depends on the solvent, and the answer has ignored it. Aqueous sodium hydroxide supplies hydroxide ions that act as nucleophiles, so the bromine is replaced by OH and ethanol is formed. Ethene is only produced when the sodium hydroxide is dissolved in ethanol, so that there is no water present and the hydroxide acts as a base instead.
The answer that scoresWith NaOH(aq) and heat under reflux the product is ethanol: C2H5Br + NaOH -> C2H5OH + NaBr, a substitution. With NaOH in ethanol and heat under reflux the product is ethene: C2H5Br + NaOH -> C2H4 + NaBr + H2O, an elimination. Always state the solvent, because it decides whether the nucleophile attacks the carbon or a hydrogen atom on the neighbouring carbon.
Revise this topicHalogen compounds
A student wrote · Halogen compoundsA student wrote: '1-chlorohexane hydrolyses faster than 1-iodohexane, because chlorine is more electronegative than iodine, so the C-Cl bond is more polar.'
Why it loses marksPolarity is not the same as reactivity. The rate of hydrolysis depends on how easily the C-X bond breaks, and the C-I bond is much weaker than the C-Cl bond, so it needs less energy to break. The more electronegative halogen makes the carbon more delta-positive, but it also forms the stronger bond.
The answer that scoresThe C-X bond enthalpy decreases from C-F to C-I, so the activation energy for breaking the bond decreases and the rate of hydrolysis increases in the order RI > RBr > RCl > RF. The silver nitrate test shows it directly: 1-iodohexane gives a yellow precipitate of silver iodide in the cold, while 1-chlorohexane needs several minutes of heating before white silver chloride appears.
Revise this topicHalogen compounds
A student wrote · Halogen compoundsA student wrote: 'In the SN1 mechanism the hydroxide ion attacks the carbon atom first, and the C-Br bond breaks afterwards.'
Why it loses marksThat is the SN2 order of events, not SN1. The SN1 mechanism is unimolecular in its slow step, which means the halogenoalkane must fall apart on its own before the nucleophile is involved at all. Attacking first would make the rate depend on the hydroxide concentration, which it does not.
The answer that scoresIn SN1 the C-Br bond breaks heterolytically first, in the slow rate-determining step, with the pair of electrons moving onto the bromine to give a bromide ion and a carbocation. The hydroxide ion then attacks the carbocation in a fast second step. The rate depends only on the halogenoalkane, rate = k[RX], which is why SN1 is favoured by tertiary halogenoalkanes whose carbocations are stabilised by the inductive effect of their alkyl groups.
Revise this topicHalogen compounds
A student wrote · Halogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Bromoethane heated with potassium cyanide in ethanol gives ethylamine, because the cyanide is reduced to an amine.'
Why it loses marksThe cyanide ion is a nucleophile that attacks the carbon and stays attached, so the carbon of the CN group joins the chain: the product is a nitrile with one carbon more than the starting material, not an amine. Nothing in the reaction reduces anything, and no amine is formed under these conditions.
The answer that scoresBromoethane with KCN in ethanol, heated under reflux, gives propanenitrile: C2H5Br + KCN -> C2H5CN + KBr. The chain has grown by one carbon, and to reach an amine you would either reduce the nitrile, or use the separate reaction of bromoethane with ammonia in ethanol heated under pressure: C2H5Br + 2NH3 -> C2H5NH2 + NH4Br.
Revise this topicHalogen compounds
A student wrote · Hydroxy compoundsA student wrote: 'Propan-1-ol was heated with acidified potassium dichromate(VI) under reflux for thirty minutes. The organic product is propanal.'
Why it loses marksUnder reflux the condenser is vertical, so nothing escapes: the propanal that forms stays in the flask with the excess oxidising agent and is oxidised again. The colour change alone does not tell you where the oxidation stopped, so choosing the product from the colour change rather than from the apparatus loses the mark.
The answer that scoresHeating under reflux with an excess of acidified potassium dichromate(VI) oxidises propan-1-ol all the way to propanoic acid: propan-1-ol -> propanal -> propanoic acid, with [O] needed at each stage. Propanal is the product only if the reaction mixture is distilled and the aldehyde, which boils at about 49 degrees C, is collected as it forms and removed from the oxidising agent.
Revise this topicHydroxy compounds
A student wrote · Hydroxy compoundsA student wrote: 'A tertiary alcohol such as 2-methylpropan-2-ol is oxidised by acidified potassium dichromate(VI) to a ketone, so the solution turns green.'
Why it loses marksThe first step in the oxidation of an alcohol is the removal of the hydrogen atom attached to the carbon that carries the -OH group, together with the hydrogen of the O-H group, to build the C=O bond. In a tertiary alcohol that carbon is joined to three carbon atoms, so there is no hydrogen there to remove, and the mild oxidising agent cannot break a carbon-carbon bond instead.
The answer that scoresA tertiary alcohol has no hydrogen atom on the carbon carrying the -OH group, so it is not oxidised by acidified potassium dichromate(VI) or by acidified potassium manganate(VII). The solution stays orange and no ketone is formed. This is the reaction that identifies an unknown tertiary alcohol, because a primary or a secondary alcohol in the same tube would turn the solution from orange to green.
Revise this topicHydroxy compounds
A student wrote · Hydroxy compoundsA student wrote: 'Ethanol was warmed with alkaline iodine solution and a yellow precipitate of iodine was formed.'
Why it loses marksThe yellow precipitate is not iodine. Iodine in alkaline solution is a reagent, and it reacts with the CH3CH(OH)- group of the ethanol to give a compound in which three iodine atoms are bonded to a single carbon atom. Iodine itself is brown in aqueous solution and does not precipitate in this way.
The answer that scoresThe pale yellow precipitate is tri-iodomethane, CHI3, formed because ethanol contains the CH3CH(OH)- group; the ion left in solution is the methanoate ion, HCO2-, since R = H for ethanol. Naming the precipitate correctly, and giving the ion that goes with it, is what scores the marks.
Revise this topicHydroxy compounds
A student wrote · Hydroxy compoundsA student wrote: 'Acidified potassium dichromate(VI) is the catalyst for the oxidation of ethanol, so only a few drops are needed.'
Why it loses marksIt is the oxidising agent, not a catalyst. It is reduced during the reaction, from chromium(VI) in the orange dichromate(VI) ion to chromium(III) ions, which are green, so it is used up as the alcohol is oxidised and a few drops would oxidise only a trace of the alcohol.
The answer that scoresAcidified potassium dichromate(VI) is the oxidising agent and is used in excess when a full conversion to the carboxylic acid is wanted. The orange-to-green colour change is the oxidising agent being reduced, and it is also the observation that shows the alcohol has been oxidised. A true catalyst, such as the H3PO4 in the hydration of ethene, is not used up and is not reduced.
Revise this topicHydroxy compounds
A student wrote · Carbonyl compoundsA student wrote: 'Heating propan-1-ol under reflux with acidified potassium dichromate(VI) gives propanal.'
Why it loses marksUnder reflux the propanal that forms stays in contact with the excess oxidising agent and the acid, so it is oxidised again to propanoic acid. The mark is lost because the separation method does not match the product asked for.
The answer that scoresTo stop at the aldehyde the mixture must be heated with acidified potassium dichromate(VI) and the propanal distilled off as it forms, because propanal is more volatile than propan-1-ol and leaves the flask before it can be oxidised further. Reflux is used when the carboxylic acid is wanted.
Revise this topicCarbonyl compounds
A student wrote · Carbonyl compoundsA student wrote: 'The unknown compound gave an orange precipitate with 2,4-DNPH, so it is an aldehyde.'
Why it loses marks2,4-DNPH reacts with the carbonyl group, and both aldehydes and ketones contain one, so both give an orange crystalline precipitate of a 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazone. The test confirms the presence of a carbonyl group and nothing more.
The answer that scoresThe orange precipitate shows only that a carbonyl group is present. To find out whether the compound is an aldehyde or a ketone, warm separate samples with Fehling's solution and with Tollens' reagent. An aldehyde gives a brick-red precipitate of Cu2O with Fehling's solution and a silver mirror with Tollens' reagent; a ketone gives no change with either.
Revise this topicCarbonyl compounds
A student wrote · Carbonyl compoundsA student wrote: 'In the mechanism, a molecule of HCN attacks the delta-positive carbon of the carbonyl group.'
Why it loses marksThe species that attacks the carbon must carry a lone pair and a negative or partial negative charge. Cyanide ions do that, but hydrogen cyanide is a weak acid and is only very slightly ionised, so practically all of the HCN present is in the molecular form, which is not the nucleophile. The KCN is added precisely to supply CN- ions.
The answer that scoresThe nucleophile is the cyanide ion, CN-. A few drops of KCN are added to provide it, because HCN is a weak acid. The lone pair on the carbon of CN- attacks the delta-positive carbonyl carbon, the pi bond of the C=O breaks and both electrons move onto the oxygen to give an alkoxide ion, and the alkoxide is then protonated by a molecule of HCN to give the hydroxynitrile. The cyanide ion is regenerated, so KCN acts as a catalyst.
Revise this topicCarbonyl compounds
A student wrote · Carbonyl compoundsA student wrote: 'Reducing propanone with NaBH4 in aqueous ethanol gives propan-1-ol.'
Why it loses marksPropanone is a ketone, and its carbonyl carbon already carries two carbon groups. Reducing it can only add hydrogen across the C=O bond; it cannot move a carbon group, so the -OH ends up on the middle carbon and the product is a secondary alcohol.
The answer that scoresThe hydride ion from NaBH4 adds to the carbonyl carbon and the oxygen is protonated, giving propan-2-ol, CH3CH(OH)CH3, which is a secondary alcohol. A primary alcohol such as propan-1-ol can only be obtained by reducing an aldehyde, in this case propanal.
Revise this topicCarbonyl compounds
A student wrote · Carboxylic acids and derivativesA student wrote: 'Heating propan-1-ol with acidified potassium dichromate(VI) under reflux gives propanal.'
Why it loses marksPropanal is what you get when the product is distilled out of the mixture as it forms. Under reflux nothing escapes, so the propanal that is made first stays in contact with the excess oxidant and is oxidised again, and the final product is the carboxylic acid.
The answer that scoresUnder reflux with excess acidified dichromate(VI) the oxidation runs through both steps, primary alcohol -> aldehyde -> carboxylic acid, so propan-1-ol gives propanoic acid. To stop at the aldehyde you heat gently and distil the propanal off as it is formed, because an aldehyde boils well below the alcohol it came from.
Revise this topicCarboxylic acids and derivatives
A student wrote · Carboxylic acids and derivativesA student wrote: 'Ethyl ethanoate hydrolyses in dilute sodium hydroxide solution to give ethanoic acid and ethanol.'
Why it loses marksThe dilute alkali reacts with the carboxylic acid as it is formed, converting it into its salt. The free acid is not the product of alkaline hydrolysis, and this is the point at issue whenever a question specifies alkali rather than acid.
The answer that scoresEthyl ethanoate with dilute sodium hydroxide and heat gives sodium ethanoate and ethanol, and the hydrolysis goes to completion because the alkali removes the carboxylic acid from the equilibrium as its salt. To obtain ethanoic acid itself the mixture must be acidified afterwards. Acid hydrolysis, by contrast, is reversible and gives ethanoic acid and ethanol in an equilibrium mixture.
Revise this topicCarboxylic acids and derivatives
A student wrote · Carboxylic acids and derivativesA student wrote: 'Carboxylic acids are weaker acids than alcohols, because they contain more hydrogen atoms that the molecule can lose.'
Why it loses marksAcid strength depends on how readily the proton is released, and that in turn depends on how stable the ion left behind is, not on the number of hydrogens. The carboxylate ion is stabilised by delocalisation of the negative charge over both oxygen atoms, which makes the carboxylic acid much stronger, not weaker.
The answer that scoresA carboxylic acid is a stronger acid than an alcohol. Ethanoic acid donates a proton to water to give the ethanoate ion, in which the negative charge is delocalised over both oxygen atoms; ethanol gives the ethoxide ion, in which the charge sits on a single oxygen atom, so that ion is far less stable and the equilibrium lies much further to the left. That is why ethanoic acid fizzes with sodium carbonate and ethanol does not react with it.
Revise this topicCarboxylic acids and derivatives
A student wrote · Carboxylic acids and derivativesA student wrote: 'Ethanoic acid is reduced to ethanol by warming it with sodium tetrahydridoborate, NaBH4.'
Why it loses marksNaBH4 is a mild reducing agent and will not reduce a carboxylic acid, whose carbon is bonded to two oxygen atoms and needs a stronger reagent. NaBH4 reduces aldehydes and ketones only.
The answer that scoresEthanoic acid is reduced to ethanol, a primary alcohol, by lithium tetrahydridoaluminate, LiAlH4, in dry ether: CH3COOH + 4[H] -> CH3CH2OH + H2O. Dry ether is essential because LiAlH4 reacts violently with water, so the apparatus must be dry and no flame may be used near the ether. NaBH4 would be the correct answer only for an aldehyde or a ketone.
Revise this topicCarboxylic acids and derivatives
A student wrote · Nitrogen compoundsA student wrote: '1-Bromopropane is heated under reflux with KCN in ethanol to make propanenitrile, CH3CH2CN.'
Why it loses marksThe carbon of the cyanide group becomes part of the chain, so the nitrile has one carbon atom more than the halogenoalkane. Replacing the bromine of a three-carbon chain by CN gives a four-carbon chain, not a three-carbon one.
The answer that scores1-Bromopropane, CH3CH2CH2Br, has three carbon atoms, so the product is butanenitrile, CH3CH2CH2CN, which has four. The same counting applies after hydrolysis: butanenitrile gives butanoic acid, CH3CH2CH2COOH, not propanoic acid.
Revise this topicNitrogen compounds
A student wrote · Nitrogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Heating propanenitrile with dilute sodium hydroxide gives propanoic acid, which can be distilled off straight away.'
Why it loses marksUnder alkaline conditions the carboxylic acid that is formed is immediately neutralised by the alkali, so the product present is the carboxylate salt, sodium propanoate, and the nitrogen leaves as ammonia. There is no free carboxylic acid in the flask to distil.
The answer that scoresAlkaline hydrolysis gives CH3CH2CN + NaOH + H2O -> CH3CH2COONa + NH3. The mixture must then be acidified, CH3CH2COONa + HCl -> CH3CH2COOH + NaCl, before propanoic acid can be distilled out. With dilute acid the carboxylic acid is formed directly, together with ammonium ions.
Revise this topicNitrogen compounds
A student wrote · Nitrogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Bromoethane and ammonia react by electrophilic substitution, because the bromine atom is substituted by an amino group.'
Why it loses marksAmmonia is the electron-rich species, not the electron-poor one, so it cannot be an electrophile. The carbon it attacks is delta-positive because bromine is more electronegative than carbon, and the bromine leaves taking the bonding pair with it.
The answer that scoresThe reaction is nucleophilic substitution. A lone pair on the nitrogen atom of the ammonia attacks the delta-positive carbon atom of the C-Br bond, and the C-Br bond breaks heterolytically so that the pair of electrons goes to the bromine, which leaves as Br-. The product is the protonated amine, CH3CH2NH3+, which loses a proton to give ethylamine; a second molecule of ammonia removes the HBr.
Revise this topicNitrogen compounds
A student wrote · Nitrogen compoundsA student wrote: 'In the reaction of propanone with HCN, the hydrogen cyanide molecule itself is the nucleophile, so no KCN is needed and the addition is fast.'
Why it loses marksHCN is a weak acid and is only slightly ionised, so the concentration of cyanide ions in the mixture is far too low for the reaction to be fast. The nucleophile is the cyanide ion, CN-, not the molecule.
The answer that scoresThe cyanide ion is the nucleophile: a lone pair on its carbon atom attacks the delta-positive carbon of the C=O group, the pi bond of the C=O moves onto the oxygen, and the negative oxygen then takes a proton. A small amount of KCN supplies CN- ions so the reaction goes at a usable rate, and because the CN- is regenerated at the end of the mechanism only a catalytic amount is needed. The product is 2-hydroxy-2-methylpropanenitrile, CH3C(OH)(CH3)CN.
Revise this topicNitrogen compounds
A student wrote · PolymerisationA student wrote: 'Poly(chloroethene) is made from chloroethane, CH3CH2Cl, and the repeat unit is -CH2-CHCl-.'
Why it loses marksThe monomer is wrong. Chloroethane is saturated, so it has no C=C double bond and cannot undergo addition polymerisation. Only a molecule with a C=C can open up and join to the next unit.
The answer that scoresThe monomer is chloroethene, CH2=CHCl, also called vinyl chloride. It is unsaturated, so the C=C opens and the units join to give the repeat unit -CH2-CHCl-. Chloroethane has no double bond, so it cannot be the monomer and the repeat unit could not be formed from it.
Revise this topicPolymerisation
A student wrote · PolymerisationA student drew the repeat unit of the polymer from ethene as (-CH2=CH2-)n, keeping the double bond inside the brackets.
Why it loses marksThat is the monomer with brackets round it, not a repeat unit. In addition polymerisation the pi bond opens and each carbon forms a new single bond to a carbon of the next monomer, so the backbone of the polymer contains only C-C single bonds.
The answer that scoresThe repeat unit is (-CH2-CH2-)n, with a single bond between the two carbons and the two joining bonds drawn through the brackets. The polymer is saturated, which is why poly(ethene) does not decolourise bromine water while ethene does.
Revise this topicPolymerisation
A student wrote · PolymerisationA student wrote: 'Burning waste poly(chloroethene) produces carbon dioxide and water, which are the same harmless products as burning poly(ethene).'
Why it loses marksPVC contains chlorine, so its combustion also produces hydrogen chloride. That gas is acidic, corrosive and toxic, and the answer misses both it and the carbon monoxide formed when any plastic is burned in a limited supply of air.
The answer that scoresBurning PVC gives carbon dioxide and water, but also hydrogen chloride, because the polymer contains chlorine. The hydrogen chloride is acidic and corrosive and dissolves in rain to give acid deposition, and incomplete combustion also produces toxic carbon monoxide and soot. Incinerators therefore burn PVC in a controlled furnace and pass the flue gases through an alkaline scrubber to neutralise the hydrogen chloride: Ca(OH)2 + 2HCl -> CaCl2 + 2H2O.
Revise this topicPolymerisation
A student wrote · PolymerisationA student wrote: 'Addition polymerisation of 10.0 g of ethene gives less than 10.0 g of poly(ethene), because water is lost when the monomers join.'
Why it loses marksNothing is lost in an addition polymerisation. Water is lost in a condensation polymerisation, where a small molecule is eliminated each time a link forms, but here the C=C simply opens and the units add together.
The answer that scoresThe theoretical mass of polymer equals the mass of monomer, so 10.0 g of ethene gives up to 10.0 g of poly(ethene). The empirical formula is unchanged, CH2, and any shortfall in a real plant is the unreacted monomer that was recovered rather than a product that was lost.
Revise this topicPolymerisation
A student wrote · Organic synthesisA student wrote: 'To convert propan-1-ol into propanal I would heat it with acidified potassium dichromate(VI) under reflux.'
Why it loses marksReflux keeps the aldehyde in the flask in contact with hot oxidising agent, and an aldehyde still has a hydrogen on the carbonyl carbon, so it is oxidised straight on to propanoic acid. The student has named the right reagent but the wrong way of running the reaction.
The answer that scoresHeat propan-1-ol with acidified potassium dichromate(VI) and distil the product out as it forms. Propanal boils at a lower temperature than propan-1-ol, so it leaves the mixture before the dichromate can oxidise it further to propanoic acid. Reserve reflux for the day you want the carboxylic acid.
Revise this topicOrganic synthesis
A student wrote · Organic synthesisA student wrote: 'Ethanoic acid can be reduced to ethanol by warming it with NaBH4 in water.'
Why it loses marksNaBH4 is a mild reducing agent that reduces aldehydes and ketones only. It is not strong enough to reduce a carboxylic acid, and a mark scheme that asks for the reduction of a COOH group will not accept it.
The answer that scoresUse LiAlH4 in dry ether, which reduces a carboxylic acid to the primary alcohol. It also reduces aldehydes, ketones, esters and nitriles, so it cannot be used when another group has to be left untouched.
Revise this topicOrganic synthesis
A student wrote · Organic synthesisA student wrote: 'Bromoethane reacts with KCN to give ethanenitrile, which is then hydrolysed to ethanoic acid.'
Why it loses marksThe carbon of the cyanide ion becomes part of the chain, so the product has one more carbon than the halogenoalkane. Bromoethane has two carbons, so the nitrile has three and the acid has three; two different compounds have been given the wrong names.
The answer that scoresBromoethane and KCN in aqueous ethanol, heated under reflux, give propanenitrile, CH3CH2CN. Hydrolysis with dilute hydrochloric acid under reflux then gives propanoic acid, CH3CH2COOH. Count the carbons across the arrow: C2 to C3 is the whole point of the step.
Revise this topicOrganic synthesis
A student wrote · Organic synthesisA student wrote: 'Heating 1-bromobutane with NaOH(aq) gives butan-1-ol as the only product, because the hydroxide ion substitutes for the bromine.'
Why it loses marksThe same hot alkali also brings about elimination, in which the hydroxide removes a hydrogen from the carbon next to the C-Br and the bromine leaves with it to form a double bond. With secondary and tertiary halogenoalkanes this competing reaction can even give more alkene than alcohol.
The answer that scoresHeating 1-bromobutane with NaOH(aq) gives butan-1-ol as the main product, contaminated with but-1-ene formed by elimination. If the alkene is what you want, change the solvent: KOH in ethanol makes elimination the main reaction and the alkene the main product.
Revise this topicOrganic synthesis
A student wrote · Analytical techniquesA student wrote: 'The molecular ion peak is the tallest peak in the mass spectrum, so the peak at m/e 31 in the spectrum of ethanol is the molecular ion and ethanol has Mr 31.'
Why it loses marksThe tallest peak is the base peak, which is the most stable cation formed. In an alcohol the molecular ion carries so much surplus energy that it fragments readily, so the base peak is a fragment and the molecular ion is one of the smaller peaks. Reading Mr from the base peak gives a value that is far too low.
The answer that scoresIdentify the molecular ion as the peak at the highest m/e value in the spectrum, ignoring the small [M + 1] and [M + 2] isotope peaks just above it. In ethanol that peak is at m/e 46, so Mr is 46, which matches C2H5OH ((2 x 12) + (6 x 1) + 16 = 46). The peak at m/e 31 is the base peak and is the fragment ion CH2OH+, formed when the molecular ion loses a methyl radical, and 31 + 15 = 46 confirms it.
Revise this topicAnalytical techniques
A student wrote · Analytical techniquesA student wrote: 'The mass spectrum shows a peak two mass units above the molecular ion that is about half as tall as the molecular ion peak, so the compound contains one chlorine atom.'
Why it loses marksThe two halogen ratios have been muddled. An [M + 2] peak about half the height of M+ points to bromine, whose isotopes are present in almost equal abundance. Chlorine-37 is only about one third as abundant as chlorine-35, so one chlorine atom gives an [M + 2] peak about one third of the height of M+.
The answer that scoresOne chlorine atom gives an [M + 2] peak about one third the height of the M+ peak, because chlorine is roughly 75% chlorine-35 and 25% chlorine-37. One bromine atom gives an [M + 2] peak about the same height as the M+ peak, because bromine is almost exactly 50% bromine-79 and 50% bromine-81. A peak at about half the height of M+ therefore indicates one bromine atom, and if the compound also contained two chlorine atoms the spectrum would show an M+, M+2, M+4 pattern in the ratio 9 : 6 : 1.
Revise this topicAnalytical techniques
A student wrote · Analytical techniquesA student wrote: 'The infrared spectrum of ethanoic acid has a strong absorption at about 3000 cm-1, so that is the C-H bond, and the sharp peak at about 1710 cm-1 shows the alcohol group.'
Why it loses marksBoth assignments are wrong. The broad absorption of a carboxylic acid runs from about 2500 to 3300 cm-1 and is the O-H of the acid, overlapping the much weaker C-H absorptions at about 2840-3100 cm-1. A sharp strong absorption at about 1710 cm-1 is a C=O group, not an O-H group.
The answer that scoresThe broad absorption between 2500 and 3300 cm-1 is the O-H of the carboxylic acid, and the sharp strong absorption at about 1710 cm-1 is the C=O. It is the combination that matters: a broad O-H with no C=O would be an alcohol, whereas a broad O-H together with a C=O is a carboxylic acid. An O-H group never gives a sharp, narrow absorption, and a carbonyl group never gives a broad one.
Revise this topicAnalytical techniques
A student wrote · Analytical techniquesA student wrote: 'The mass spectrum of copper shows lines at m/e 63 and m/e 65, in the ratio 69.2 : 30.8, so the relative atomic mass of copper is (63 + 65) / 2 = 64.0.'
Why it loses marksThe relative atomic mass is a weighted mean, so the more abundant isotope must pull the answer towards its own mass. Averaging the two isotope masses gives each isotope equal weight and ignores the abundances altogether, so it is wrong whenever the two isotopes are not equally abundant.
The answer that scoresMultiply each isotope mass by its fractional abundance and add: Ar = (63 x 69.2 + 65 x 30.8) / 100 = (4359.6 + 2002) / 100 = 63.6, to one decimal place. The answer lies closer to 63 than to 65 because copper-63 is the more abundant isotope, and it is not a whole number precisely because it is a weighted mean.
Revise this topicAnalytical techniques
A Level Content
A student wrote · Chemical energeticsA student wrote: 'The lattice energy of sodium chloride is +788 kJ mol-1, because energy has to be put in to separate the ions in the lattice.'
Why it loses marksThe student has used the opposite definition from the one used in Born-Haber cycles. Taking lattice energy as the change from gaseous ions to the solid lattice makes it exothermic, and a positive value would reverse every arrow in the cycle and give the wrong answer for the unknown quantity.
The answer that scoresLattice energy is the enthalpy change when one mole of a solid ionic lattice is formed from its gaseous ions, so for sodium chloride it is -788 kJ mol-1; energy is released as the oppositely charged ions come together. Separating the lattice takes in the same amount of energy, +788 kJ mol-1, and that is the endothermic step you draw in an enthalpy of solution cycle, written as -delta H_latt.
Revise this topicChemical energetics
A student wrote · Chemical energeticsA student calculating the lattice energy of magnesium oxide wrote: 'The ionisation term is 2 x 738 = 1476 kJ mol-1, because magnesium forms a 2+ ion and loses two electrons.'
Why it loses marksThe two electrons removed from a magnesium atom are not removed equally easily. The second electron is taken from an already positive ion, so it costs much more energy than the first, and doubling the first ionisation energy underestimates the ionisation term by hundreds of kilojoules per mole.
The answer that scoresUse the first and second ionisation energies separately and add them: +738 + +1451 = +2189 kJ mol-1 for Mg(g) -> Mg2+(g) + 2e-. The same principle applies to a 2- anion such as oxide, where the first electron affinity is negative (about -142 kJ mol-1) but the second is positive (about +798 kJ mol-1), so the two must be added with their own signs.
Revise this topicChemical energetics
A student wrote · Chemical energeticsA student wrote: 'In the Haber process the temperature should be as low as possible, because delta G becomes more negative as the temperature falls, so running the plant at 300 K gives the best feasible yield.'
Why it loses marksThe thermodynamic conclusion is correct but the industrial conclusion is not. Lowering the temperature makes delta G more negative, but it also makes the reaction far slower, and a reaction that is thermodynamically feasible but takes years is useless in a plant.
The answer that scoresA low temperature does make the Haber reaction more feasible, because delta H is negative and delta S is negative so T delta S is a positive term that is subtracted and grows with temperature. But feasibility is not rate, so the plant uses a compromise temperature of about 700 K, an iron catalyst to speed up the reaction, a high pressure to favour the side with fewer gas molecules, and continuous removal of the ammonia to shift the position of equilibrium.
Revise this topicChemical energetics
A student wrote · Chemical energeticsA student wrote: 'For CaCO3(s) -> CaO(s) + CO2(g), delta S = +160 kJ K-1 mol-1, so at 298 K delta G = 178 - 298 x 160 = -47 502 kJ mol-1 and the reaction is feasible.'
Why it loses marksThe entropy change has been left in J K-1 mol-1 while the enthalpy change is in kJ mol-1, so the temperature term is a thousand times too large. The arithmetic is internally consistent but the units are mixed, which produces a nonsense value: a decomposition that does not happen at 298 K has been called feasible.
The answer that scoresConvert first: delta S = +160.4 J K-1 mol-1 = +0.1604 kJ K-1 mol-1, so T delta S = 298 x 0.1604 = 47.8 kJ mol-1 and delta G = 178 - 47.8 = +130.2 kJ mol-1. The positive value is exactly what the sign rules predict for a reaction with positive delta H and positive delta S at a low temperature, and the decomposition only becomes feasible above T = 178 / 0.1604 = 1110 K.
Revise this topicChemical energetics
A student wrote · ElectrochemistryA student wrote: 'E(Zn2+/Zn) = -0.76 V and E(Cu2+/Cu) = +0.34 V, so E(cell) = -0.76 - 0.34 = -1.10 V and the zinc-copper cell cannot work.'
Why it loses marksThe subtraction has been done in the wrong order and the potentials have been treated as if the cell were written with the copper being oxidised. The cell potential is the potential of the couple that is actually reduced minus the potential of the couple that is actually oxidised, so the two numbers must be deducted in the order the reaction runs.
The answer that scoresZinc is oxidised and copper(II) ions are reduced, so E(cell standard) = E(Cu2+/Cu) - E(Zn2+/Zn) = +0.34 - (-0.76) = +1.10 V. The value is positive, so the cell works, zinc is the negative electrode and electrons flow from zinc to copper through the external circuit. Subtracting the other way round simply describes the reverse reaction, and its negative value correctly says that the reverse reaction is not feasible.
Revise this topicElectrochemistry
A student wrote · ElectrochemistryA student wrote: 'Diluting the copper(II) sulphate in a copper half-cell raises E(Cu2+/Cu) above +0.34 V, because there are fewer Cu2+ ions to be reduced, so there is less to hold the reduction back.'
Why it loses marksDiluting lowers the concentration of the oxidised species, which makes reduction less favourable, so E falls rather than rises. The direction of the change is set by which species is on the oxidised side of the half-equation.
The answer that scoresFor Cu2+ + 2e- <-> Cu the Nernst equation is E = 0.34 + (0.059 / 2) log[Cu2+], so lowering [Cu2+] from 1.00 to 0.0100 mol dm-3 gives E = 0.34 + 0.0295 x (-2) = +0.28 V. Increasing the concentration of the oxidised species makes E more positive, and increasing the concentration of the reduced species makes E less positive.
Revise this topicElectrochemistry
A student wrote · ElectrochemistryA student wrote: 'Concentrated aqueous sodium chloride gives oxygen at the anode, because the standard electrode potential for the reduction of oxygen, +1.23 V, is less positive than that for chlorine, +1.36 V, so the oxygen couple is the easier one to reverse.'
Why it loses marksThe comparison of the two standard values is right, but those values are both quoted for 1.00 mol dm-3, and they do not stay 0.13 V apart when the chloride concentration is changed. In concentrated brine the chloride concentration is far above 1.00 mol dm-3, which lowers the potential of the chlorine couple and reverses which one is easier to reverse.
The answer that scoresIn dilute sodium chloride the chloride concentration is far below 1.00 mol dm-3, so the oxygen couple is the one reached and oxygen is given off from 2H2O -> O2 + 4H+ + 4e-. In concentrated brine the high chloride concentration makes the chlorine couple easier to reverse, so chlorine is the anode product from 2Cl- -> Cl2 + 2e-. Hydrogen is produced at the cathode in both cases, because water is reduced rather than sodium ions, E(Na+/Na) = -2.71 V.
Revise this topicElectrochemistry
A student wrote · ElectrochemistryA student wrote: 'A current of 2.00 A was passed through copper(II) sulphate for 30.0 minutes, giving 3600 / 96500 = 0.0373 mol of electrons, so the mass of copper deposited is 0.0373 x 63.5 = 2.37 g.'
Why it loses marksThe mole calculation for the electrons is correct, but the student has assumed one electron per copper atom. The half-equation Cu2+ + 2e- -> Cu needs two electrons for each atom, so the moles of copper are half the moles of electrons, and the answer is roughly double what it should be.
The answer that scoresMoles of electrons = It / F = (2.00 x 1800) / 96500 = 0.0373 mol. From Cu2+ + 2e- -> Cu, n = 2, so moles of copper = 0.0373 / 2 = 0.0187 mol and the mass deposited is 0.0187 x 63.5 = 1.19 g. Always take n from the half-equation of the substance you are weighing or measuring.
Revise this topicElectrochemistry
A student wrote · EquilibriaA student wrote: 'Ethanoic acid has a concentration of 0.100 mol dm-3, so [H+] = 0.100 mol dm-3 and the pH is 1.00.'
Why it loses marksEthanoic acid is a weak acid and is only partly dissociated, so treating it as though every molecule released a hydrogen ion gives a pH that is nearly two units too low.
The answer that scoresUse Ka rather than the concentration of the acid: [H+] = sqrt(Ka x c) = sqrt(1.8 x 10^-5 x 0.100) = sqrt(1.8 x 10^-6) = 1.34 x 10^-3 mol dm-3, so pH = -log10(1.34 x 10^-3) = 2.87. Only about 1.3 per cent of the acid is dissociated, which is what makes the approximation valid.
Revise this topicEquilibria
A student wrote · EquilibriaA student wrote: 'A 0.0100 mol dm-3 solution of barium hydroxide has [OH-] = 0.0100 mol dm-3, so [H+] = 1.00 x 10^-12 mol dm-3 and the pH is 12.00.'
Why it loses marksBarium hydroxide is Ba(OH)2, so each formula unit gives two hydroxide ions and the hydroxide concentration is twice the concentration of the alkali. Getting [OH-] wrong by a factor of two moves the pH by 0.30.
The answer that scores[OH-] = 2 x 0.0100 = 0.0200 mol dm-3, so [H+] = Kw / [OH-] = 1.00 x 10^-14 / 0.0200 = 5.00 x 10^-13 mol dm-3 and pH = -log10(5.00 x 10^-13) = 12.30. Always look at the formula of the alkali before converting.
Revise this topicEquilibria
A student wrote · EquilibriaA student wrote: 'Silver chloride is more soluble in 0.100 mol dm-3 sodium chloride solution than in pure water, because the extra chloride ions pull more silver chloride into solution.'
Why it loses marksThis is the common ion effect the wrong way round. Adding a product of the dissolution equilibrium shifts it to the left, so the solubility falls rather than rises. The ion product [Ag+][Cl-] cannot exceed Ksp in a saturated solution.
The answer that scoresKsp = [Ag+][Cl-] = 1.8 x 10^-10 mol2 dm-6. In 0.100 mol dm-3 sodium chloride solution, [Cl-] is fixed at 0.100 mol dm-3 by the sodium chloride, so [Ag+] = 1.8 x 10^-10 / 0.100 = 1.8 x 10^-9 mol dm-3, compared with 1.34 x 10^-5 mol dm-3 in pure water. The solubility is about seven thousand times lower, because the extra chloride ions push the equilibrium AgCl(s) <-> Ag+(aq) + Cl-(aq) to the left and precipitate silver chloride.
Revise this topicEquilibria
A student wrote · EquilibriaA student wrote: 'Kpc = 4.0 for a solute between ethoxyethane and water, so when 100 cm3 of aqueous solution is shaken with 100 cm3 of ethoxyethane, 4.0 mol of the solute moves into the ethoxyethane for every 1.0 mol left in the water.'
Why it loses marksKpc is a ratio of equilibrium concentrations, not of amounts in moles. The ratio of amounts happens to equal Kpc here only because the two volumes are equal, and treating Kpc as a ratio of moles gives the wrong answer as soon as the volumes differ.
The answer that scoresWrite Kpc = [solute in ethoxyethane] / [solute in water] and let the equilibrium concentrations be 4c and c. With equal volumes, 4c x 0.100 + c x 0.100 = 2.00 x 10^-3 mol, so c = 0.00400 mol dm-3 and 4c = 0.0160 mol dm-3. The amounts are 1.60 x 10^-3 mol in the ethoxyethane and 0.400 x 10^-3 mol in the water.
Revise this topicEquilibria
A student wrote · Reaction kineticsA student wrote: 'For the reaction 2A + B -> C, the rate equation is rate = k[A]2[B], because the order of each reactant is just the number in front of it in the equation.'
Why it loses marksOrders are measured by experiment, and the numbers in a balanced equation only tell you the overall stoichiometry. The rate equation comes from the rate-determining step of the mechanism, so a reactant that reacts in a fast step after the slow one has an order of zero no matter how large its coefficient.
The answer that scoresThe rate equation must be deduced from experimental data or from the mechanism, and it can be anything the data show. If doubling [B] makes no difference to the rate, the reaction is zero order in B and B does not appear in the rate equation at all. Only the species involved in the rate-determining step (and in any faster steps before it) appear.
Revise this topicReaction kinetics
A student wrote · Reaction kineticsA student wrote: 'To find the initial rate I timed how long it took for all the reactant to be used up, then divided the starting concentration by that time.'
Why it loses marksDividing the total concentration change by the total time gives an average rate over the whole reaction, not the initial rate. The rate falls steadily as the reactants are used up, so an average rate from a reaction that took a long time to finish is far smaller than the rate at the start, and comparing averages from different experiments gives the wrong orders.
The answer that scoresTake the gradient of the concentration-time curve at t = 0, which is the tangent drawn at the start, or use a clock method that times a small, fixed change at the beginning of the reaction. Change one concentration at a time, keep every other concentration the same, hold the temperature constant and repeat the runs, so that each measured rate belongs to known starting concentrations.
Revise this topicReaction kinetics
A student wrote · Reaction kineticsA student wrote: 'Doubling the concentration of a reactant doubles the rate, so the reaction must be first order in that reactant.'
Why it loses marksDoubling the concentration doubles the rate only when the order really is 1. If the order is 2, doubling the concentration multiplies the rate by 4; if the order is 0, the rate does not change at all. The size of the change is the evidence, so it has to be measured rather than assumed.
The answer that scoresCompare the ratio of the two rates with the ratio of the two concentrations. A concentration ratio of 2 with a rate ratio of 2 is first order, a rate ratio of 4 is second order, and a rate ratio of 1 is zero order. If the concentration is multiplied by 3, the rate multiplies by 3 for first order and by 9 for second order.
Revise this topicReaction kinetics
A student wrote · Reaction kineticsA student wrote: 'The half-life of a first-order reaction gets longer as the reaction goes on, because there is less reactant left to react.'
Why it loses marksThat is the rule for a second-order reaction, whose half-life doubles each time the concentration halves. A first-order reaction loses the same fraction of whatever is left in each half-life, so its half-life is constant and independent of the starting concentration. Half-lives that change prove the reaction is not first order.
The answer that scoresFor a first-order reaction the half-life is constant, and k = 0.693 / t1/2. Starting from 0.800 mol dm-3, the concentration falls to 0.400, then 0.200, then 0.100 mol dm-3 in equal intervals of time. If the half-life measured from the graph grows as the reaction proceeds, the reaction is second order, and the constant half-life test has failed.
Revise this topicReaction kinetics
A student wrote · Group 2A student wrote: 'Barium carbonate is more thermally stable than magnesium carbonate because barium is more reactive and forms a stronger bond to the oxygen.'
Why it loses marksThe bond that breaks when a carbonate decomposes is the C-O bond inside the carbonate ion, not the ionic bond between the metal ion and the anion, so the strength of the barium-oxygen attraction is irrelevant. The real reason is that the larger Ba2+ ion has a lower charge density and polarises the carbonate ion less, so the anion is left less distorted and more energy is needed to break it down.
The answer that scoresThermal stability increases down the group because polarising power falls as the cation radius increases. Mg2+ is small and highly polarising, so it distorts the carbonate ion strongly, weakens a C-O bond and lowers the decomposition temperature. Ba2+ is large and only weakly polarising, so the carbonate ion is distorted less, its C-O bonds are left stronger and a much higher temperature is needed before carbon dioxide is released.
Revise this topicGroup 2
A student wrote · Group 2A student wrote: 'Magnesium hydroxide is insoluble in water because its enthalpy change of solution is endothermic, and a compound with an endothermic enthalpy change of solution cannot dissolve.'
Why it loses marksEnthalpy is not the only factor. Dissolving a solid also increases the entropy of the system, because a rigid lattice becomes freely moving hydrated ions, and for many salts that entropy increase is enough to drive dissolving even when the enthalpy change is endothermic - ammonium nitrate and potassium chloride dissolve readily in water for exactly that reason. The comparison of lattice enthalpy with enthalpy of hydration explains the trend down the group, not whether a compound dissolves at all.
The answer that scoresMagnesium hydroxide is only sparingly soluble because dissolving it is endothermic, so it is not favoured by the enthalpy change; its low solubility is the reason its saturated solution contains so few hydroxide ions. Going down the group the lattice enthalpy falls faster than the enthalpy of hydration of the cation, so the enthalpy change of solution becomes less endothermic and finally exothermic, and the hydroxides become more soluble.
Revise this topicGroup 2
A student wrote · Group 2A student wrote: 'The Group 2 sulfates become more soluble down the group because the lattice enthalpy falls faster than the enthalpy of hydration, just as it does for the hydroxides.'
Why it loses marksThis applies the hydroxide explanation to the sulfates, where the opposite is true. The sulfate ion is large, so the lattice enthalpy of a Group 2 sulfate depends only slightly on the size of the cation and falls slowly, while the enthalpy of hydration of the cation falls steeply because it is the small, highly charged cation that binds water molecules most strongly.
The answer that scoresThe enthalpy of hydration of the cation falls faster than the lattice enthalpy for the sulfates, because the large sulfate ion means the lattice is not very sensitive to the size of the cation. The enthalpy change of solution therefore becomes less exothermic and eventually endothermic down the group, dissolving becomes less favourable, and solubility falls - which is why barium sulfate is effectively insoluble while magnesium sulfate is very soluble.
Revise this topicGroup 2
A student wrote · Group 2A student wrote: 'I added barium nitrate solution to an unknown solution, got a white precipitate, so the unknown must contain sulfate ions.'
Why it loses marksSeveral anions give a white precipitate with Ba2+ ions. Carbonate ions give white barium carbonate and sulfite ions give white barium sulfite, so without acidifying the solution first the test does not distinguish between them and the conclusion is unsafe.
The answer that scoresAcidify the unknown solution with dilute hydrochloric acid first - this removes carbonate and sulfite ions by converting them to carbon dioxide and sulphur dioxide - then add barium chloride or barium nitrate solution. A white precipitate that does not dissolve in the dilute acid is barium sulfate, so the solution contains sulfate ions; barium carbonate and barium sulfite would have dissolved in the acid and given no precipitate.
Revise this topicGroup 2
A student wrote · Chemistry of transition elementsA student wrote: 'Zinc is a transition element because it is in the d-block and it has 3d electrons.'
Why it loses marksThe definition is about the ion, not the atom. Zinc forms only Zn2+, which has the configuration [Ar]3d10, so the d sub-shell is full; an ion must have an incomplete d sub-shell for the element to be a transition element.
The answer that scoresA transition element is a d-block element which forms one or more stable ions with incomplete d orbitals. Zinc is a d-block element but not a transition element, because its only common ion, Zn2+, has a full 3d sub-shell with the configuration [Ar]3d10. Scandium is the other exception: it forms Sc3+, which is [Ar]3d0, with an empty d sub-shell.
Revise this topicChemistry of transition elements
A student wrote · Chemistry of transition elementsA student wrote: 'A complex is coloured because the d electrons absorb light and jump to a higher energy level, so the colour seen is the colour of the light absorbed.'
Why it loses marksThe colour seen is the light that passes through, not the light that is absorbed. The eye sees the mixture of wavelengths the solution does not take out, which is the complementary colour of the light absorbed.
The answer that scoresThe ligands split the degenerate d orbitals into two non-degenerate sets separated by an energy gap dE. An electron absorbs a photon of frequency matching dE and is promoted, so the solution absorbs part of the visible spectrum. The colour observed is the complementary colour, the light that is not absorbed: a solution that absorbs orange light looks blue, which is why [Cu(H2O)6]2+ solutions, which absorb mainly in the red, look pale blue.
Revise this topicChemistry of transition elements
A student wrote · Chemistry of transition elementsA student wrote: 'When a few drops of aqueous ammonia are added to copper(II) sulphate solution the pale blue precipitate that appears is [Cu(NH3)4(H2O)2]2+.'
Why it loses marksAmmonia solution contains hydroxide ions, so the first product of adding a little ammonia to a copper(II) solution is the insoluble hydroxide, not the ammonia complex. The complex only forms when enough ammonia is present to dissolve the precipitate.
The answer that scoresWith a few drops of aqueous ammonia a pale blue precipitate of copper(II) hydroxide forms: Cu2+(aq) + 2OH-(aq) -> Cu(OH)2(s). Adding excess ammonia dissolves the precipitate and gives a deep blue solution containing the complex [Cu(NH3)4(H2O)2]2+: [Cu(H2O)6]2+ + 4NH3 <-> [Cu(NH3)4(H2O)2]2+ + 4H2O. Only four of the six water ligands are replaced, so the coordination number stays at 6.
Revise this topicChemistry of transition elements
A student wrote · Chemistry of transition elementsA student wrote: 'Copper(II) ions cannot oxidise iodide ions, because E(Cu2+/Cu+) = +0.15 V is less positive than E(I2/I-) = +0.54 V.'
Why it loses marksThe student applied the E values to the free copper(I) ion and stopped there. Copper(I) iodide is very insoluble, and a precipitate that removes a product of the half-equation changes the effective potential of that couple.
The answer that scoresOn the free-ion potentials alone the reaction would not be feasible, because 0.15 - 0.54 = -0.39 V. It happens anyway because copper(I) iodide is precipitated, and removing Cu+ from solution pulls the equilibrium over and makes the effective potential of the copper couple much more positive. The reaction is 2Cu2+ + 4I- -> 2CuI + I2, and the iodine formed is titrated with sodium thiosulphate: 2S2O3^2- + I2 -> S4O6^2- + 2I-.
Revise this topicChemistry of transition elements
A student wrote · An introduction to A Level organic chemistryA student wrote: 'Benzene reacts with bromine in the dark to give 1,2-dibromocyclohexane, in a reaction just like the addition of bromine to cyclohexene.'
Why it loses marksBenzene is not a cycloalkene with three localised double bonds. Its six electrons are delocalised, which makes it about 150 kJ mol-1 more stable than a structure with alternating double bonds, so the ring resists addition. Bromine water is not decolourised by benzene, and bromination does not happen without a halogen carrier.
The answer that scoresBenzene and bromine react by electrophilic substitution, and only in the presence of a halogen carrier such as iron(III) bromide, which polarises the bromine molecule. The delocalised ring attacks the polarised bromine, giving a delocalised carbocation intermediate, and a hydrogen ion is then lost to restore the aromatic ring: C6H6 + Br2 -> C6H5Br + HBr. The product is bromobenzene, not a dibromocyclohexane, because losing H+ keeps the delocalisation energy that an addition would destroy.
Revise this topicAn introduction to A Level organic chemistry
A student wrote · An introduction to A Level organic chemistryA student wrote: 'The two enantiomers of butan-2-ol have different boiling points and react differently with sodium metal, so a racemic mixture can be separated by fractional distillation.'
Why it loses marksEnantiomers have the same atoms joined in the same order, so all their ordinary physical properties are identical - boiling point, melting point, density and solubility - and their reactions with achiral reagents such as sodium or hydroxide are identical too. Distillation therefore cannot separate them.
The answer that scoresEnantiomers differ only in a chiral environment: they rotate the plane of plane-polarised light by equal amounts in opposite directions, and they behave differently towards enzymes and receptors. A racemic mixture is optically inactive because the rotations cancel. To separate the enantiomers you must use a chiral method, such as chromatography on a chiral stationary phase, or reaction with a single pure enantiomer of another compound to form salts that are no longer mirror images and so have different physical properties.
Revise this topicAn introduction to A Level organic chemistry
A student wrote · An introduction to A Level organic chemistryA student drew the electrophilic addition of HBr to propene with the curly arrow starting on the hydrogen atom of HBr and pointing at the carbon of the C=C, and said the major product is 1-bromopropane.
Why it loses marksA curly arrow must start where the electrons are, and hydrogen has no lone pair - the electrons are in the middle of the H-Br bond. Two arrows are needed: one from the pi bond of the C=C to the hydrogen, and one from the H-Br bond to the bromine. The product is also wrong, because the hydrogen adds to the carbon that already carries more hydrogens.
The answer that scoresDraw the arrow from the pi bond of the C=C to the hydrogen atom of H-Br, and a second arrow from the H-Br bond to the bromine. That gives the secondary carbocation, CH3CH+CH3, and a bromide ion, and the bromide then attacks the positive carbon to give 2-bromopropane. The secondary carbocation is preferred because the two alkyl groups release electron density inductively and stabilise the positive charge, and this is Markovnikov's rule.
Revise this topicAn introduction to A Level organic chemistry
A student wrote · An introduction to A Level organic chemistryA student wrote: 'Chlorobenzene reacts with hot aqueous sodium hydroxide in the same way as 1-chlorobutane, giving phenol and sodium chloride.'
Why it loses marksIn chlorobenzene the chlorine is joined to an sp2 ring carbon, and a lone pair on the chlorine is partly delocalised into the ring, so the C-Cl bond is shorter and stronger and the ring repels a nucleophile. The halogenoalkane hydrolysis reaction does not happen at a useful rate.
The answer that scoresChlorobenzene does not hydrolyse with hot aqueous sodium hydroxide, so phenol is not made that way. Industrially phenol is made from benzene by the cumene process: Friedel-Crafts alkylation of benzene with propene gives cumene, oxidation with air gives cumene hydroperoxide, and acid-catalysed cleavage gives phenol and propanone. The mechanism you learn for halogenoalkanes, nucleophilic substitution at a saturated sp3 carbon, does not apply to a halogenoarene.
Revise this topicAn introduction to A Level organic chemistry
A student wrote · HydrocarbonsA student wrote: 'Benzene decolourises bromine water quickly, because it contains three C=C double bonds and each one adds a molecule of bromine.'
Why it loses marksBenzene does not contain three separate double bonds, and it does not decolourise bromine water in the dark. Its six pi electrons are delocalised over the whole ring, so all six carbon-carbon bonds are identical and about 0.139 nm long, and addition would destroy that delocalisation. Adding bromine needs a halogen carrier, and even then the bromine attacks by substitution.
The answer that scoresBenzene has a delocalised pi system rather than three isolated double bonds, so it does not decolourise bromine water in the dark. To brominate the ring, bromine is used with a halogen carrier such as anhydrous AlBr3, and the reaction is electrophilic substitution giving bromobenzene and hydrogen bromide. An alkene such as cyclohexene does decolourise bromine water, and it does so by electrophilic addition.
Revise this topicHydrocarbons
A student wrote · HydrocarbonsA student wrote: 'Methylbenzene reacts with chlorine in the presence of anhydrous aluminium chloride and ultraviolet light to give (chloromethyl)benzene.'
Why it loses marksThe two sets of conditions do different jobs and must not be combined. Anhydrous AlCl3 is a halogen carrier, so it puts the chlorine into the aromatic ring; ultraviolet light starts free-radical substitution at the side chain. Using both at once gives a mixture of ring-chlorinated and side-chain-chlorinated products and no clean product at all.
The answer that scoresFor (chloromethyl)benzene, C6H5CH2Cl, use chlorine with methylbenzene and ultraviolet light, and leave the aluminium chloride out, so that the substitution is free-radical at the side-chain carbon. For chlorination of the ring, use chlorine with anhydrous AlCl3 in the dark, away from ultraviolet light: the methyl group is a 2,4-director, so the products are 1-chloro-2-methylbenzene and 1-chloro-4-methylbenzene, with hydrogen chloride as the by-product.
Revise this topicHydrocarbons
A student wrote · HydrocarbonsA student wrote: 'The nitro group in nitrobenzene is a 2,4-director because it makes the ring more reactive, so a second nitration goes at the 2- and 4-positions.'
Why it loses marks-NO2 withdraws electron density from the ring, so it deactivates the ring: nitrobenzene is less reactive than benzene, not more. It is a 3-director, so the second nitro group goes mainly to the 3-position, and the second nitration needs a hotter and more concentrated nitrating mixture than the first.
The answer that scores-NO2 is a 3-director and it deactivates the ring. It removes electron density especially from the 2-, 4- and 6-positions, so the arenium ion formed by attack at the 3-position avoids putting the positive charge on the carbon that carries the nitro group and is therefore the most stable intermediate. Nitration of nitrobenzene gives mainly 1,3-dinitrobenzene, and it is slower than the nitration of benzene.
Revise this topicHydrocarbons
A student wrote · HydrocarbonsA student wrote: 'In the mechanism of the nitration of benzene, the nitrogen atom of the nitronium ion attacks the ring, and the hydrogen is then removed as a hydride ion.'
Why it loses marksThe direction is the other way round: the electrophile is attacked by the ring, so a lone pair of the delocalised pi system forms the new bond to the positively charged nitrogen. The hydrogen also does not leave as a hydride ion; it leaves as H+, because the pair of electrons in the C-H bond goes back into the ring to restore the delocalised pi system.
The answer that scoresThe pi electrons of the ring attack the NO2+ ion, forming a new carbon-nitrogen bond and giving an arenium ion in which the positive charge is delocalised over the five remaining carbon atoms. The electrons of the C-H bond on that same carbon then move back into the ring and a proton, H+, is lost, which restores the delocalised ring and gives nitrobenzene. The H+ reacts with HSO4- to regenerate the sulphuric acid, so H2SO4 is a catalyst.
Revise this topicHydrocarbons
A student wrote · Halogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Chlorobenzene hydrolyses when it is heated under reflux with aqueous sodium hydroxide, giving phenol, just as chloroethane gives ethanol.'
Why it loses marksThe two C-Cl bonds are not equally reactive. In chlorobenzene the lone pair on the chlorine is delocalised into the ring, so the C-Cl bond has partial double bond character: it is shorter (about 0.170 nm) and stronger (about 400 kJ mol-1) than the corresponding bond in chloroethane (about 0.177 nm and about 340 kJ mol-1). The ring also repels an approaching nucleophile. Reflux conditions are nowhere near enough.
The answer that scoresChlorobenzene is unchanged by NaOH(aq) under reflux, and it gives no precipitate with AgNO3(aq) in ethanol, because no chloride ions are released. To hydrolyse it at all the conditions must be severe: aqueous sodium hydroxide at about 300 C under a high pressure in a sealed reactor, which gives phenol and sodium chloride. Chloroethane, by contrast, is hydrolysed at reflux to give ethanol and sodium chloride, because its C-Cl bond is a plain polar single bond that a nucleophile can break.
Revise this topicHalogen compounds
A student wrote · Halogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Chlorobenzene reacts with aqueous silver nitrate in ethanol to give a white precipitate of silver chloride, so the test confirms that chlorine is present.'
Why it loses marksThe silver nitrate test only works if the halogen is released as a halide ion, and chlorobenzene does not release its chlorine. There is no chloride ion in the mixture for the silver ions to precipitate, so the tube stays clear no matter how long it is warmed. The test identifies the halogen of a halogenoalkane, not of a halogenoarene.
The answer that scoresChlorobenzene gives no precipitate with AgNO3(aq) in ethanol, because the C-Cl bond is not broken under those conditions. Chloroethane gives a white precipitate of silver chloride within a few minutes of warming, because its C-Cl bond breaks and the chloride ion released is precipitated as AgCl. The difference is the delocalisation of the chlorine lone pair into the ring in chlorobenzene, which strengthens the C-Cl bond and stops the halide leaving.
Revise this topicHalogen compounds
A student wrote · Halogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Benzene does not react with chlorine because chlorine is not an electrophile, so aluminium chloride is added as a solvent to bring the two reactants together.'
Why it loses marksAluminium chloride is a catalyst, not a solvent, and it is added because a chlorine molecule is too weak an electrophile to attack the delocalised ring on its own. The aluminium chloride is a Lewis acid that accepts a lone pair, polarises the chlorine molecule and produces a species with Cl+ character, which the ring can then attack. Only a small amount is needed, because the catalyst is regenerated at the end.
The answer that scoresChlorine on its own will not substitute a benzene ring. Anhydrous AlCl3 acts as a halogen carrier: it accepts a chloride ion from the chlorine molecule, forming AlCl4- and leaving a strongly electrophilic species with Cl+ character: Cl2 + AlCl3 -> Cl+ + AlCl4-. The pi electrons of the ring attack that electrophile to give the arenium ion, a proton is lost, and the H+ released reacts with AlCl4- to give HCl and regenerate the AlCl3, so the catalyst is used over and over again.
Revise this topicHalogen compounds
A student wrote · Halogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Chlorine adds across one of the double bonds of the benzene ring to give a chlorinated cyclohexadiene, and the third double bond is left unchanged.'
Why it loses marksBenzene does not contain three separate double bonds. Its six pi electrons are delocalised over all six carbon atoms, which is why all six carbon-carbon bonds are the same length, about 0.139 nm. Adding chlorine across a ring bond would destroy that delocalisation and lose the ring about 150 kJ mol-1 of stabilisation energy, so addition does not happen under these conditions.
The answer that scoresThe reaction is substitution, not addition: chlorine replaces one hydrogen atom of the ring, and that hydrogen leaves as H+. The ring is restored to full aromaticity at the end of the reaction, so no stabilisation energy is lost. The product from benzene is chlorobenzene with hydrogen chloride as the by-product. Addition would only be possible with hydrogen under severe conditions, with a platinum or nickel catalyst.
Revise this topicHalogen compounds
A student wrote · Hydroxy compounds: acyl chlorides, phenol and phenolic compoundsA student wrote: 'Phenol is a weaker acid than ethanol because the benzene ring makes the molecule less polar, so the proton is held more tightly.'
Why it loses marksThe order is the wrong way round. Phenol is the stronger acid of the two, and polarity of the molecule is not the reason. The acid strength depends on how stable the anion left behind is.
The answer that scoresPhenol is the stronger acid. When it loses a proton the negative charge on the phenoxide ion is delocalised into the aromatic ring and spread onto the 2-, 4- and 6-positions, which stabilises the ion and pushes the dissociation further to the right. The ethoxide ion has no ring to delocalise the charge into and its electron-donating ethyl group makes the ion less stable, so ethanol is the weaker acid. Phenol has pKa about 10 and ethanol about 16, so phenol will dissolve in NaOH(aq) and ethanol will not.
Revise this topicHydroxy compounds: acyl chlorides, phenol and phenolic compounds
A student wrote · Hydroxy compounds: acyl chlorides, phenol and phenolic compoundsA student wrote: 'Phenol is brominated with bromine water only if iron(III) bromide is added as a catalyst and the apparatus is kept dry, because that is how benzene is brominated.'
Why it loses marksThe conditions for benzene are being carried over to phenol. The -OH group feeds electron density into the ring, so the ring of phenol is activated and no halogen carrier is needed; water does not interfere either.
The answer that scoresPhenol is brominated by Br2(aq) at room temperature with no catalyst and no need for dry conditions. The orange colour of the bromine water disappears and a white precipitate of 2,4,6-tribromophenol forms, with three hydrogens replaced. Benzene needs liquid bromine with a halogen carrier catalyst such as FeBr3 or AlCl3 and anhydrous conditions, and gives only bromobenzene, because its ring is not activated.
Revise this topicHydroxy compounds: acyl chlorides, phenol and phenolic compounds
A student wrote · Hydroxy compounds: acyl chlorides, phenol and phenolic compoundsA student wrote: 'Phenol reacts with sodium hydroxide solution to give sodium phenoxide and hydrogen gas, and the mixture fizzes.'
Why it loses marksHydrogen is not produced by a reaction with hydroxide. With NaOH(aq) this is an acid-base reaction and the second product is water; hydrogen is only given off when phenol reacts with sodium metal.
The answer that scoresWith NaOH(aq): C6H5OH + NaOH -> C6H5ONa + H2O, sodium phenoxide and water, with no gas evolved. With sodium metal: 2C6H5OH + 2Na -> 2C6H5ONa + H2, sodium phenoxide and hydrogen, and here the sodium does fizz as it reacts. The reaction with sodium metal is not a way of showing that phenol is acidic towards hydroxide: it works for ethanol as well.
Revise this topicHydroxy compounds: acyl chlorides, phenol and phenolic compounds
A student wrote · Hydroxy compounds: acyl chlorides, phenol and phenolic compoundsA student wrote: 'Phenylamine is converted into phenol by warming it with sodium nitrite and dilute hydrochloric acid.'
Why it loses marksWarming during the first step destroys the diazonium salt before it can be hydrolysed. The two stages have different temperatures and they must not be mixed up.
The answer that scoresThe nitrous acid, made from NaNO2 and dilute HCl, is added to phenylamine while the mixture is kept below 10 degrees C in an ice bath, which forms benzenediazonium chloride. Only when that salt has formed is the mixture warmed, and the warming is done with water, which replaces the -N2+ group with -OH: benzenediazonium chloride + water -> phenol + nitrogen + HCl.
Revise this topicHydroxy compounds: acyl chlorides, phenol and phenolic compounds
A student wrote · Carboxylic acids and derivatives (A Level)A student wrote: 'Chloroethanoic acid is a stronger acid than ethanoic acid because the chlorine atom is electron-donating and pushes electron density onto the carboxylate ion, which stabilises it.'
Why it loses marksThe direction of the effect is reversed. Chlorine is more electronegative than carbon, so it withdraws electron density along the sigma bonds; it does not donate it. Also, a group that pushed electron density towards the carboxylate ion would concentrate the negative charge and make the ion less stable, which would make the acid weaker.
The answer that scoresChlorine is electronegative, so it withdraws electron density inductively (-I effect) along the sigma bonds of the chain. The withdrawal disperses and stabilises the negative charge in the chloroethanoate ion, so the conjugate base is more stable, the O-H bond is weakened and ionisation is easier: the pKa falls from about 4.8 for ethanoic acid to about 2.9 for chloroethanoic acid, which means the acid is stronger.
Revise this topicCarboxylic acids and derivatives (A Level)
A student wrote · Carboxylic acids and derivatives (A Level)A student wrote: 'Ethanoyl chloride reacts with ethanol to give ethyl ethanoate if you add concentrated sulfuric acid as a catalyst, in the same way as ethanoic acid reacts with ethanol.'
Why it loses marksAn acyl chloride does not need an acid catalyst, and adding concentrated sulfuric acid would be pointless because the reaction already releases HCl. The student has described the esterification of a carboxylic acid, which is a different, much slower reaction needing a catalyst and prolonged heating.
The answer that scoresEthanoyl chloride reacts with ethanol rapidly at room temperature with no catalyst: CH3COCl + C2H5OH -> CH3COOC2H5 + HCl. The products are ethyl ethanoate and hydrogen chloride, and the HCl fumes are the evidence that the reaction has taken place. The slow, reversible esterification of ethanoic acid with ethanol, which does need concentrated sulfuric acid as a catalyst, is a different reaction.
Revise this topicCarboxylic acids and derivatives (A Level)
A student wrote · Carboxylic acids and derivatives (A Level)A student wrote: 'A carboxylic acid cannot be oxidised by anything, because the carbon of the carboxyl group is already in its highest oxidation state.'
Why it loses marksThis is true for most carboxylic acids, such as ethanoic acid, but not for all of them. Methanoic acid has a hydrogen atom on the carboxyl carbon, so it can be oxidised to carbon dioxide and water, and ethanedioic acid can be oxidised because the carbon-carbon bond joining its two carboxyl carbons can break to give two molecules of CO2.
The answer that scoresMethanoic acid, HCOOH, is oxidised to carbon dioxide and water by Tollens' reagent (silver mirror), Fehling's solution (red-brown precipitate of copper(I) oxide), acidified KMnO4 (purple decolourised) and acidified K2Cr2O7 (orange to green): HCOOH + [O] -> CO2 + H2O. Ethanedioic acid, HOOCCOOH, is oxidised by warm acidified KMnO4 to carbon dioxide and water. Ethanoic acid, CH3COOH, has a methyl group on the carboxyl carbon and is not oxidised by any of these reagents.
Revise this topicCarboxylic acids and derivatives (A Level)
A student wrote · Carboxylic acids and derivatives (A Level)A student wrote: 'Chlorobenzene and ethanoyl chloride are both chlorides of carbon, so both are hydrolysed rapidly when they are shaken with water at room temperature.'
Why it loses marksThe two C-Cl bonds are completely different. In ethanoyl chloride the carbon also carries a C=O group and is strongly electron-deficient, so water attacks it and the chloride leaves readily. In chlorobenzene the lone pair on the chlorine is delocalised into the ring, which gives the C-Cl bond partial double-bond character, makes it shorter and stronger, and removes the electron deficiency from the carbon.
The answer that scoresEthanoyl chloride is hydrolysed rapidly by cold water because its carbon is strongly delta-positive and chloride is a good leaving group, so the addition-elimination route is easy: CH3COCl + H2O -> CH3COOH + HCl. Chlorobenzene is not hydrolysed by water or dilute alkali at all, because the chlorine lone pair is delocalised into the pi system of the ring and the C-Cl bond is strengthened. Hydrolysing chlorobenzene needs very harsh conditions, such as concentrated sodium hydroxide solution at high temperature and pressure. The order of ease of hydrolysis is acyl chloride > alkyl chloride (chloroethane, needing hot aqueous alkali) > halogenoarene.
Revise this topicCarboxylic acids and derivatives (A Level)
A student wrote · Nitrogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Phenylamine is a stronger base than ammonia, because the phenyl group is a big group and pushes electron density onto the nitrogen.'
Why it loses marksThe phenyl group does the opposite. The nitrogen lone pair overlaps with the delocalised pi system of the ring and is spread around the ring, so it is not available on the nitrogen to accept a proton, and the sp2 ring carbon withdraws electron density inductively as well. The base strength of phenylamine is far lower than that of ammonia, not higher.
The answer that scoresPhenylamine is a much weaker base than ammonia. In phenylamine the lone pair on the nitrogen is delocalised into the pi system of the benzene ring, so it cannot be used to accept a proton, and Kb for phenylamine is only about 4 x 10^-10 mol dm-3. Ethylamine is stronger than ammonia because its alkyl group pushes electron density towards the nitrogen by a positive inductive effect, and the order of base strength is ethylamine > ammonia > phenylamine, roughly 4 x 10^-4 > 2 x 10^-5 > 4 x 10^-10 mol dm-3.
Revise this topicNitrogen compounds
A student wrote · Nitrogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Ethanamide must be a base, because the nitrogen atom has a lone pair, so it should be at least as strong a base as ethylamine.'
Why it loses marksHaving a lone pair is not enough; the mark is for where the lone pair is and whether it is available. In an amide the nitrogen is bonded to a carbonyl carbon and its lone pair is delocalised into the pi system of the C=O group, so it is not available to accept a proton and the amide is essentially neutral in water.
The answer that scoresIn an amine the lone pair sits on the nitrogen and is available, so ethylamine is a weak base with Kb about 4 x 10^-4 mol dm-3. In an amide the lone pair is delocalised over the O-C-N system, so ethanamide is essentially neutral and gives no alkaline solution. The same reasoning explains why the peptide bond that holds amino acids together is not basic: it is an amide bond.
Revise this topicNitrogen compounds
A student wrote · Nitrogen compoundsA student wrote: 'Bromoethane heated with excess concentrated ammonia in ethanol gives diethylamine, because the ethylamine formed attacks a second molecule of bromoethane.'
Why it loses marksThe second substitution does happen, but the reagent in excess decides the product. With an excess of ammonia, most collisions involving the halogenoalkane are with ammonia rather than with the small amount of amine that has been formed, so the primary amine is the main product. Diethylamine is made deliberately by using an excess of the primary amine instead.
The answer that scoresBromoethane with an excess of concentrated ammonia in ethanol in a sealed tube gives ethylamine as the main product: CH3CH2Br + 2NH3 -> CH3CH2NH2 + NH4Br. The excess ammonia removes the hydrogen bromide formed and keeps the concentration of the amine low, so further substitution is limited. A secondary amine such as diethylamine is made by heating a halogenoalkane with an excess of the primary amine in ethanol in a sealed tube: CH3CH2Br + CH3CH2NH2 -> (CH3CH2)2NH + HBr.
Revise this topicNitrogen compounds
A student wrote · Nitrogen compoundsA student wrote: 'In electrophoresis at pH 6 every amino acid moves towards the cathode, because all amino acids contain an -NH2 group and an -NH2 group is positive.'
Why it loses marksAn -NH2 group on its own is neutral, not positive. Whether an amino acid has a net charge at a given pH, and which sign it is, depends on how that pH compares with the amino acid's own isoelectric point, so different amino acids move in different directions or not at all.
The answer that scoresThe charge on an amino acid is decided by comparing the buffer pH with its isoelectric point. At pH 6, glutamic acid (isoelectric point about 3.2) is above its isoelectric point, so it carries a net negative charge and moves towards the anode; glycine (about 6.0) is at its isoelectric point, so it is mainly the zwitterion and does not move; and lysine (about 9.7) is below its isoelectric point, so it carries a net positive charge and moves towards the cathode.
Revise this topicNitrogen compounds
A student wrote · PolymerisationA student wrote: 'Poly(ethene) and nylon-6,6 are made by the same type of polymerisation, because in both cases the monomers join together into a long chain.'
Why it loses marksJoining up into a long chain is common to both types of polymerisation and tells you nothing. The test is what the monomers contain and whether a small molecule is lost: addition polymerisation needs a C=C double bond and loses nothing at all, while condensation polymerisation needs two functional groups on each monomer and loses a small molecule such as water or hydrogen chloride at every link.
The answer that scoresEthene has a C=C double bond and no second functional group, so poly(ethene) is made by addition polymerisation and every atom of the monomer ends up in the polymer. Hexane-1,6-diamine and hexanedioic acid each carry two functional groups, an amine and a carboxylic acid, so nylon-6,6 is made by condensation polymerisation, and one molecule of water is lost at each of the two links formed per repeat unit.
Revise this topicPolymerisation
A student wrote · PolymerisationA student wrote: 'The repeat unit of nylon-6,6 is -H2N-(CH2)6-NH2-HOOC-(CH2)4-COOH-, because those are the monomers that were used.'
Why it loses marksThat is the two monomers written out one after the other, not the repeat unit. A repeat unit is the fragment that is actually left after the small molecules have been eliminated, and it must be drawn with one free bond at each end so that the next unit can join on to it.
The answer that scoresHexane-1,6-diamine and hexanedioic acid condense with the loss of two molecules of water per repeat unit, so the repeat unit is -NH-(CH2)6-NH-CO-(CH2)4-CO-. Each -NH2 group has become an -NH- in an amide link and each -COOH group has become a -CO- in an amide link, and the two free bonds at the ends are where the neighbouring repeat units are joined.
Revise this topicPolymerisation
A student wrote · PolymerisationA student wrote: 'Poly(ethene) is biodegradable because it is made from ethene, which comes from a natural source, and all polymers can be broken down by bacteria.'
Why it loses marksPoly(ethene) is made from ethene obtained by cracking crude oil, and coming from a natural feedstock says nothing about whether a polymer can be attacked chemically. A poly(alkene) has a backbone of strong, non-polar C-C and C-H single bonds, with no polar link for water to hydrolyse and no group that an enzyme can attack, so it is chemically inert and persists for decades in the environment.
The answer that scoresPoly(ethene) is not biodegradable: its backbone has no polar link that hydrolysis can open and no group that an esterase or a protease can attack, so microorganisms cannot break the chains. A polyester such as PET is biodegradable because it contains ester links, which are hydrolysed by acid, by alkali and by esterase enzymes, and a polyamide such as nylon-6,6 is biodegradable because its amide links are hydrolysed in the same way.
Revise this topicPolymerisation
A student wrote · PolymerisationA student wrote: 'A photodegradable carrier bag disappears completely in sunlight, so it solves the problem of plastic waste.'
Why it loses marksLight breaks the polymer chains into shorter fragments, but it does not remove the material. Unless the fragments are themselves biodegradable, the plastic has simply been turned into small pieces, which are harder to collect and are easily eaten by animals.
The answer that scoresUltraviolet light is absorbed by the carbonyl groups built into the chain and the chain is broken at that point, so the plastic becomes brittle and fragments. That is only the first step: the fragments must then be hydrolysed and metabolised by microorganisms before the material is actually removed. A polymer is only fully degradable if the bonds in it can also be attacked by water or by enzymes.
Revise this topicPolymerisation
A student wrote · Advanced organic synthesisA student wrote: 'Heating methylbenzene with hot alkaline potassium manganate(VII) gives benzaldehyde, which can then be distilled out of the mixture.'
Why it loses marksThe side-chain oxidation in the syllabus is a complete oxidation, and its conditions are hot alkaline manganate(VII) followed by dilute acid. Every carbon of the side chain except the one joined to the ring is oxidised away, so the product is the benzoate ion and no distilling step is involved. An aldehyde is only an intermediate of an incomplete oxidation.
The answer that scoresHeat methylbenzene with hot alkaline potassium manganate(VII) to oxidise the side chain completely, then add dilute acid: the product is benzoic acid, C6H5COOH. Benzaldehyde and benzyl alcohol are the partially oxidised compounds you would get if the oxidation stopped early, which these conditions do not allow.
Revise this topicAdvanced organic synthesis
A student wrote · Advanced organic synthesisA student wrote: 'Nitrobenzene is heated with tin and concentrated hydrochloric acid, and the phenylamine is then distilled straight out of the mixture.'
Why it loses marksThe reduction is carried out in strongly acidic solution, so the nitrogen ends up protonated and the product is the phenylammonium ion, held in the aqueous layer as a salt. Distilling that acidic mixture gives nothing useful; the free amine has to be liberated first.
The answer that scoresHeat the nitrobenzene with tin and concentrated hydrochloric acid, cool the mixture, then add sodium hydroxide solution until it is alkaline. That liberates the free amine, phenylamine, and dissolves the tin salts. The phenylamine is then separated in a separating funnel or steam-distilled from the alkaline mixture, dried over a drying agent such as potassium hydroxide pellets, and distilled.
Revise this topicAdvanced organic synthesis
A student wrote · Advanced organic synthesisA student wrote: 'Phenylamine can be made from chlorobenzene by heating it with ammonia in ethanol under pressure, in the same way that propan-1-amine is made from 1-chloropropane.'
Why it loses marksA halogenoarene is not a halogenoalkane. In chlorobenzene the chlorine is joined to an sp2 ring carbon and a lone pair on the chlorine is partly delocalised into the ring, so the C-Cl bond is shorter and stronger, and the electron-rich ring repels the nucleophile. The nucleophilic substitution that works so well for a halogenoalkane does not take place at a useful rate.
The answer that scoresMake phenylamine from benzene in two steps: nitration with concentrated nitric acid and concentrated sulphuric acid at 25-60 C gives nitrobenzene, and heating nitrobenzene with tin and concentrated hydrochloric acid, followed by sodium hydroxide solution, reduces the nitro group to an amino group. Chlorobenzene is not a starting material for phenylamine, just as it is not a starting material for phenol.
Revise this topicAdvanced organic synthesis
A student wrote · Advanced organic synthesisA student wrote: 'Phenol is nitrated with dilute nitric acid at room temperature and the product is 4-nitrophenol only.'
Why it loses marksThe -OH group releases electron density into the ring and directs substitution into the 2-, 4- and 6-positions, so both the 2- and the 4-position are attacked and a mixture of two products is obtained. The 2- and 6-positions are equivalent by symmetry, which is why there are two distinct products rather than three.
The answer that scoresThe nitration of phenol with dilute nitric acid at room temperature gives a mixture of 2-nitrophenol and 4-nitrophenol, which can be separated. Benzene has no activating group, so its ring is less reactive and it needs concentrated nitric acid with concentrated sulphuric acid at 25-60 C; under those conditions it gives the single product nitrobenzene, because all six positions of benzene are equivalent.
Revise this topicAdvanced organic synthesis
A student wrote · Analytical techniques (A Level)A student wrote: 'In thin-layer chromatography the polar compound travels furthest up the plate, so it has the larger Rf value.'
Why it loses marksThis reverses the interaction with the stationary phase. In the usual system of an aluminium oxide plate with a non-polar solvent, the polar compound is held firmly by the polar stationary phase and also dissolves poorly in the mobile phase, so it moves the least distance. The student has remembered that molecules interact with the stationary phase without deciding which way that interaction pushes the spot.
The answer that scoresThe polar compound is held strongly by adsorption on the polar stationary phase and is only poorly soluble in the non-polar mobile phase, so it spends most of its time on the stationary phase and moves a short distance, giving the smaller Rf value. The non-polar compound dissolves readily in the mobile phase and is carried along quickly, so it has the larger Rf value. Explaining an Rf always needs both phases and the polarity of the compound.
Revise this topicAnalytical techniques (A Level)
A student wrote · Analytical techniques (A Level)A student wrote: 'Rf = distance moved by the solvent front / distance moved by the spot, so a value greater than 1 is possible.'
Why it loses marksThe definition has been turned upside down. Dividing the larger distance by the smaller one gives a number above 1, which cannot happen, because the spot is carried by the solvent and can never travel further than the solvent front.
The answer that scoresRf = distance moved by the spot from the baseline / distance moved by the solvent front from the same baseline. Both distances are measured from the baseline, and since the solvent front always travels at least as far as any spot, Rf is always between 0 and 1. A spot at the solvent front has Rf 1 and a spot that has not moved at all has Rf 0.
Revise this topicAnalytical techniques (A Level)
A student wrote · Analytical techniques (A Level)A student wrote: 'The tallest peak in the mass spectrum of compound Z is at m/e 43, so the relative molecular mass of Z is 43.'
Why it loses marksThe tallest peak is the base peak, which is the most stable cation produced by fragmentation, not the molecular ion. Reading Mr from the base peak gives a value that is too low, and it throws out the molecular formula that every later deduction depends on.
The answer that scoresThe relative molecular mass is read from the molecular ion, the peak at the highest m/e value apart from the small [M + 1] and [M + 2] isotope peaks that sit above it. In this question the molecular ion is at m/e 88, so Mr is 88, which fits C4H8O2. The peak at m/e 43 is a fragment: it is the CH3CO+ ion formed when the molecular ion loses a neutral ethoxy radical of mass 45, and 43 + 45 = 88 confirms that assignment.
Revise this topicAnalytical techniques (A Level)
A student wrote · Analytical techniques (A Level)A student wrote: 'The carbon-13 NMR spectrum of propanone shows three peaks, one for the C=O carbon and one for each of the two CH3 groups, because the two methyl groups are in different parts of the molecule.'
Why it loses marksThe two methyl groups are equivalent, not different. Both are attached to the same carbonyl carbon and the molecule can be rotated so that one methyl group takes the place of the other, so they are chemically identical and give one peak between them. The error is counting carbon atoms instead of counting carbon environments.
The answer that scoresPropanone, CH3COCH3, gives two peaks: one for the carbonyl carbon and one for the two equivalent methyl groups. The number of peaks in a carbon-13 NMR spectrum is the number of different carbon environments, and equivalent carbon atoms give a single peak, so symmetry must always be considered before the peaks are counted.
Revise this topicAnalytical techniques (A Level)