AS & A Level Marine Science · Area 1 · AS Level content

The open ocean, coral reefs, rocky and sandy shores, and mangroves

Five very different ecosystems, and the examiners test each one the same way: name the zone or the organism, then explain the physical condition that controls it. The open ocean is a question about light penetration and about the ocean-atmosphere exchange; the reef is a question about zooxanthellae, the polyp and the four reef shapes; the shores are questions about the tide. You lose marks by describing an organism without linking it to the abiotic factor, and by calling a coral a plant because it photosynthesises.

Not started

Syllabus coverage

  • Identify the world's five oceans as the Arctic, Atlantic, Pacific, Indian and Southern, and understand that they are inter-connected and encircle the Earth as a World Ocean
  • Identify zones found in the open ocean, limited to epipelagic, mesopelagic, bathypelagic, abyssopelagic and benthic zones, and describe these zones in terms of light penetration
  • Explain the importance of oceans and their interaction with the atmosphere as carbon sinks and as sources of oxygen
  • Explain the importance of oceans in temperature buffering and in global climate control, and identify regions of the oceans as polar, temperate or tropical
  • Describe the conditions required for tropical coral reef formation
  • Describe corals as animals in the phylum Cnidaria that form sessile colonies of polyps, often having a symbiotic relationship with zooxanthellae, and understand that hard and soft corals vary in the extent of calcification and population size of zooxanthellae
  • Describe and compare the four types of tropical coral reef - fringing, barrier, patch and atoll - in terms of their proximity to the coast and lagoon structure
  • Describe the structure of a typical hard coral polyp, limited to tentacle, nematocyst, mouth, stomach, calyx, theca and basal plate, and describe the functions of these structures
  • Explain how corals obtain their nutrition, including the mutualistic relationship between the polyps of some corals and zooxanthellae
  • Discuss the importance of coral reefs, including tourism, food source, coastal protection, medicines and biodiversity
  • Discuss the causes and effects of reef erosion, including pH change, temperature change, predation, physical damage and the presence of sediment, and discuss the use of artificial reefs
  • Identify the zones of a typical exposed rocky shore and describe the changing abiotic factors across them during one tidal cycle, and explain how biotic and abiotic factors interact to affect the distribution and abundance of organisms there
  • Explain, using named examples, the adaptations of organisms to living in the different rocky shore zones, and describe the sandy shore as an ecosystem with an unstable, shifting, porous substrate in which relatively few organisms can live
  • Describe the mangrove forest as a tidal ecosystem, outline the conditions required for its formation, explain the adaptations of Rhizophora mangle, and explain and discuss its ecological importance, its value to people and the threats it faces

Part of the AS & A Level Marine Science syllabus 9693.

Rocky shore zonationSplash zone to lower shoreOne organism per bandup the shoreSplash zoneSea slatersUpper shorePeriwinklesMiddle shoreBarnaclesLower shoreKelpstypical organismhigh waterlow wateralways submerged
Zonation on a rocky shore: different organisms occupy the splash, upper, middle and lower shore, each band set by how long it is exposed to air.

One World Ocean, and the zones defined by light

Although we name five oceans - the Arctic, Atlantic, Pacific, Indian and Southern - there is only one body of water. The boundaries between them are drawn by continents and by lines of latitude, not by anything in the water, and the Southern Ocean runs unbroken around Antarctica and joins the Atlantic, Pacific and Indian. The syllabus calls this single connected body the World Ocean, and the connection matters: heat, dissolved gases, nutrients, pollutants, plankton and larvae travel between the named oceans, so what happens in one is felt in the others.

The zones of the open ocean are defined by light penetration, because light is what decides whether a plant or an algal symbiont can photosynthesise there. The epipelagic zone runs from the surface down to about 200 m. It is the photic zone: light is strong enough for photosynthesis, so the phytoplankton live here and this is where nearly all of the ocean's primary production happens. The mesopelagic zone, from about 200 m to 1000 m, is the twilight or dysphotic zone. There is still enough light for animals to see by, but not enough for net photosynthesis, so no plant can grow there; the animals that live in it either feed on what sinks from above or swim up to the surface at night to feed.

Below that there is no sunlight at all. The bathypelagic zone runs from about 1000 m to 4000 m and the abyssopelagic zone from about 4000 m to 6000 m. Both are aphotic: the only light is the blue-green glow of bioluminescence made by the animals themselves, the water is close to freezing, the pressure is enormous and the food supply is a thin rain of dead plankton, faecal pellets and carcasses falling from the sunlit water far above. Because there is no light there is no photosynthesis, so the deep ocean has no plant production at all and its food web is built on material imported from the surface.

The benthic zone is different from the other four: it is not a layer of water but the sea floor itself, running from the shore to the bottom of the deepest trench. Because it underlies every depth, its light level depends on how deep it is - a coral reef's floor is brilliantly lit, while the abyssal plain is permanently dark with only a few centimetres of oxygenated sediment on top.

Regions of the ocean are also classified by latitude as polar, temperate or tropical, which decides water temperature, the amount of seasonal light and whether production peaks once a year, twice a year or stays fairly constant. Polar water is cold and close to freezing, with months of complete darkness and a short explosive summer bloom; temperate water has clear seasons and two blooms in spring and autumn; tropical water is warm all year, strongly stratified, and nutrient-poor.

Zone or regionDepth or positionLightConsequence for life
EpipelagicSurface to about 200 mLit - bright enough for photosynthesisPhytoplankton and reef algae can photosynthesise; almost all primary production and most fishing happens here
MesopelagicAbout 200 m to 1000 mTwilight - some light, too little for net photosynthesisNo plant growth; animals migrate to the surface at night to feed, and many have large eyes or light organs
BathypelagicAbout 1000 m to 4000 mNo sunlight - aphoticFood arrives only as falling debris; bioluminescence is the only light; low biomass and slow metabolism
AbyssopelagicAbout 4000 m to 6000 mNo sunlight - aphoticNear-freezing, very high pressure; sparse scavengers and deposit feeders on the sediment below
BenthicThe sea floor, from the shore to the deepest trenchDepends on depth: lit in the shallows, dark in the deep seaSoft sediment or rock; burrowing deposit feeders and attached filter feeders, not swimmers
Polar, temperate, tropicalLatitude bands of the surface oceanPolar has months of darkness; tropical is lit all yearPolar and temperate have seasonal blooms; tropical water is warm, stable and nutrient-poor
The benthic zone is not the deepest zone. It is the bottom, and it exists at every depth, so a question that asks for the zone of the sea floor is answered by 'benthic' whether the water above it is 5 m or 5000 m deep.

The ocean and the atmosphere: carbon sink, oxygen source, climate control

The ocean and the atmosphere are in constant exchange across the sea surface, and the syllabus asks for four consequences of that exchange. The first is the ocean as a carbon sink. Carbon dioxide dissolves from the air into the surface water, where it reacts to form bicarbonate and carbonate ions, and it is then taken up by phytoplankton during photosynthesis and built into the calcium carbonate shells and skeletons of corals, molluscs and coccolithophores. When those organisms die, some of the carbon in their shells and in the faecal pellets of the animals that eat them sinks into deep water, where it can stay out of contact with the atmosphere for centuries. The ocean therefore holds by far the largest store of carbon at the Earth's surface, and it has absorbed a large part of the carbon dioxide that humans have released by burning fossil fuels.

The second is the ocean as a source of oxygen. Photosynthesis by phytoplankton, seaweed and seagrasses in the epipelagic zone releases oxygen into the water, and some of it passes into the atmosphere across the surface. Marine phytoplankton are among the most important producers of atmospheric oxygen on the planet, which is easy to forget because they are invisible and drift with the current. The exchange works both ways, so the ocean is both a sink and a source depending on the gas, the temperature and the biology of the water.

The third is temperature buffering. Water has a very high specific heat capacity, which means it takes a great deal of energy to warm it and gives that heat back slowly as it cools. The ocean therefore absorbs solar energy in summer and in the tropics without its own temperature rising much, and releases heat in winter and at high latitudes, so coastlines have smaller temperature ranges than inland areas at the same latitude. This is why maritime climates are mild and continental climates are extreme, and why coastal towns rarely see the frost or the heat of the interior.

The fourth is global climate control. Surface currents and the slow thermohaline circulation carry warm water from the tropics towards the poles and cold water back along the deep sea floor, redistributing heat around the planet and shaping where rain falls. Evaporation from the warm surface supplies the water vapour that becomes rainfall, and the temperature of the sea surface controls how much of it evaporates. Change the circulation or the surface temperature and you change weather patterns thousands of kilometres inland, which is why the ocean is treated as part of the climate system rather than as a passive container of water.

  • Carbon sink: carbon dioxide dissolves in surface water, is used by phytoplankton and locked into calcium carbonate shells; sinking debris carries it to deep water for centuries.
  • Source of oxygen: photosynthesis by phytoplankton, seaweeds and seagrasses releases oxygen, some of which enters the atmosphere.
  • Temperature buffering: water's high specific heat capacity means the ocean absorbs and releases heat slowly, so coastal climates are milder than inland ones at the same latitude.
  • Global climate control: surface currents and the thermohaline circulation move heat from the tropics to the poles, and evaporation from the sea supplies water vapour for rainfall.
  • Cold water dissolves more carbon dioxide than warm water, so a warming ocean takes up less of it - the sink weakens as the water warms.
Say where the carbon goes. 'The ocean absorbs carbon dioxide' is a starting point; the marks are for dissolving to bicarbonate, use in photosynthesis, incorporation into calcium carbonate and transport to deep water by sinking.

Corals as animals, and the conditions a reef needs

A coral is an animal, not a plant and not a rock. Corals belong to the phylum Cnidaria, the same phylum as jellyfish and sea anemones, and the reef is built by colonies of tiny polyps. Each polyp is a hollow, sac-like animal with a ring of tentacles around a single opening, and each sits in a cup of calcium carbonate that it has secreted itself. The polyps are sessile - fixed in one place, unable to move - and they are joined to their neighbours so that a colony shares tissue and, in many species, a continuous skeleton. A reef is therefore the accumulated skeleton of thousands of generations of animals, with only the thin living layer on the outside alive.

The reason a tropical reef can exist in water that is almost devoid of nutrients is zooxanthellae, single-celled algae that live inside the tissues of the polyp. The partnership is a symbiosis, and because both partners benefit it is specifically a mutualism. This is why the word 'photosynthesis' appears in a topic about an animal: the polyp does not photosynthesise, its symbionts do.

The conditions required for reef formation follow directly from that partnership and from the polyp's own needs. Water must be warm, roughly 20 to 30 °C, which is why reefs are confined to the tropics and subtropics. It must be shallow, generally less than about 50 m and best above 20 m, because the zooxanthellae need light. It must be clear, because sediment and plankton in the water absorb light and because silt settles on the polyps and smothers them. It must be low in nutrients, because a nutrient-rich sea grows thick phytoplankton and filamentous algae that shade the coral and overgrow it - the clearest blue water is the best reef water. Salinity must be fully marine and stable, around 35, because corals cannot tolerate much dilution by fresh water, so reefs do not form off large river mouths. There must be hard substrate for the larvae to settle on, and moderate water movement to bring oxygen and plankton and to remove sediment without smashing the fragile branches.

FeatureHard coralSoft coral
ExampleStaghorn coral, AcroporaSea fan, Gorgonia
CalcificationHeavy: each polyp sits in a solid calcium carbonate cup and the colony builds a rigid skeleton that forms the reef frameworkSlight: the colony is supported mainly by flexible protein fibres with only small scattered skeletal pieces, so it bends in the current
ZooxanthellaeLarge populations; most of the colony's nutrition comes from the symbionts, which is why hard corals are restricted to bright shallow waterSmaller populations; soft corals rely more on capturing plankton from the current, so they can live a little deeper and in dimmer water
Contribution to the reefBuilds and cements the reef structure and gives it its three-dimensional shapeAdds few or no skeletal deposits; contributes cover and habitat rather than structure
Hard and soft coral differ in two examinable ways only: how much skeleton they calcify, and how many zooxanthellae they house. Link the second to the first - a coral that depends on its symbionts must live where the light reaches it.

The structure of a hard coral polyp and how it feeds

The syllabus limits the polyp to seven structures, and each one has a job you should be able to state in a phrase. The tentacles form a ring around the mouth and are the polyp's hands: they capture small animals from the water and push food towards the mouth. They are armed with nematocysts, which are stinging cells - each one contains a coiled thread with a barb and a dose of toxin that fires out on contact, paralysing or holding prey too small and too quick to be caught otherwise. The mouth is the only opening to the gut, so food goes in and waste comes out through the same hole.

Inside, the stomach (the gastrovascular cavity) digests the prey and distributes the nutrients around the colony, and it is also where the zooxanthellae live and where their products are released. The skeleton has three named parts. The calyx is the cup-shaped depression in the skeleton in which the polyp sits. The theca is the wall of that cup, the calcified side of the corallite that rises around the polyp and can be raised when the polyp retracts. The basal plate is the flat plate of calcium carbonate at the bottom of the cup, on which the polyp rests and with which it is cemented to the colony and the reef beneath.

Nutrition comes from two directions at once. By day the polyp lives on the products of its zooxanthellae: the algae photosynthesise inside the coral's tissues, using carbon dioxide and nutrients from the polyp's waste, and release sugars, glycerol and amino acids that can supply the great majority of the coral's energy. The polyp gives the algae a safe place inside its tissue, a supply of carbon dioxide and nitrogen and phosphorus from its waste, and a position in bright shallow water. By night many polyps extend their tentacles and feed as consumers, catching zooplankton and small animals with their nematocysts and digesting them in the stomach, which supplies the protein and phosphorus that the symbionts cannot provide in sufficient quantity. Corals also absorb some dissolved organic matter directly through the body surface. This is why a coral can survive a short period without feeding but not without light.

StructureFunction
TentacleRing of flexible extensions around the mouth that capture and manipulate prey and pass it to the mouth; can be retracted into the calyx
NematocystStinging cell in the tentacle that fires a coiled, barbed thread and injects toxin to paralyse or hold prey
MouthThe single opening to the gut; takes in food and expels undigested waste
StomachGastrovascular cavity that digests prey, distributes nutrients through the colony and houses the zooxanthellae
CalyxCup-shaped depression in the skeleton in which the polyp sits and into which it can retract
ThecaCalcified wall of the corallite forming the side of the calyx and protecting the polyp
Basal plateFlat plate of calcium carbonate at the base of the cup, supporting the polyp and cementing it to the colony and the reef
Two sources of food, one exam answer. A full-mark answer says the polyp is a consumer that catches zooplankton with nematocysts on its tentacles, and that it also receives carbohydrates from its zooxanthellae - then adds what each partner gives the other.

The four types of tropical coral reef

Reefs are classified by two things only: how far the reef is from the coast, and whether there is a lagoon between the reef and the land. Learn the four shapes as a progression, because they are usually described as stages of the same history - a reef growing up around a volcanic island as the island sinks or the sea level rises.

A fringing reef is attached directly to the shore, with no lagoon, and it is the commonest type on a tropical coast with a narrow shelf. A barrier reef lies further offshore and is separated from the land by a lagoon of shallow, sheltered water, often several kilometres wide and deep enough for boats; the Great Barrier Reef off Queensland is the largest example in the world. A patch reef is small and isolated, a mound of coral growing up from the floor of a lagoon or reef flat, with no connection to the shore and no lagoon of its own. An atoll is a ring of reef, often broken into channels, enclosing a central lagoon with no land inside it except low sand cays; atolls are found far out in the tropical ocean, classically on the submerged remains of a volcanic island, and the Maldives is built almost entirely of them. Note the lagoon question: fringing and patch reefs have none, barrier reefs and atolls do, and at an atoll the lagoon is in the middle of the reef, not between the reef and a continent.

Reef typeProximity to the coastLagoonOther features
Fringing reefAttached directly to the shore, with no water between reef and landNoneNarrow reef flat against the coast; the commonest type, and the most exposed to runoff from the land
Barrier reefOffshore, running roughly parallel to the coastYes - a wide, often deep lagoon separates the reef from the landThe largest reefs; the Great Barrier Reef is the classic example; a boat can pass between reef and shore
Patch reefIsolated mound, usually within a lagoon or on a reef flatNone of its ownSmall and scattered; grows up from a sandy or rubble floor rather than from the shore
AtollFar from any continent, in the open tropical oceanYes - a central lagoon enclosed by the reef ringA ring of reef, often with channels and low sand cays, formed on the remains of a subsided volcanic island; the Maldives
Fringing touches the shore, barrier is held off it by a lagoon, patch is a lone mound, atoll is a ring with the lagoon inside. If you can say those four clauses you can answer any comparison question on reef type.

Why reefs matter, how they erode, and what artificial reefs can do

The importance of coral reefs is easiest to remember as five headings from the syllabus. Biodiversity: although reefs cover a tiny fraction of the sea floor, they hold a very large share of marine species, because the complex three-dimensional skeleton provides an enormous number of niches, refuges and feeding surfaces. Food source: reef fish, crabs, lobsters, octopus, sea cucumbers and giant clams feed millions of people and support both local and commercial fisheries, and the reef is the nursery that stocks the surrounding sea. Coastal protection: the reef flat and the crest break wave energy offshore, so the shore behind it is sheltered from storms and the beach is not stripped away. Tourism: diving, snorkelling and glass-bottom boats bring income and employment to tropical countries, and they depend on a reef that is still alive and colourful. Medicines: reef organisms produce a wide range of chemical defences, and compounds derived from sponges, soft corals and other reef invertebrates have been investigated for and used in drugs, including antiviral and anticancer agents and painkillers.

Reef erosion means the loss of living coral and of reef structure, and the syllabus gives five causes. pH change - ocean acidification - lowers the concentration of carbonate ions in the water, so corals calcify more slowly and their skeletons begin to dissolve, which makes the whole reef framework weaker. Temperature change causes bleaching: above the coral's tolerance the polyp expels its zooxanthellae, so the colony turns white, loses most of its energy supply and starves if the heat lasts. Predation by the crown-of-thorns starfish, Acanthaster planci, which eats the living tissue and can strip a reef when its populations outbreak, and by parrotfish and other browsers, removes coral faster than it can regrow. Physical damage from tropical cyclones, boat anchors, divers, dragging fishing gear and destructive fishing breaks the branches and overturns the colonies. Sediment washed off cleared land or dumped from dredging settles on the polyps, blocks the light and forces the coral to spend energy cleaning itself, and the runoff carries nutrients that let algae overgrow the coral.

The effects run together: loss of live coral means loss of the three-dimensional structure, and with it the fish and invertebrates that depend on it, so biodiversity falls; the fishery and the tourism income fall with it; and because a dead reef no longer absorbs wave energy, the coast behind it erodes and storm damage on land increases. A bleached reef can recover if the water cools quickly and larvae arrive from elsewhere, but a reef that is repeatedly bleached, buried in silt or eaten by starfish shifts permanently to a covering of algae.

An artificial reef is a structure placed on the seabed to act as a hard substrate on which reef organisms can settle. Purpose-built concrete modules and specially designed units are used, as are limestone boulders and cleaned ships and other structures, and coral fragments are sometimes attached to them. The benefits are that they provide hard surface where the bottom is otherwise sand or mud, they create structure for fish and invertebrates, they can stabilise sediment, they can support dive tourism and they can be placed to take pressure off a damaged natural reef. The limitations are equally examinable: they do not fix the cause of the erosion, so a coral transplanted onto a module in water that is too warm or too turbid will also bleach or suffocate; they can attract fish and concentrate fishing effort on them; some materials leach pollutants or break down; and a structure placed in the wrong place can simply be buried or swept away.

Cause of reef erosionWhat happensEffect on the reef
pH change (acidification)More dissolved carbon dioxide lowers pH and the supply of carbonate ionsSlower calcification and some dissolution of existing skeleton; a weaker, more easily broken reef
Temperature changeWater warmer than the coral's tolerance for a sustained periodBleaching - zooxanthellae are expelled, the colony turns white and starves if the heat continues
PredationCrown-of-thorns starfish, parrotfish and other predators eat living coral tissueLive coral cover falls, especially in an outbreak; algae colonise the dead skeleton
Physical damageCyclones, anchors, divers, dragging gear and destructive fishing break and overturn coralBroken branches, overturned colonies and rubble that is slow to stabilise and recolonise
SedimentSoil from cleared land, dredging or coastal construction settles on the polyps and clouds the waterLight is blocked, polyps are smothered by silt, and nutrients in the runoff encourage algae to overgrow the coral
For a discuss question, take each cause and carry it through to a consequence for people. Bleaching is a biology fact until you add that the fish leave, the dive boats stop coming and the coast behind the reef is no longer protected.

The rocky shore: zones, the tide, and the shift from abiotic to biotic control

A rocky shore is divided into zones by how long each one is out of the water during the tidal cycle. At the top, the splash zone is wetted only by spray and by the highest spring tides, so it is damp rather than submerged. The upper shore is covered only at high tide, and on a neap tide may hardly be covered at all. The middle shore is covered and uncovered twice a day by every tide. The lower shore is exposed only briefly at low water, and the subtidal zone below it is permanently submerged. The pattern is not a tidy ladder of equal bands - the exact heights depend on the tidal range and on how exposed the shore is to waves - but the order never changes.

The abiotic factors change across those zones during a single tidal cycle, which is the point most answers miss. On the upper shore, low tide means desiccation: the organism loses water to the air, and the longer the emersion the more it loses. It also means a large temperature range, because rock in the sun heats far above water temperature while at night it can fall close to freezing, and salinity swings, because water evaporating from a pool concentrates the salt while rain dilutes it. Wave action is strongest low on the shore and on an exposed headland, and it brings oxygen and food but also threatens to tear organisms off the rock. Light is at its maximum when the rock is exposed, which is a problem for algae that would dry out and an opportunity for the ones that can tolerate it. In pools cut off by the tide, oxygen falls overnight as respiration continues without photosynthesis, and pH swings with it.

The classic examinable pattern is that abiotic factors control the upper shore and biotic factors control the lower shore. High up, only the organisms that can survive drying, heating and dilution live there at all, and their upper limit is set by physical tolerance rather than by their neighbours - the barnacles on the top of the shore are not there because they prefer it but because nothing else can hold that ground against the physical stress. Lower down, conditions are mild and stable, and space becomes the limiting resource: competition for rock surface between barnacles, mussels, algae and sponges, and predation by dog whelks, starfish, crabs and shore birds, decide who actually occupies the space. A predator or a dominant competitor can therefore set the lower limit of a species, while its upper limit is set by desiccation - which is why removing a predator experimentally allows its prey to spread downwards, and why the same species sits higher on a sheltered shore than on an exposed one.

The adaptations follow from the stresses, and the syllabus wants them with named organisms. Against desiccation, the limpet Patella vulgata has a conical shell that sheds water, a large muscular foot that clamps it down to seal in a film of water, and a homing behaviour that returns it to the same scar in the rock before each low tide; barnacles such as Semibalanus balanoides close calcareous plates over the body and are cemented in place; the wrack Fucus vesiculosus has a thick, mucilage-coated frond that resists drying, lies flat to shade itself at low tide, and uses air bladders to stand up towards the light when submerged. Against wave action the same limpet's low profile and clamped foot reduce drag, mussels anchor with byssus threads, kelp attaches with a holdfast rather than roots, and anemones such as Actinia equina withdraw their tentacles and contract into damp crevices. Mobile animals behave their way out of trouble instead: periwinkles seal the shell with an operculum, and crabs and small fish move down the shore or into pools as the tide falls.

  • Patella vulgata (limpet): conical shell, large muscular foot clamped to the rock, homing to a scar - seals in water and resists both drying and wave drag.
  • Semibalanus balanoides (barnacle): cemented to the rock, plates close over the body to retain water; feeds by filtering with feathery cirri when submerged.
  • Fucus vesiculosus (bladder wrack): leathery mucilage-covered frond that resists drying, air bladders for buoyancy, holdfast for attachment.
  • Nucella lapillus (dog whelk): drills through barnacle and mussel shells with its radula and a softening secretion; tolerates exposure by retreating into crevices.
  • Actinia equina (beadlet anemone): retracts its tentacles and contracts when exposed, lives in damp crevices and pools on the lower shore.
  • Laminaria (kelp): holdfast instead of roots, flexible stipe, restricted to the lower shore and subtidal where it is rarely exposed.
ZoneTidal positionMain abiotic stressTypical named organisms
Splash zoneWetted by spray and the highest spring tides onlySevere desiccation, salt spray, great temperature range, long emersionLichens such as Verrucaria, cyanobacteria, small periwinkles (Littorina saxatilis) in crevices
Upper shoreCovered only at high tideLong emersion, drying, heating, rain diluting poolsChthamalus barnacles, limpets (Patella vulgata), rough periwinkles
Middle shoreCovered and uncovered twice a dayAlternating submersion and exposure, wave action, competition for spaceSemibalanus balanoides, mussels (Mytilus edulis), dog whelk (Nucella lapillus), bladder wrack (Fucus vesiculosus)
Lower shoreExposed only briefly at low waterWave action, intense competition for space, predationSerrated wrack (Fucus serratus), sea anemones (Actinia equina), starfish, crabs, coralline algae
Subtidal zonePermanently submergedReduced light with depth, wave surge, predationKelp (Laminaria), kelp-forest fish and urchins, sponges and sea squirts
Upper limit = physical tolerance, lower limit = competition and predation. Name the organism, name the structure, then name the stress the structure defeats - a limpet's foot is worth nothing in an answer until it is trapping water against an hour of drying air.

The sandy shore: an unstable, porous substrate with low biodiversity

A sandy shore is an ecosystem built on a substrate that will not hold still. The substrate is unstable and shifting: waves and currents move the sand with every tide, so anything that cemented itself to the surface would be scoured away or buried. It is also porous, so water drains through it quickly, and that single property explains most of the biology. Coarse sand has large particles and large pore spaces, so it is highly permeable - water passes through fast, draining the beach at low tide and pulling oxygen down into the sediment, but also drying the surface layers. Fine sand and silt have small pore spaces and are much less permeable: water is held, the sediment stays waterlogged, and oxygen is used up by bacteria faster than it can be replaced, so the layer below the surface becomes anoxic. This is exactly what the practical investigation of particle size and permeability shows, and it is why the animals of fine sand live close to the surface or keep a connection to it, while those of coarse sand can live deeper.

Biodiversity is relatively low for several reasons that work together. There is no hard surface for attachment, so the whole community of seaweeds, barnacles, mussels and anemones that dominates a rocky shore is missing. The surface is abrasive and mobile, so delicate organisms are damaged. Water drains away at low tide, so the surface dries and heats and cools far more than rock does, and the variation in temperature and salinity through the tidal cycle is greater than on a rocky shore. Oxygen is limited below the surface in fine sediment, and food is thin, because the sand itself contains little organic matter compared with the silt of an estuary. Only organisms with a way of burrowing, or of moving with the water, can live there - and because so few species can do it, the ones that can are often present in very large numbers. Low species diversity therefore does not mean low biomass: a sandy beach can hold a great many lugworms and cockles of very few species.

Biodiversity is relatively low for reasons that work together. There is no hard surface for attachment, so the seaweeds, barnacles, mussels and anemones of a rocky shore are absent; the surface is abrasive and mobile, so delicate organisms are damaged; water drains away at low tide, so the surface dries, heats and cools and varies more in temperature and salinity than rock does; and below the surface of fine sediment oxygen is used up faster than it is replaced. Food is also thin, because sand holds little organic matter compared with estuarine silt. Only organisms that can burrow, or that keep a connection to the surface, can live there - and because so few species can, the ones that can are often present in very large numbers, so low diversity does not mean low biomass.

The adapted organisms are therefore all burrowers or rapid movers. The lugworm Arenicola marina lives in a permanent mucus-lined U-shaped burrow, swallows sand and passes the digested remains out as a coiled cast, and extends a muscular, eversible proboscis to the surface to feed, so it is protected from abrasion and drying and irrigates its own burrow. The cockle Cerastoderma edule pulls itself down with a muscular foot and keeps short siphons at the surface to filter feed. Razor shells such as Ensis have a smooth, streamlined shell and a powerful foot for rapid vertical burrowing, with long siphons that stay in contact with the surface. Burrowing amphipods and isopods swim in the swash and dig into wet sand between tides, and the heart urchin Echinocardium cordatum lives deep in the sand, kept in contact with the surface by a funnel and moved by its spines.

  • Unstable, shifting substrate: sand moves with every tide, scouring or burying anything attached at the surface.
  • Porous: water drains through quickly at low tide, so the surface dries and the sediment drains and refills with each tidal cycle.
  • Particle size controls permeability: coarse sand drains fast and holds oxygen; fine sand and silt drain slowly, stay waterlogged and become anoxic below the surface.
  • No hard substrate: seaweeds, barnacles and mussels cannot attach, so an entire group of organisms is absent.
  • Arenicola marina (lugworm): mucus-lined U-shaped burrow, eversible proboscis for surface feeding, sediment swallowed; casts mark its position.
  • Cerastoderma edule (cockle): muscular foot to burrow, short siphons to draw water in while buried, ribbed shell resists crushing.
  • Ensis (razor shell): smooth narrow shell and powerful foot for rapid vertical burrowing, long siphons kept at the surface.
  • Echinocardium cordatum (heart urchin): lives deep in the sand, in contact with the surface through a funnel, moved by its spines.
Low diversity, high abundance. A sandy beach can hold thousands of animals of five species and almost nothing else, because the substrate admits only burrowers - and that is the answer to any question about its biodiversity.

The mangrove forest: a tidal forest on muddy tropical coasts

A mangrove forest is a tidal ecosystem in the littoral zone of some tropical and subtropical coasts, dominated by salt-tolerant trees and shrubs growing in muddy sediment that is flooded and drained by every tide. It is not a single species but a community: the trees, the algae on their roots and in the mud, the crabs, snails, shrimps and fish that live among the roots, the birds that nest in the canopy and the plankton and juvenile fish in the creeks. The different tree species occupy different levels of the shore - species of Rhizophora, with their arching prop roots, usually nearest the water, and Avicennia species, with vertical pneumatophores pushing up through the mud, further back - so the forest is zoned by how much flooding and how little oxygen each species can tolerate.

The conditions required for a mangrove forest are a combination of climate and coast. The climate must be tropical or subtropical and frost-free, with water warm enough for the trees to grow all year, because mangroves cannot survive frost. The coast must be sheltered from strong wave action - estuaries, lagoons, deltas and leeward shores - because the seedlings cannot establish where waves scour the mud, and their roots cannot resist heavy surf. The sediment must be fine and muddy, so that it holds water and nutrients and the roots can penetrate it, and that mud is usually waterlogged and low in oxygen. There must be regular tidal flooding by salt water, to which the trees are adapted, together with a supply of fresh water and sediment from the land. Take away the shelter, the mud or the tidal water and the forest cannot form.

Rhizophora mangle, the red mangrove, shows three adaptations that the syllabus names. Its prop roots grow out from the trunk and lower branches and arch down into the mud, forming a tripod that braces the tree in a soft, unstable substrate where an ordinary root plate could not hold it upright; their surfaces carry lenticels, so oxygen from the air can be taken in and supplied to the roots, which is essential because the waterlogged mud contains very little. Salt exclusion happens at the root: the root membranes act as a filter that keeps most sodium and chloride ions out, so the tree can take up water from saline soil, and the small amount of salt that does get through is stored in older leaves that are then shed. Reproduction is viviparous: the seed germinates while it is still attached to the parent tree and grows into a long, cigar-shaped propagule, which eventually drops, floats, survives for weeks in salt water and then roots where it strands in the mud.

The ecological importance of the forest comes from the physical structure of the roots. They form a nursery: the tangle of roots and the muddy water beneath them provide refuge from larger predators, so juvenile fish, prawns, crabs and molluscs grow there before moving out to the reef or the open sea, which is why mangrove loss shows up as a fall in catches elsewhere. The roots also trap sediment: they slow the water moving through the forest, so particles settle out and are held, which stabilises the coastline and builds it up instead of letting it erode. In doing so the forest keeps sediment off the reefs and seagrass beds offshore, because sediment that would otherwise be carried out and smother corals or shade seagrasses is intercepted and held in the mangrove mud.

Its value to people runs along the same lines. The forest is coastal protection, because the roots and trunks absorb the energy of waves and storm surges and hold the shoreline together, which matters most where low-lying land behind it is densely populated. It is a food source, because the fish, prawns, crabs and molluscs reared among the roots are caught by coastal communities, and it supplies timber for construction and poles and fuel in the form of firewood and charcoal. It supports tourism, from boat trips and boardwalks to birdwatching, and it adds biodiversity that the surrounding mudflat or cleared pond does not have.

The threats are equally specific. Temperature change warms the water and raises sea level, so the trees are stressed and the shore they occupy may be drowned faster than they can move inland. Over-harvesting for timber and fuel removes the trees faster than they regenerate. Storm damage from cyclones strips canopy and breaks trunks, and a forest already weakened by other pressures recovers slowly. Change in coastal land use is the biggest of all: clearance for aquaculture ponds, agriculture, urban development, ports and tourist resorts removes the forest outright, and once the roots are gone the sediment that was held is released, the coast erodes and the silt is carried out towards the reef.

AdaptationStructureHow it worksProblem it solves
SupportProp roots growing from the trunk and lower branchesArch downwards into the mud to form a wide brace around the trunkUnstable, soft sediment in which a normal root system could not anchor the tree
Oxygen supplyLenticels on the prop roots and aerial root surfacesAllow air to enter the root tissue and reach the buried rootsWaterlogged mud with very low oxygen concentration
Salt exclusionRoot membranes acting as a filterKeep most sodium and chloride ions out so water can be absorbedSaline soil and tidal water that would otherwise dehydrate the tree
ReproductionViviparous seed developing into a propagule on the parent treeGerminates while attached, then drops, floats and disperses before rootingSeedlings cannot establish in soft mud or salt water, so the propagule is already large and buoyant
The mangrove is a coastal defence that pays for itself. The same roots that brace the tree against the tide also hold the shoreline, trap the sediment, shelter juvenile fish and keep silt off the reef - so clearing the forest costs the community its protection, its fishery and its tourism at once.

Key terms you must be able to define

Epipelagic zone
The surface layer of the open ocean, from the surface to about 200 m. It is the photic zone, with enough light for photosynthesis, so it contains the phytoplankton and almost all of the ocean's primary production.
Mesopelagic zone
The layer from about 200 m to 1000 m, the twilight or dysphotic zone. There is enough light for animals to see by but not enough for net photosynthesis, so no plants grow there and animals feed on what sinks from above or migrate to the surface at night.
Bathypelagic zone
The aphotic layer from about 1000 m to 4000 m, with no sunlight at all. Food arrives only as falling debris, the only light is bioluminescence, and biomass is low.
Abyssopelagic zone
The aphotic layer from about 4000 m to 6000 m, near freezing and under very high pressure, with sparse scavengers and deposit feeders.
Benthic zone
The sea floor itself, from the shore to the bottom of the deepest trench. It is not a depth band: it underlies every other zone, so its light level depends on the depth of water above it.
Zooxanthellae
Single-celled algae that live inside the tissues of reef-building corals. They photosynthesise and pass sugars, glycerol and amino acids to the polyp, and receive carbon dioxide, nutrients from its waste and a protected, well-lit position in return.
Nematocyst
The stinging cell of a cnidarian, found in the tentacles of a coral polyp. On contact it fires a coiled, barbed thread that injects toxin, paralysing or holding small prey.
Calyx and theca
The calyx is the cup-shaped depression in the coral skeleton in which the polyp sits and into which it can retract. The theca is the calcified wall forming the side of that cup.
Fringing reef
A reef attached directly to the shore with no lagoon between reef and land. It is the commonest type of tropical reef and the most exposed to runoff from the land.
Barrier reef
A reef lying offshore and roughly parallel to the coast, separated from the land by a wide, often deep lagoon - for example the Great Barrier Reef off Queensland.
Atoll
A ring of reef enclosing a central lagoon, far out in the tropical ocean and typically formed on the submerged remains of a volcanic island; the Maldives is built almost entirely of them.
Desiccation
Drying out. It is the main abiotic stress on the upper shore, because organisms there are exposed to air for most of the tidal cycle, and it sets the upper limit of most rocky shore species.
Prop root
An aerial root that grows out from the trunk or lower branches of the red mangrove, Rhizophora mangle, arching down into the mud. It braces the tree in soft, unstable sediment and has lenticels for gas exchange in waterlogged, low-oxygen soil.
Propagule
The long, cigar-shaped seedling of a mangrove, produced by viviparous reproduction: the seed germinates while still attached to the parent tree, then drops, floats and disperses before rooting in the mud.

Applied to the sea

9693 marks the named marine example and the data in front of you. These show how to move from a definition to a worked marine case, then you do the same with the examples your teacher gives you.

Reef types: the Great Barrier Reef, Queensland

The Great Barrier Reef is the largest barrier reef system in the world, running roughly parallel to the Queensland coast and separated from it by a wide lagoon, so it shows the defining feature of a barrier reef - you can sail between the reef and the land. It also contains the other types within it: fringing reefs against the islands and the mainland, and patch reefs growing up from the floor of the lagoon. It supports a very high biodiversity of corals, fish and invertebrates, underpins a large dive and snorkelling industry, and shelters the Queensland coast from swell. Mass bleaching has affected parts of it in several recent warm years, and runoff of sediment and nutrients from cleared and farmed catchments is the other main pressure, which makes it the best single example for reef importance, reef erosion and reef type at once.

Artificial reefs: the ex-USS Oriskany, Florida

The aircraft carrier Oriskany was cleaned of pollutants and sunk in the Gulf of Mexico off Pensacola, Florida, in 2006 to create an artificial reef. It provides a large area of hard substrate in water that was otherwise soft sediment, and it has been colonised by corals, sponges, encrusting organisms and fish, becoming a well-known dive site and a fishing area. It illustrates both sides of the syllabus point: an artificial structure can create reef habitat where none existed and can support tourism, but it does not change water temperature, pH or sediment input, so it cannot rescue a natural reef that is being eroded by those causes. The same argument applies to concrete reef modules and to coral fragments transplanted onto them.

Rocky shore zonation: barnacles, limpets and wracks on an exposed shore

On an exposed rocky shore in southwest England the zones are visible in a few metres of vertical height. Chthamalus barnacles and small periwinkles occupy cracks high on the upper shore, where only the highest tides reach; Semibalanus balanoides, limpets and the dog whelk Nucella lapillus dominate the middle shore, with bladder wrack in the wetter patches; serrated wrack, sea anemones and coralline algae take the lower shore; and kelp begins in the subtidal. The pattern is the syllabus in one place: desiccation sets the upper limit of each species, competition for space and predation by Nucella and starfish set the lower limit, and the whole arrangement shifts up the shore where the rock is sheltered from waves.

Sandy shore: lugworms, cockles and razor shells on a North Sea beach

On a wave-washed sandy beach, the visible evidence of the community is a field of coiled lugworm casts and the small keyhole depressions of cockle siphons. Arenicola marina lives in a mucus-lined burrow and swallows sand, Cerastoderma edule filters from just below the surface with its siphons, and Ensis razor shells burrow vertically at speed when the sand is disturbed. This is a community of very few species but very large numbers of individuals, and every one of its members is a burrower - which is the direct consequence of an unstable, porous substrate with no hard surface to attach to.

Mangroves: Rhizophora mangle in the Caribbean, and the Sundarbans

On sheltered muddy tropical coasts, Rhizophora mangle shows all three adaptations in one tree: a cage of prop roots arching into the mud to brace it against the tide and to take oxygen through lenticels, root membranes that exclude salt so the tree can take up water from saline soil, and viviparous reproduction in which a long propagule develops on the parent tree and then drops to float and root. Mangrove forests of this kind fringe large areas of the Caribbean and Florida, acting as a nursery for reef fish and trapping sediment before it reaches the reef. The Sundarbans, the mangrove forest across the Ganges-Brahmaputra delta in Bangladesh and India, shows the human value of the same ecosystem: it absorbs the energy of cyclone surges and protects the densely populated low-lying land behind it, and it is harvested for timber and fuel and cleared for ponds and farmland - the trade-off the syllabus asks you to discuss.

Flashcards

Click a card to flip it. Mark honestly — the tracker uses this.

Q1Name the world's five oceans and explain what the World Ocean means.
Arctic, Atlantic, Pacific, Indian and Southern. They are not separate bodies of water - they are joined into one continuous World Ocean that encircles the Earth, so heat, dissolved gases, nutrients, pollutants and larvae move between them. Their boundaries are drawn by continents and lines of latitude, not by any barrier in the water.
Q2Name the open ocean zones in order and state the light conditions in each.
Epipelagic (surface to about 200 m): lit, enough for photosynthesis, so it is the photic zone and holds almost all primary production. Mesopelagic (about 200-1000 m): twilight, enough light to see by but not for net photosynthesis. Bathypelagic (about 1000-4000 m): aphotic, no sunlight. Abyssopelagic (about 4000-6000 m): aphotic, near freezing, very high pressure. Benthic: the sea floor at every depth, so its light depends on the depth of water above it.
Q3Give the four roles of the ocean in its interaction with the atmosphere.
Carbon sink: carbon dioxide dissolves and forms bicarbonate, is used by phytoplankton and locked into calcium carbonate shells, and sinking debris carries the carbon to deep water for centuries. Source of oxygen: photosynthesis by phytoplankton, seaweeds and seagrasses releases oxygen, some of which enters the atmosphere. Temperature buffering: water's high specific heat capacity means the ocean absorbs and releases heat slowly, so coastal climates are milder. Global climate control: surface currents and the thermohaline circulation move heat from the tropics to the poles, and evaporation supplies water vapour for rainfall.
Q4State the conditions required for tropical coral reef formation.
Warm water, about 20-30 °C; shallow water, generally less than 50 m, so light reaches the zooxanthellae; clear water with little suspended sediment; water low in nutrients, so algae do not overgrow the coral or cloud the water; stable, fully marine salinity around 35, so not off large river mouths; hard substrate for the larvae to settle on; moderate water movement to supply oxygen and remove sediment.
Q5What kind of animal is a coral, and how do hard and soft corals differ?
Corals are animals in the phylum Cnidaria, living as sessile colonies of polyps, often in symbiosis with zooxanthellae. Hard corals, such as staghorn (Acropora), calcify heavily - each polyp sits in a calcium carbonate cup and the colony builds the reef framework - and they house large populations of zooxanthellae. Soft corals, such as the sea fan Gorgonia, calcify only slightly, are supported by flexible protein fibres, have smaller zooxanthellae populations and rely more on capturing plankton, so they can live in dimmer water.
Q6Name the seven structures of a hard coral polyp and give the function of each.
Tentacle - captures and handles prey. Nematocyst - stinging cell in the tentacle that fires a barbed thread and injects toxin. Mouth - the single opening to the gut. Stomach - gastrovascular cavity that digests prey, distributes nutrients and houses the zooxanthellae. Calyx - the cup in the skeleton in which the polyp sits. Theca - the calcified wall forming the side of the cup. Basal plate - the plate at the base that supports the polyp and cements it to the colony.
Q7Explain how a coral polyp gets its nutrition.
Two ways. From its zooxanthellae, which photosynthesise inside its tissues and release sugars, glycerol and amino acids, supplying most of its energy; the polyp gives them carbon dioxide, nutrients from its waste and a protected, sunlit place. And by feeding as a consumer: at night the polyp extends its tentacles, fires nematocysts to catch zooplankton, and digests them in the stomach, supplying the protein and phosphorus the symbionts cannot provide. Corals can also absorb some dissolved organic matter.
Q8Compare the four types of tropical coral reef.
Fringing: attached directly to the shore, no lagoon. Barrier: offshore and parallel to the coast, separated from the land by a wide, often deep lagoon (Great Barrier Reef). Patch: a small isolated mound growing from the floor of a lagoon or reef flat, with no connection to the shore and no lagoon of its own. Atoll: a ring of reef enclosing a central lagoon, far out in the tropical ocean, typically formed on a subsided volcanic island (the Maldives).
Q9Give the five main causes of reef erosion and their effects.
pH change: lower pH and fewer carbonate ions, so calcification slows and skeleton dissolves. Temperature change: bleaching, as the polyp expels its zooxanthellae, loses its colour and starves. Predation: crown-of-thorns starfish (Acanthaster planci), parrotfish and other browsers remove living tissue. Physical damage: cyclones, anchors, divers and destructive fishing break and overturn coral. Sediment: silt smothers polyps and blocks light, and nutrients in runoff let algae overgrow the reef.
Q10Name the rocky shore zones, the main stress in each, and two named adaptations to it.
Splash zone (wetted by spray and the highest spring tides only): severe desiccation, salt spray, wide temperature range - lichens and cyanobacteria, small periwinkles in crevices. Upper shore (covered only at high tide): long emersion and drying - Chthamalus barnacles, limpets, rough periwinkles. Middle shore (covered twice a day): alternating submersion and exposure, competition for space - Semibalanus balanoides, mussels, dog whelk Nucella lapillus, bladder wrack. Lower shore (exposed only briefly): wave action, competition and predation - serrated wrack, anemones, starfish. Subtidal: permanently submerged, light falls with depth - kelp. Adaptations: Patella vulgata clamps its shell down with a muscular foot to trap water and resists wave drag with its low conical profile; Fucus vesiculosus has a leathery mucilage-coated frond, air bladders and a holdfast; barnacles close their plates over the body and are cemented to the rock.
Q11Why does a sandy shore have low biodiversity, and how do its organisms live there?
The substrate is unstable, shifting and porous, so nothing can attach, the surface dries and heats at low tide, temperature and salinity vary more than on rock, and fine sediment is oxygen-poor below the surface. Coarse sand is more permeable and better oxygenated than fine sand - the point of the particle size and permeability practical. The organisms burrow: Arenicola marina in a mucus-lined U-shaped burrow feeding with an eversible proboscis; Cerastoderma edule with a muscular foot and short siphons; Ensis razor shells burrowing rapidly with a powerful foot and long siphons.
Q12State the conditions for mangrove formation and the adaptations of Rhizophora mangle.
Conditions: tropical or subtropical, frost-free coasts with water above about 20 °C; sheltered, low wave energy shores such as estuaries, lagoons and deltas; fine muddy sediment that is waterlogged and low in oxygen; and regular tidal flooding by salt water with some freshwater and sediment input. Adaptations of the red mangrove: prop roots for stability in soft mud and for oxygen uptake through lenticels; salt exclusion at the root membranes, with any salt stored in older leaves that are shed; viviparous reproduction, the seed germinating on the parent tree into a propagule that drops, floats and disperses before rooting.
0 of 12 marked as known

Exam-style questions

8 questions, 29 marks. Write your answer, then reveal the mark scheme and tick each point you actually made. Answering honestly here is what makes the rest of the site useful.

StateAO11 mark
State the name of the open ocean zone in which there is enough light for photosynthesis to take place.

Mark scheme — tick each point you actually made

Examiner tip: One mark, one zone. The mesopelagic zone is dim but does not support net photosynthesis, and the benthic zone is a depth-independent answer to a different question.
DescribeAO12 marks
Describe two conditions, other than temperature, that are required for the formation of a tropical coral reef.

Mark scheme — tick each point you actually made

Examiner tip: Any two of shallow water, clarity, low nutrients, hard substrate, stable salinity around 35 and moderate water movement score, but each needs the reason as well as the condition. 'Warm water' is excluded by the question.
ExplainAO23 marks
Explain how the mutualistic relationship between a coral polyp and its zooxanthellae benefits both partners.

Mark scheme — tick each point you actually made

Examiner tip: Give the benefit in both directions explicitly. Saying only what the coral gets describes commensalism, not mutualism, and loses the third mark.
ExplainAO24 marks
Explain how the ocean interacts with the atmosphere to act as a carbon sink and as a source of oxygen.

Mark scheme — tick each point you actually made

Examiner tip: Both roles need a mechanism, not just a label. The fourth mark is for recognising the exchange works in both directions and that the sink weakens as the water warms.
ExplainAO24 marks
Explain how the relative importance of abiotic and biotic factors changes between the upper shore and the lower shore of an exposed rocky shore.

Mark scheme — tick each point you actually made

Examiner tip: Answer with the general rule and then support it: upper limit set by physical tolerance, lower limit set by competition and predation. An answer that describes the zones without saying which type of factor controls which limit scores about half.
ExplainAO24 marks
Explain how the abiotic and biotic features of a sandy shore lead to a relatively low biodiversity.

Mark scheme — tick each point you actually made

Examiner tip: The marks are for the mechanism behind each feature, not for a list. Say why an unstable, porous, oxygen-poor, abrasive substrate excludes species, and finish with the idea of low diversity but high abundance.
DiscussAO35 marks
Discuss the causes and effects of coral reef erosion.

Mark scheme — tick each point you actually made

Examiner tip: Use the five causes in the syllabus and then do the effects properly - biodiversity, fisheries, tourism and coastal protection. A cause list with no consequence for people cannot reach the top of the band.
DiscussAO36 marks
Discuss the importance of mangrove forests to coastal communities and the threats that they face.

Mark scheme — tick each point you actually made

Examiner tip: This is a discuss question, so both halves are needed and the last mark is for a judgement. Use the syllabus headings - tourism, food source, coastal protection, timber, fuel source, biodiversity - then the four threats, and finish by weighing the short-term gain against the long-term loss.

Exam technique for this topic

  • For the open ocean, link every zone to light and then to what that means for life. Epipelagic is lit, so it photosynthesises; mesopelagic is too dim for net photosynthesis, so its animals feed on what falls or migrate; bathypelagic and abyssopelagic are aphotic, so food arrives only as debris. A list of depths with no consequence scores little.
  • When a question asks for the ocean's interaction with the atmosphere, name the four roles separately - carbon sink, oxygen source, temperature buffering, global climate control - and give the mechanism for each. 'The ocean controls climate' is not a point; 'water has a high specific heat capacity, so the ocean absorbs heat slowly and coastal climates are milder' is.
  • For a coral polyp or reef erosion question, keep the direction of the symbiosis clear. Zooxanthellae photosynthesise and give the polyp carbohydrate; the polyp gives the algae carbon dioxide, nutrients from its waste and a protected, sunlit position. Never write that the coral photosynthesises.
  • On the shores, always convert a description of the tide into the abiotic stress it causes - emersion means desiccation, sun on wet rock means a temperature rise, evaporation from a pool means rising salinity, drying sediment means falling oxygen. Then attach each named organism's structure to the stress it defeats.
  • For reef types, answer with the two variables the syllabus names: proximity to the coast and lagoon structure. Fringing is attached with no lagoon, barrier is offshore behind a lagoon, patch is an isolated mound, atoll is a ring with the lagoon inside it. One sentence per type is enough if each clause is correct.

Why students lose marks here

A student wroteA student wrote: 'Corals are plants because they contain zooxanthellae and carry out photosynthesis, and the reef is a rock formed by the coral.'
Why it loses marksThe coral animal does not photosynthesise - its symbionts do. Corals are animals in the phylum Cnidaria, and the reef is a skeleton secreted by the polyps, not a rock. The error loses marks both for classification and for nutrition, and it usually drags the polyp structure answer down with it.
The answer that scoresCorals are animals in the phylum Cnidaria that live as sessile colonies of polyps. Each polyp has tentacles with nematocysts, a mouth, and a stomach, and it is a consumer that captures zooplankton. Many reef-building corals also live in a mutualistic symbiosis with zooxanthellae, single-celled algae inside their tissues; the algae photosynthesise and supply the polyp with sugars, glycerol and amino acids, while the polyp supplies carbon dioxide, nutrients from its waste and a protected position in bright shallow water. The polyp secretes a calcium carbonate skeleton, and the reef is the accumulated skeleton of many generations of polyps, which is why a reef is a biological structure rather than a rock.
A student wroteA student wrote: 'Coral reefs need warm, shallow, nutrient-rich water because the corals need plenty of nutrients to grow.'
Why it loses marksWarm and shallow are right, but nutrient-rich is the opposite of the requirement. High nutrient concentrations favour phytoplankton and filamentous algae, which cloud the water, block the light and overgrow the coral. Reef water is famously clear and nutrient-poor precisely because that is what lets the zooxanthellae receive light.
The answer that scoresReef-building corals need warm water of about 20 to 30 °C, shallow water generally less than 50 m deep, clear water with little suspended sediment so that light reaches the zooxanthellae, and water that is low in nutrients, because nutrient enrichment encourages algae to grow over the coral and cloud the water. Salinity must be fully marine and stable at around 35, so reefs do not form off large river mouths, and there must be hard substrate for the larvae to settle on and moderate water movement to supply oxygen and remove sediment. The requirement for low nutrients is why reefs are found in clear tropical seas rather than in turbid coastal water.
A student wroteA student wrote: 'The benthic zone is the deepest part of the ocean, below the abyssopelagic zone, where no light reaches.'
Why it loses marksThe benthic zone is not a depth band at all. It is the sea floor, and it exists under the shore, under the epipelagic zone and under the deepest water alike. Treating it as the deepest layer puts it in the wrong order and makes it impossible to explain why a coral reef floor is brightly lit.
The answer that scoresThe benthic zone is the sea floor itself, from the shore down to the bottom of the deepest trench, so it underlies all of the water-column zones rather than lying beneath them. Its light level depends on the depth of water above it: the benthic zone under a shallow reef is brightly lit and covered in algae and corals, while the benthic zone on the abyssal plain is permanently dark and its animals depend on organic debris settling from above. The deepest water-column zone is the abyssopelagic, from about 4000 m to 6000 m, which is aphotic, near freezing and under very high pressure.
A student wroteA student wrote: 'Sandy shores have a low biodiversity because there is not enough food, and the animals there are just the ones that have not been eaten.'
Why it loses marksFood is not the limiting factor in the way this answer implies, and the second half is not a mechanism at all. The low diversity follows from the physical nature of the substrate - unstable, porous, no hard surface for attachment, greater temperature and salinity variation, and low oxygen below the surface in fine sand.
The answer that scoresSandy shores have a relatively low biodiversity because the substrate is unstable and shifting, so nothing can attach to it and the whole community of seaweeds, barnacles, mussels and anemones found on rocky shores is absent. The sediment is porous, so water drains away at low tide and the surface dries, heats and cools, and the variation in temperature and salinity through the tidal cycle is greater than on rock. Below the surface of fine sand the sediment is waterlogged and oxygen-poor, and the abrasive, moving sand damages delicate organisms. Only animals that can burrow, or that keep a connection to the surface with siphons, can live there, so the number of species is small - although the individuals of those few species can be very numerous.
A student wroteA student wrote: 'Mangroves get rid of salt by excreting it from their prop roots, which also absorb oxygen from the air to help the tree grow faster.'
Why it loses marksThe roots exclude salt rather than excrete it, and the point of the aerial roots is not faster growth. Prop roots give mechanical support in soft, unstable mud, and their lenticels allow gas exchange because the sediment they grow in is waterlogged and low in oxygen.
The answer that scoresRhizophora mangle has prop roots that grow out from the trunk and branches and arch down into the mud. They brace the tree in soft, shifting sediment where an ordinary root system could not hold it upright, and they carry lenticels so that oxygen can be taken in from the air and supplied to the roots below, which is necessary because the waterlogged mud is low in oxygen. Salt is excluded at the root, where the membranes act as a filter and keep most sodium and chloride ions out so that the tree can absorb water from saline soil, and any salt that does enter is stored in older leaves that are then shed. Reproduction is viviparous: the seed germinates on the parent tree into a long propagule, which drops, floats, disperses and then roots in the mud.